ב"ה
Thursday, 6 Iyyar, 5786
  |  April 23, 2026

The Breathwork Program That Crown Heights Rabbonim Approved

Amid general concern, members of the Crown Heights Beis Din approved one specific breathwork program of the Neshamos organization facilitated by Rabbi Yehoshua Kaganoff. Full Story

New Tools Make Moshiach Learning More Accessible Than Ever

Next Story »

Stay-at-Home Moms: Don’t Stay at Home!

42 Comments
oldest
newest most voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Tim C
January 22, 2026 2:20 pm

I wish there are some activists out there that can be against this mishagas!

Moshich
Reply to  Tim C
January 22, 2026 2:41 pm

You mean to say that you know better than the רבנים

Kosher nosh
Reply to  Moshich
January 22, 2026 6:36 pm

Just because nosh has a hechsher doesn’t mean it is good for you

hechsher
Reply to  Kosher nosh
January 23, 2026 12:08 am

and just because an apple doesn’t have a hechsher doesn’t mean it’s not kosher or not good for you. delegating responsibility completely to packaged hechsher is also not a good thing. anyone remember when there was no such thing as hechsherim on most things? And yet generations of chassidim lived….

Date on English letter doesn't match up
January 22, 2026 2:24 pm

11th of Marcheshvan 5786 would be 11/02/2025, not 11/03/2026

Moshich
Reply to  Date on English letter doesn't match up
January 22, 2026 2:40 pm

Look at Hebrew letter
It’s dated יא תשרי תשפו
From this year

which rabbi is that
January 22, 2026 3:06 pm

the photo

The Commenter
Reply to  which rabbi is that
January 22, 2026 4:21 pm

In the subject line, the “which” should have a capital W and a question mark, and in “the photo”, there should also be a capital and a period.

What's your point.
Reply to  The Commenter
January 22, 2026 7:18 pm

Thanks for adding nothing to the discussion.

Incredible life saving work
January 22, 2026 3:16 pm

Thank you! May Hashem bentch you with continued success!!

Here we go again r'l
January 22, 2026 3:28 pm

You can dress this up in new clothing, even the most tznius clothing but it is still the same chazor. It’s important to remember that this is a ‘profitable business’ masquerading as concerned healer. Sadly those who get caught up in these ‘scams’ are not helped in the long run and even worse, become more distressed when they realize they were fooled. This smacks of “call of the shofar’ just different players with different fancy terms. What happened to us? When did this cult like healing centers become acceptable? Poor Rabbi Hecht, these keep popping up like a virus. He… Read more »

Do doctors dress up and charge?
Reply to  Here we go again r'l
January 22, 2026 8:05 pm

Title says it all

Grateful to the Neshamos Fitness Center for everyt
January 22, 2026 3:43 pm

As a frum Lubavitcher who needed – and needs- healing, I want to express my sincere and deep appreciation to the Neshamos Emotional Fitness Center. While talk therapy has helped me, I knew it wasn’t enough. I needed a deeper modality that would really be able to release and heal what my body and subconscious was holding onto. But I was faced with a problem. How could I really know if the other modalities are in line with Torah values? I’ve heard about people who were helped. Truly helped. But the risk of getting involved in something that isn’t Torah… Read more »

Confused
January 22, 2026 3:44 pm

I don’t get it, what is a “modality”? is it therapy? Group therapy? meditation? Hypnosis? Why not call it what it is?

So many words, so little explanation
January 22, 2026 4:18 pm

What modalities? Are they proven? Peer reviewed? You write its NOT therapy or psychiatrics care, do you make sure your participants are getting REAL care they need?

Work
January 22, 2026 4:39 pm

The Rabbanim will probably look into his work again.

B"H for Neshamos.org
January 22, 2026 4:41 pm

Neshamos.org is actually doing the work of making healing experiences available to the community.
They are doing it properly, responsibly, with and advisory board with a wide array of medical and mental health proffessionals, and under the auspices of the C.H Beis Din.

If someone “knows better” than all the healing professionals, and also all the rabbonim, and also the psychologists, therapists, and doctors, parhaps it may prove valuable for them to do some personal introspection . . . or they could just continue to spout verbal throw up all over themselves if that makes them feel better.

What they say
Reply to  B"H for Neshamos.org
January 22, 2026 6:34 pm

“The Emotional Fitness Center does not replace medical or psychiatric care and is not intended for situations requiring emergency intervention.”

Yep
Reply to  B"H for Neshamos.org
January 22, 2026 7:36 pm

All the people that don’t understand what it is all about – good for you, you are not the target audience.
For those who are struggling, however, those can be very helpful. Are there guarantees? No. Again, someone in the parsha knows that already, and if you are not, these things exists to help the struggling. Much in the same way as you don’t call out a conventional doctor for helping you in exchange for money, as long as it helped, same has to apply here.

true
Reply to  Yep
January 22, 2026 10:53 pm

however it still must be in accordance in halacha, because otherwise you are not healing but doing the opposite

Breathwork by itself
January 22, 2026 6:20 pm

Even if it’s done with rabbinic supervision is not enough. It must be accompanied with a plan of positive day to day action of how to move fwd.
And,
Also the focus of searching, searching and more searching to find and gather all the negative stuff in order to heal can have the opposite effect of healing.
May Hashem help everyone find a path fwd to heal that is fully in line with the Torah. Otherwise, what you think is healing, can actually c”v hurt you.

One thing is for sure
January 22, 2026 6:36 pm

Until Moshiach is fully here, and may it be now, we do need to acknowledge that not everyone is going to choose to find healing and growth through learning Torah and Chassidus. We still go to doctors, therapists etc There are Yidden that for whatever reason don’t have a mashpia, and/or are not using Tanya and Maamorim and Sichos… to help them grow emotionally and mentally. So we do as a community need to ensure that there are places and ways for everyone to have a safe space to work on their growth, that is completely in line with the… Read more »

What is the difference
January 22, 2026 7:00 pm

It’s strange people are ok with traditional therapy knowing full well it is heavily based on secular science, but are against alternatives therapies, even when a Rabanim sanction it. There is nothing wrong with learning from techniques found in other places and adapting them to Torah if there is a need for it. It is known the Rebbe encourage kosher forms of meditation to help keep people away from non kosher forms. If people in the community need emotional therapy, for whatever reason, then why not have options for them to choose from, as long it is all with in… Read more »

Tldr
January 22, 2026 7:10 pm


Please be more concise and to the point

Is this not geneivas da'as?
January 22, 2026 8:06 pm

One person writes an ad-style op-ed, and another says their product is trief, and a third comes up with a ‘kosher’ version. This takes away business from the first, who also seems to be an ehrlicher yid.

nah...
Reply to  Is this not geneivas da'as?
January 23, 2026 7:42 am

He’s the guy who’s approved

And who said approval is necessary?
Reply to  nah...
January 25, 2026 10:47 pm

Since when do we need hechsheirim on health?

It’s not breathwork that’s approved
January 22, 2026 8:36 pm

It’s the person giving the breathwork, did they learn it through the lens of Buddhism? Or through a pareve lense? Or a kosher lense. Meditation is. Not necessarily kosher, it can be kosher. Yoga is not necessarily kosher, without its origins it can be kosher. So it’s not the practice , it’s the facilitator. And that is why each person is vetted.

Confusing
January 23, 2026 12:52 am

Rabbi Hecht said breathwork is assur. This place says it’s kosher. What makes one kosher and one not.
Not everyone lives in Crown Heights. How does know how to judge which is halachically acceptable?

BDTZ
Reply to  Confusing
January 24, 2026 9:50 pm

Neshamos has the explicit approval — in writing — of the Beis Din of C.H. who appointed a specialized expert posek to oversee it.

Shea Hecht is rambling his insecurities all over the public.

Which would you trust?

Adina in the hood
Reply to  Confusing
January 24, 2026 10:01 pm

Rabbi Hecht is not a Rov, Rabbi kaganoff is.

what an absolutely
Reply to  Adina in the hood
January 25, 2026 3:25 pm

obnoxious thing to say!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

God bless Rabbi Hecht!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

also God bless
Reply to  what an absolutely
January 26, 2026 11:05 am

Rabba Kaganoff of course

Misleading
January 23, 2026 2:33 am

The letter says nothing about breath work

Forsure
January 23, 2026 7:42 am

Is the name Kahanov or Kaganoff??
I’m sure the Rabonim didn’t write this letter. Someone wrote it for them and asked them to sign.
I don’t believe they are endorsing any specific technique used..

instead of assuming why dont you call the rabbis?
Reply to  Forsure
January 23, 2026 11:28 am

Breathwork was not endorsed. Rabbi Kaganoff was hired by the crown heights rabbanim to interview each facilitator and see wether his specific approach is kosher. so far some breathwork was given a hechsher, others not…

Ask your own Rav
January 23, 2026 10:43 am

Before doing anything that may be halachically questionable, speak to a Rav that knows the person, family or situation. This is why the Rebbe wanted everyone to have a rav. I personally don’t ascribe to most of what is considered “alternative”. I think that there are psychiatric illnesses that need expert intervention and possibly these doctors should weigh in about Breathwork or other alternatives on an individual basis. I am not sure that Breathwork therapists are qualified to recognize when the person needs psychiatric care by an MD. This question needs to be answered; how often does a Breathwork therapist… Read more »

Michoel
January 23, 2026 11:12 am

First of all the headline is misleading.

The Badatz did not endorse breath-work. All the old letter says that this rabbi is okay
To give rabbinic guidance for this organization. That’s all this old letter says.

In addition it’s interesting that we can rely on a Megulach rov for this but can’t rely on chasidishe dayonim and rabonim of large frum communities to give a Hechsher on the “Brooklyn” eruv?

I am not referring to CH eruv.

hakt in chainik
Reply to  Michoel
January 23, 2026 2:39 pm

he is a mashgiach not a rav

Adina in the hood
Reply to  hakt in chainik
January 24, 2026 10:03 pm

No, he’s a rav

Qualified opinion
January 25, 2026 7:32 am

I am a healthcare provider and have been involved with breath work and other therapies. The major issue is too many untrained and unlicensed people are trying to make money and gain spiritual influence doing these things. I have an nyc license, I spent years in school, I have malpractice insurance. What do these guys have to keep them straight? Shea Hecht may be too extreme but no offense the rabbonim who signed have no knowledge of these things. The best would be to train licensed medical professionals in crown heights to do modalities like breath work. Halacha requires licensing.… Read more »

maybe if people were nice to each other and obser
January 25, 2026 3:24 pm

ved the Torah, people wouldn’t have the problems they now have!!!!!!!!!!!!!

X