ב"ה
Friday, 3 Adar, 5780
  |  February 28, 2020

Non-Mevushal Wine With Guests

Question for the rabbi: Can we serve non-mevushal wine at the Shabbos table with non-observant Jews and gentile guests? Full Story

100’s to Join ‘Heights Shabbat’

Next Story »

Mesibas Shabbos Goes Global

7
Opinions and Comments

To keep track of your comments, follow a conversation or flag a comment Login
avatar
  Subscribe  
newest oldest most voted
Notify of
Question on note 13
Guest
Question on note 13

The fact that the Ben ish Chai says yishmailim don’t affect the wine because they are not oived avoidah zara how does that equate with a mechalel Shabbos who is considered halachacly like an oived avoidoh zoro and especially when quoting in note 9 that the Rebbe says not to be maikil bedavka on this issue?

Mevushal or non mevushal
Guest
Mevushal or non mevushal

It’s not clear if the wine we are talking about it mevushal or not?

To number two
Guest
To number two

Non mevushal. A goy is allowed to pour you mevushal wine.

Otd
Guest
Otd

What about all the otd children so many of us are unfortunately experiencing today are we aloud 2 use none mevushal ?

Kos shel Brocho
Guest
Kos shel Brocho

What type of wine did the Rebbe use for Kos Shel Brocho?

ben ish chai
Guest
ben ish chai

but he says not to differenciate from other goyim and to be machmir.

Rabbi
Guest
Rabbi

LeKovodo Rabbi Chaim Hillel Raskin Shelit”a, I wonder why you only quote from the Ben Ish Chai Balak 2, 1? When in sief 11, quoting the Sefer Tifferes Adam 36:2, if the Goy doesn’t touch the wine itself, Lift the cup (bottle) & Swirl the wine, one can drink the wine. In my humble opinion Kevodo should have started the topic with the the foundation of the Halacha. For Yayin Nesech to take place there are 3 conditions that must be met Lehalacha (not al pee Kaballah). 1)Lifting, 2) Kavanah (LeAvodah Zarah) & 3) Shichshuch, Swirling (like professional wine tasters… Read more »

X