ב"ה
Saturday, 17 Nisan, 5786
  |  April 4, 2026

Don’t Let Another Shliach’s Child Be Alone

From the COLlive inbox: "Open your homes and hearts to the children of Shluchim studying far from their families because a single invite can change, and even save, a life." Full Story

Sunday: Road Closures in NYC Due to 2025 Marathon

Next Story »

Picture of the Day

140 Comments
oldest
newest most voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Thank you
November 1, 2025 7:36 pm

And I would extend this message to non-shluchims kids as well. Many of them also lost and lonely in the yeshiva stage or past that.

much bigger problem
Reply to  Thank you
November 1, 2025 10:57 pm

is that you have a separate elitist website for children of shluchim. You need to merge that website with chabadmatch immediately and make it so that there is not a separate special website just for shluchim kids.

Which
Reply to  much bigger problem
November 2, 2025 12:25 am

Which website is that?

Which website?
Reply to  much bigger problem
November 2, 2025 1:12 am

What is the “separate elitist website for children of shluchim”? I have never heard of one

Which website?
Reply to  much bigger problem
November 2, 2025 1:36 am

Is just for schluchim kids?

2nd comment
Reply to  Thank you
November 2, 2025 1:27 am

All sorts of theories will come out in these comments other than the elephant in the room. What are we doing in this world ?what are we pursuing in life? Give from yourselves to help a fellow yid. Stop all the cheshbonos or allowing the soton to come in…. Shluchim anash…. Bt… were talking about Jewish children for heavens sake…. smile at someone, speak nice of someone, even if they don’t fit your families profile….. stop running around life like a chicken. those who are real will understand this message. those who are not keep looking for what makes you… Read more »

Kan Tziva
Reply to  Thank you
November 4, 2025 3:10 pm

I agree that baalei teshuva families as well don’t have that tight clique network that many shluchim families have. The parents trust the Rebbe ‘s system of ahavas Yisroel and inclusion. We don’t even realize what our ostracized children are experiencing.

Ridiculous
November 1, 2025 7:44 pm

Omg nonsense! Stop looking for problems in life. No one asked them to do either of those. Either don’t send your kids away or teach them how to speak up for themselves. Make friends meet ppl who are not like them and don’t judge them and then they will have planty of places to eat and go for shabbes. Don’t make this a problem that it’s not people are more then happy to host. And the schools can help by providing a list of honest or other students who have family should bring along one or two friends and hopefully… Read more »

A little sensitivity…
Reply to  Ridiculous
November 2, 2025 3:45 am

Do… you know the context of this letter? A 17 year old child is no longer alive.

Thank You
Reply to  A little sensitivity…
November 2, 2025 3:16 pm

Thank you for writing that with eidelkiet and sensitivity

Do you even know kids??
Reply to  Ridiculous
November 2, 2025 10:39 am

It’s natural for a teenager to not want to constantly ask for themselves! Relax dude.

Were you never taught about hachnosas orchim?

Motti
Reply to  Ridiculous
November 2, 2025 2:53 pm

Stupid comment of the week.
Many shlichim have no local chinuch so have no choice but to send children away at a young age
Whereas people “in town” have their kids at home into their teens where they can look after them etc.

Well said. Thank you
November 1, 2025 8:04 pm

Many years ago our daughter went to Seminary in Eretz Yisroel. Growing up on shlichus we always had an open home. Every off Shabbos she had to arrange a place to go. As we had no relatives there it made it very difficult for her. One Shabbos she organized a place in Yerushalayim but when she got there they told her they were sorry but had no room. She ended up sleeping on a bench in the street. When one spends a fortune on Seminary and Yeshiva it should be the responsibility of the organization to make sure the students… Read more »

Agree
Reply to  Well said. Thank you
November 1, 2025 10:41 pm

All dorms need to include all meals. It is unfair to expect children who are signed up to the school to have to find meals.

The real issue!
Reply to  Well said. Thank you
November 2, 2025 1:54 am

The real issue is the Seminaries and Yeshivos are robbing the parents and don’t really care about the students.
Who can afford $25,000 tuition for a seminary???
Who can afford $20,000 for Mesivta???

On what planet???
The people running the Moisdos are laughing all the way to the bank…
And recently the wealthy businessmen are cashing in by opening their own Moisad i.e. business.

Sad

Exactly!
Reply to  The real issue!
November 2, 2025 9:02 am

The “top chassidishe” yeshivas are doing this.

Responsibility
Reply to  Well said. Thank you
November 2, 2025 8:55 am

The school must make sure that every student has a place for Shabbos and Yomtov. And yes, it includes Sukkos and Pesach.
My granddaughter was in Seminary in Melbourne and the school made sure that every single girl was invited for Shabbos and Yomtov. The community was extremely welcoming. Kol Hakavod!
The seminary had around 30 foreign students. The larger seminaries should find away to manage providing for each girl.

BH
November 1, 2025 8:12 pm

Thank you so much for expressing what we’re all feeling.

Not sure why only kids of shluchim
November 1, 2025 8:17 pm

Aren’t we all one mishoacha this message is foe all anash and indeed for all of klal Israel when you see some one who is in need help.

Agreed
Reply to  Not sure why only kids of shluchim
November 2, 2025 8:20 am

Absolutely agreed! I’m so done with seeing this article after article. “Kids of shluchim..'” what about the rest of us??? Our kids deserve as much attention, sensitivity equally.

They dedicate their lives
Reply to  Not sure why only kids of shluchim
November 2, 2025 3:20 pm

Shluchim dedicate their entire lives. Their children don’t have friends in their community, they don’t have a Yiddishe infrastructure, and they do so much regardless.
So yes, they do deserve extra attention

Mistaken
November 1, 2025 8:19 pm

My heart is bleeding and I have shed countless tears for what this boy must have gone through. However this is not a Shlichus problem. Loneliness isn’t a Shlichus problem. I live in Crown Heights and every day see students who come from broken or dysfunctional homes who also feel lost. Not seen. They are also looking for Shabbos meals. Children who for behavioral or social or academical reasons have to go to “different” schools and are desperate to fit in with friends back at home but don’t have any. Loneliness is a huge problem – in every community, in… Read more »

100%
Reply to  Mistaken
November 2, 2025 12:19 am

This is a wakeup call for everyone. Everywhere. In all communities.

To be kind. To include others. Children need to be taught these values from when they’re YOUNG.

Schools need a ZERO TOLERANCE for bullying policy.

And for all of us – a reminder: to notice others more, to check in with how people are doing.
When you talk to a kid/teenager, ask about if they have friends? Are they happy in school? A little bit of care can possibly save a life.

Exactly!
Reply to  100%
November 2, 2025 9:04 am

Zero tolerance for bullying and that means zero victim blaming. Period.

Crown hts
Reply to  Mistaken
November 2, 2025 1:17 am

In crown hts, most ppl dont invite others, snobby community

To be fair
Reply to  Crown hts
November 2, 2025 9:05 am

Many in c.h. are struggling financially.

Thank you
Reply to  Mistaken
November 2, 2025 8:23 am

THANK YOU!!! WELL SAID. IT CAN ALSO BE KIDS WITH OUT FAMILY DISTINCTION.

Why not Anash in general.
November 1, 2025 8:22 pm

Why only Shluchims kids, and not all of Anash?

Contact info in NY
November 1, 2025 8:24 pm

Please share a way to connect parents of kids learning in new York so we can host.

Maybe
Reply to  Contact info in NY
November 1, 2025 10:17 pm

Someone at the Chabad office under 302 could make a hub for hosting around the world.

Thank you!
November 1, 2025 8:29 pm

As a daughter of Shluchim, thank you!

A word of gratitude
November 1, 2025 8:42 pm

As a shlucha with kids who attended schools and yeshivos all over the country and world, I want to thank all the mosdos, michanchim and michanchos and parents in the communities who hosted and cared for our chidren over the 40 yrs. Parents who hosted farbrengens, shsbbos, etc. We do appreciate it from the depths of our heart.

It’s a sad fact
November 1, 2025 8:46 pm

You’re right for sure. The truth is that the same “generosity” needs to be extended to all Bochurim and Bochurot, not just the Shluchim’s kids. I also think that people shouldn’t only invite their family’s or close friends’ children; they should stop being so worried and scared about boys and girls just speaking to each other at the table.

Anonymus
November 1, 2025 9:08 pm

Unfortunately very very true.. thank you for posting

Single mom
November 1, 2025 9:11 pm

Where is the outcry? My son could not get into zal. Went to a great mesivta. I raised him with great values and here we are, no zal, no help.

No zal
Reply to  Single mom
November 1, 2025 11:51 pm

Pls call Rabbi Yacov Barber of Machnei Israel 9178188707

Unfortunately, you are not alone
Reply to  Single mom
November 2, 2025 3:01 am

There are many not in a zal yet

So where is the outcry?
Reply to  Unfortunately, you are not alone
November 2, 2025 9:21 pm

Are we feeling okay???

Terrible
Reply to  Unfortunately, you are not alone
November 2, 2025 10:30 pm

Where’s the outcry?

Beautiful and sad
November 1, 2025 9:13 pm

What do you mean by adopt? Literally?legally?

From an article by D.B.
November 1, 2025 9:13 pm

BH May we know no more sorrow!! May we only need to comment on happy news!!! בקרוב ממש ממש נאו I want to share a few sentences from an article by Rabbi Dovi Brod from Israel. -“When a tragedy like this occurs—our hearts break, and our minds seek answers. It is a human and natural reaction: out of the fear that this could happen to any of us, we rush to ask: Who is at fault? What caused it? We look for explanations, something to hold onto—something that will calm our anxiety and make us feel that this could never… Read more »

word salad
Reply to  From an article by D.B.
November 1, 2025 10:51 pm

blah blah blah blah… how about ahavas yisroel that’s where it starts that’s where it ends…. stoo the Loshon Harah and rechilus…..
SHAME on our community!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

To "word salad"
Reply to  word salad
November 2, 2025 12:09 am

Sounds like you have a lot of anger….

hell yes
Reply to  To "word salad"
November 2, 2025 9:33 am

I do have anger, A precious was life of a child that lives a life most will never understand (unless you are in it. ) was cut short, I know the suffering of this child first hand.

I strongly disagree!
Reply to  From an article by D.B.
November 2, 2025 12:26 am

You write
“The friends and community of this bochur have begun examining their own actions, searching for what might have caused this.

But that is a mistake. Nothing in the world can directly cause something so severe.”

After hearing the horrible bullying that he went through… It is NOT a mistake for those around him to examine their behavior.
A cheshbon nefesh is HIGHLY in order!

Yes, it’s an uncomfortable truth. But you need to face it.
There is almost nothing worse for a person to endure than loneliness, being bullied, and excluded from others.

Agreed
Reply to  I strongly disagree!
November 2, 2025 9:15 am

When a person is singled out to be the Karbon it can be nearly impossible not to feel like something is inherentlt wrong with them and their existence that theyre the target,making them feel alone in the worst way.

Visitor
Reply to  Agreed
November 3, 2025 2:06 pm

It appears to have been the result of severe bullying and did not appear to be related to getting Shabbos invites.

אנונימי
Reply to  Visitor
November 5, 2025 10:27 am

שתיהם נפגשים למילה אחת-בדידות

True
Reply to  From an article by D.B.
November 2, 2025 9:46 am

Thank you

I was bullied
Reply to  From an article by D.B.
November 2, 2025 6:52 pm

This feels like you are justifying what happened. There is NO JUSTIFICATION for bullying.

He's not justifying
Reply to  I was bullied
November 8, 2025 7:52 pm

He’s saying that we can’t say for sure that a specific event was the cause for something of this nature. That is a very heavy weight the persons involved will live with unnecessarily.
Since a person is very complex and there’s so much that goes on inside that we never find out about .
Only Hashem knows for sure.

Resident
November 1, 2025 9:13 pm

My friend , we must do this for ALL children !

Exactly
Reply to  Resident
November 2, 2025 10:30 pm

We have tremendous dysfunction within

Thank you
November 1, 2025 9:17 pm

Thank you for this article. I totally relate. It is hard enough having to send them away so young. Unfortunately this happens a lot, and we are so grateful when people open their homes to our precious shluchim or shluchos who are learning out of town. Also when the mechanchim or mechanchos take extra care of children as well. Thank you

The average family
Reply to  Thank you
November 2, 2025 3:03 am

Has absolutely no way of knowing who to invite, there has to be a way for people to connect

Reach out
Reply to  The average family
November 2, 2025 3:22 pm

To the schools, Hanholos, teachers, I’m sure they will direct you

Single mom
November 1, 2025 9:18 pm

How much more can we endure? A single mom trying to get a great bachur into yeshiva.
I’ve been working on it for 8 months

Nyack
Reply to  Single mom
November 1, 2025 10:50 pm

There’s a great zal in Nyack with a menahel with a big heart. Get in touch

No zal
Reply to  Single mom
November 1, 2025 11:53 pm

Pls call Rabbi Yacov Barber of Machnei Israel 9178188707

How is it????
Reply to  Single mom
November 2, 2025 3:04 am

Not the first I have heard of this. How can there be Chabad Bochurim who want to go to zal and can’t get in ??????

Where is the outcry?
Reply to  How is it????
November 2, 2025 9:24 pm

Cuz No-one cares. Is this Torah??
We have no room?
Put a bunch of heads together and come up with a solution, a new yeshiva, but to hurt our children???
Shame on all of you!!

Midwest BT
November 1, 2025 9:20 pm

What about Anash kids or kids of BTs?

Anash kids....
Reply to  Midwest BT
November 2, 2025 3:05 am

If a child is Chabad, they are all anash… No difference.

Mental health epidemic
November 1, 2025 9:26 pm

1) While this may apply to shluchim in remote communities, it is not true for all. Regardless, ALL kids should have love and support, not just shluchim’s kids
2) The real issue here is the neglect of mental health within our community. This is a real and prevalent issue which needs to be dealt with appropriately— therapy +/- medication. Learning more Tanya is wonderful but not adequate much of the time and can end in tragic results.

Thank you for writing
November 1, 2025 9:40 pm

Yes it is our responsibility to take care of the shluchim children

Ill do my best where I live

Thank you for submitting your heartfelt words
November 1, 2025 9:44 pm

Thank you for taking the time to remind us all to be more sensitive — especially toward the children of our shluchim. No child should ever know the pain of being bullied. Especially not one who has grown up in a home where every single person — from the homeless to the wealthy — is welcomed with warmth, dignity, and love. This story breaks the heart of Klal Yisrael. This must never happen again — not to our children, and not to the children of our shluchim. We must be better, and raise our children to be better. May Hashem… Read more »

Tell us who they are
November 1, 2025 9:47 pm

Sometimes we are unaware that they have no family, no place to eat etc. can the schools reach out to parents maybe to make them aware? Not all kids want to go to random peoples houses. If they approach them and ask them, they will make a list of the ppl that want it and people will gladly host! We just don’t know who they are 🙂
Att teachers/principals: help us help them

Very True
November 1, 2025 9:54 pm

I agree one hundred percent with this article. Thank you for taking the time to write it.
As I was reading, the first thing that popped into my head was: what are all the Shluchim’s kids — away from home — thinking when they read this?

Any thoughts? Not all of them are 22.

Maybe this is exactly what they need to hear?

I just always find it funny when we write stuff like this on public platforms, literally accessible to everyone — like, what are the very people we’re trying to help thinking as they read it?

A Shliach in a small town
Reply to  Very True
November 1, 2025 11:24 pm

They’re happy to hear that someone is thinking about them, and hopefully, can soon feel more loved and less lonely.

More loved, less lonely...
Reply to  A Shliach in a small town
November 2, 2025 3:08 am

How should someone know to reach out, how, where, when etc…. Most people usually don’t feel lonely because someone is purposely making them lonely. Communication will go a long way

Shliach's Child who lives far away
Reply to  Very True
November 2, 2025 3:24 pm

I felt:
Validated
Like crying
Finally Heard
Hopeful
I hope that people will take this to heart

Yes
November 1, 2025 10:03 pm

When my children studied in crown heights, where we don’t have relatives, they often dreaded Shabbos where they’d have to scrounge around for invitations, and many in town classmates and teachers were often indifferent Ahavas Yisrael starts with the kid sitting next to you.

Different experience
Reply to  Yes
November 1, 2025 11:09 pm

I was in Crown Heights 25 years ago for high school, and there was not a single week that I did not have at least one, usually multiple invitations for Shabbos.

I especially appreciate the legendary Deitsch family, who, without exaggeration, invited me EVERY. SINGLE. WEEK. (not just a standing invitation!) and had the most beautiful Shabbos table I still aspire to emulate in my own home.

When I went to a different city to continue my schooling I was surprised to find that Shabbos invitations were harder to come by.

can't count how many chabad have completely ignore
Reply to  Yes
November 1, 2025 11:17 pm

d me when i reached out to them

Bullying
November 1, 2025 10:05 pm

Yeshivos must have serious and proactive measures to watch for and weed out bullying. Ignoring can have dreadful results…

Change from the top
Reply to  Bullying
November 2, 2025 12:19 am

It has to start by the hanhola. They have to stop bullying boys. What do they expect when hanhola members mistreat boys? My boys were bullied by hanholo members in different Yeshivas.

pain
Reply to  Change from the top
November 2, 2025 9:42 am

I was in a holiday place and my old mashgiach was renting in the same building. While he was happy to give me wine, Shishi Davening etc, he absolutely refused to listen to an important personal question I had to discuss. It brought me back memories of how in yeshiva he also was clueless of my inner feelings. And he has no idea he did anything wrong. Same with this boy, he could have had tons of invites but no one who actually understood him. Ps I once tried inviting a boy for a meal and he wouldn’t come…..

Can so relate
November 1, 2025 10:11 pm

To the writer and the case he mentioned. We are busy bH hosting others, while sending our kids far.

This incident really broke my heart. I really wish that no child and no parent should go thru such pain.
Ahavas isroel is everywhere, for everyone. Please keep a eye on my child!

Not the Shluchim's Children
November 1, 2025 10:11 pm

As a Shliach I can relate to this but please expand this and have in mind all out of towners that are constantly looking for places for Shabbos meals and/or lodging.

Thanks for the many families in Eretz Yisroel and Crown Heights that have graciously hosted my children over the years. It’s greatly appreciated and not taken for granted.

Appreciate what you have
November 1, 2025 10:46 pm

Many have bigger problems to get into schools, yeshivos, camps wtc… that no lubavitch school who supposedly represents the Rebbe have the audacity to refuse the Rebbes own kinder. Be happy they got into the Rebbes school.

sister
November 1, 2025 10:53 pm

I have a sister in CH who NEVER invited our child for anything. not shabbos not Sunday not Monday……….

The real issue!
Reply to  sister
November 2, 2025 2:03 am

What kind of relationship do you have with her???

Don't be so quick to judge
Reply to  sister
November 2, 2025 3:10 am

You don’t necessarily know what’s going on in someone’s house

If she’s your sister
Reply to  sister
November 2, 2025 10:31 am

Perhaps have a conversation with her to figure this out instead of posting a comment on COL?

Crown Heights mother
November 1, 2025 10:55 pm

This was a painful letter to read. To all Shluchim with children living away from home: We value your mesiras nefesh. We salute you. And we want to care for your children! We also want to be there for the thousands – yes, there are thousands – of other children and young adults living in Crown Heights without their families. High school and seminary girls, bochurim, children of Shluchim or regular anash, and many baalei teshuva. There are also hundreds of young couples living here for their kollel year, looking for invitations. Family, current and former students, children’s friends. We… Read more »

This is so true reach out
November 1, 2025 10:57 pm

Has a mother who has daughters in high school in New York. I see that it is constantly something that is so hard for my daughter girls will be friends with her for years. Yeah it will not cross their mind to invite her for Shabbos. We have to make it more of an awareness to reach out to those friends

much bigger problem
November 1, 2025 10:58 pm

is that people are still single.

Thank you for this article!
November 1, 2025 11:24 pm

Many years ago, my daughter attended the Chaya Aidel Seminary.
WHENEVER there was an off Shabbos, the girls knew that they could call and go to the Lebovics for Shabbos! That was so reassuring for us as parents,.. and even more, to the students.
It’s a tremendous stress to put this on a student/ and or their parents.

suggestion!
November 1, 2025 11:24 pm

Perhaps a website can be set up where the students post their name and different families can extend an invitation to the kids that are looking for a place for Shabbas or Yom Tov!

Excellent idea !
Reply to  suggestion!
November 2, 2025 5:01 am

Was just going to suggest that .
A website or WhatsApp’ group/s where the hosts and people looking for places can post .

Job for the Hanhala
Reply to  suggestion!
November 2, 2025 8:39 pm

Yes a wonderful idea but it can be very disheartening to a student (remember we’re talking about kids not adults) to list themselves — the hanhala needs to be working with their community on this so that the Shabbosim are properly organized. It’s not a child’s job.

Kan Tziva
Reply to  suggestion!
November 4, 2025 3:22 pm

Need to vet the families, unfortunately

Thank you for this article!
November 1, 2025 11:27 pm

I just want to give a shout-out to Bais Rivkah Sem Beis who had a system in place to make sure that every girl had a place to eat for shabbos.
And one thing to note is the importance of actually inviting each week. I’ve got many “open-invites” which is incredible and I’ve appreciated. It was nice to know that I can always reach out if I needed. It was even nicer to get a message during the week inviting me so I didn’t have to be the one to ask.

Mental Health in Yeshivos
November 1, 2025 11:28 pm

Mental health needs to be addressed in a serious and proactive way within our yeshivos. This is not only a Chabad issue; however, since Chabad circles tend to be more open to new ideas, they may also be more receptive to meaningful solutions. Perhaps more Chassidishe Yidden should be encouraged and supported to become trained therapists, so they can serve as part of the yeshivah faculty. At the very least, all staff should receive proper training in mental health awareness, along with clear protocols for how to respond when they notice concerning behavior. Every yeshivah should have a qualified therapist… Read more »

Great idea
Reply to  Mental Health in Yeshivos
November 2, 2025 1:48 am

But then secular education and college would be required…

Many teens
Reply to  Mental Health in Yeshivos
November 2, 2025 3:12 am

Don’t want to go to therapy, so it’s not so simple

Interesting
Reply to  Many teens
November 2, 2025 2:56 pm

You might not want it
But it’s extremely helpful and inportant

Parent of Survivor
Reply to  Mental Health in Yeshivos
November 2, 2025 10:05 am

This comment is spot on. My child BH survived a period of suicidality. It was a living hell for the entire family and we are all grateful to HKB”H that it is behind us. COL once wrote an article on how prevalent it is and how often they need to mask the true cause of death in their notifications. It saddens me that after such a tragedy, and a more open one this time, the communal response is “make sure to invite Shluchim’s children to your shabbos table”. When every Chabad yeshiva, high school and seminary has a professional guidance… Read more »

Shabbos Meal App.
November 1, 2025 11:37 pm

The feeling of loneliness is a real and growing issue—now more than ever, especially among younger people. There should be a way to use an existing platform (or create a new one) to connect hosts and guests for Shabbos meals or accommodations—whether for boys, girls, or even young married couples. Baruch Hashem, in every community there are families who are happy to host. However, they often simply don’t know who is looking for a meal or a place to stay. A platform could bridge that gap in a dignified way—ensuring proper tznius, safety, and clear guidelines for both hosts and… Read more »

lovly
November 1, 2025 11:42 pm

. These kids, who are already living lives filled with constant travel and community service, suddenly had to juggle their education in a virtual world. I have a cousin who’s one of them, and honestly, he’s a hero. Not only does he sit through online classes like any other kid, but he’s also involved in helping his parents with their Chabad House activities, often multitasking between homework and running errands for the community. It’s incredible to see him balance it all — school, family responsibilities, and everything else — without ever complaining. For these kids, the challenges are more than… Read more »

Please message me if u need in Israel
November 2, 2025 12:22 am

Hello As you no I live in Israel If anyone is thinking of moving to Israel or needs info about things here Or even about sems or yeshiva I’m happy to advise you Knowledge is free 😆 Also if your daughter comes to sem in Israel I would luv to host her for a shabbos or just a regular week night a home away from home Which I to experienced 35 years ago in beis rivka in France you may I have heard this story but for me I enjoy repeating this to all my guests why U ask so… Read more »

Ahavas Yisrael check in
November 2, 2025 12:32 am

This is an ahavas yisrael wake up call.

The Baal Shem Tov stood for “love for every Jew”.
The way of Chassidus is the way of Ahavas Yisrael.

Unfortunately, how many of us have lost this way.

Let’s bring back this way.

Ahavas Yisrael is not just for random jews we meet on a hike in Utah.
But ahavas yisrael is for our neighbors, workmates, classmates, cousins, etc and every single person you interact with.

We must must must BRING AHAVAS YISRAEL BACK.

Our lives depend on it.

We are not Sheluchim.
November 2, 2025 1:17 am

We live a distance a way from Crown Heights (25 miles a way) and this year, we sent our daughter to Bais Rivkah Sem, and every Shabbos she’s invited out………
Ether family, or friends.

Now…….

Could be that I personally have siblings in Crown Height that may make it easier.

Truth
November 2, 2025 1:51 am

There are many families out there willing to host. Some even make an effort to find guests. How can such a family know who needs? How could the student know who hosts? I’m in Israel constantly hosing bucherim and girls from Non-chabad yeshiva and seminaries because they create list of host families around the country… I’m on a bunch of lists but not a single Chabad institution I know of has one. They just expect the students or their parents to figure it out…

Off Shabbos & for those in CH From OOT
November 2, 2025 1:54 am

As a parent with child who lived in basement in CH with no family in the shchuna, I can tell you her biggest “stress” was finding places to be hosted for Shabbos meals. Invites come but not often enough to where a child feels they have to search for options. I can tell you to this day the anxiety of it is real. Also mesivta boys having to navigate off Shabbos accommodations is ridiculous. Not everyone has the luxury to get a ride home an hour or two away. Some have to fly and arrange for taxis. Cost and time… Read more »

A parent
November 2, 2025 1:09 am

So called Hanahalah who still have the old mentality and literally abuse the boys and girls mentally, should be removed from their positions ASAP. Especially the ones that left , or were quietly let go from one school, who go to a school in another and start their abuse all over again, and kill our children’s lives

A Shliach
Reply to  A parent
November 2, 2025 11:56 am

Very true . These so called Hanhalah (even though they are seemingly very pious and chassidish, they should not be within 10 feet of any of our children).
Teachers need to speak up when someone in Hanhalah higher up than them is mentally abusing a child. Hanhalah members that left one city and moved to another city/school need extra scrutiny.
This is very serious, and Bigasmiyos and/or U’Bruchniyos is literally, C”V killing our children.

You took the words out of my mouth/hand
November 2, 2025 3:48 am

As a European shlucha hosting and no local schools we had to send our children to Israel, kids never got an invite from their schoolmates.
Now years later my daughter in her tiny apartment in CH hosts the same families children for meals, over and over..
Israelies really need to wake up and realize they can’t only take, take.. My son is now in a israeli yeshiva and we are again looking for places to host him on his shabbos off..

אנונימי
Reply to  You took the words out of my mouth/hand
November 5, 2025 10:50 am

כל ילד שצריך להתארח צריך שידעו בכלל שהוא צריך ואם אתה רוצה שילדים מהבית ספר יזמינו אז צריך שהילדים בכלל יוודעו לזה שהוא צריך מקום להיות בו
לפעמים לא חושבים עלזה ולא יודעים בכלל וחושבים שהם מסתדרים..

On social exclusion
November 2, 2025 4:13 am

For young people facing severe social exclusion and bullying, shabbos meals are only a bandaid so that they are not left alone with their pain for so many hours. An “adoptive” family could help more, where they have a consistent safe place and support, but that is a big ask and there’s no good system for it. Therapy can also help with better coping skills to survive the pain and then healing when they are in a better place away from their bullies, as well as learning to project more confidence. However, the only real solution is dismantling bullying, which… Read more »

Heartbreaking both ways
November 2, 2025 4:51 am

I was excluded since I had come from a mishichist school. Bullied for being a crown heightser. Shluchim and anash need to love each other and stop treating each other like aliens. We are one family!

Loneliness
November 2, 2025 4:53 am

Loneliness whether one feels left out or alone for any reason can really kill. Let’s all try to look around us . Many times it’s not the cool ones who need a warm hello -but few look out for those . Or it can be someone going thru a difficult period that needs the “pick me up” There are sooo many podcasts teaching amazing things but let’s make as many “groups” doing what we are preaching ! המעשה הוא העיקר Don’t be afraid to reach out to someone. If you do it with love they will respond and if not… Read more »

Yeshiva’s fault
November 2, 2025 5:17 am

I know of no yeshiva that monitors social media such as WhatsApp/Instagram or other mediums…if they did…they could reach out to both the victim and perpetrators…it’s been going on for years and it’s destroying children’s lives! Shame on both boys and girls schools for ignoring social media!!! This is not 25 years ago, you all need to do this or more kids will be in danger.

And the parents?
Reply to  Yeshiva’s fault
November 2, 2025 8:05 am

Yeshivas can’t control everything. Parents need to step up to. Although there’s a lot that can easily be hidden.

Many schools do!
Reply to  Yeshiva’s fault
November 2, 2025 8:07 am

They dont allow kids to have smart phones and social media , some schools, not all

New organization
November 2, 2025 5:58 am

We need a new revolutionary Chinuch organization that can assist the kids or our revolutionary Chinuch organizations in attending revolutionary Chinuch organizations, either that or old-fashioned parents’ responsibility in parenting.

Please say the truth
Reply to  New organization
November 2, 2025 9:29 am

Starts with the parents and school teachers/Admain I was bullied in school and no one did a thing!!! And people watched and knew exactly what was going on.

Though it would be absolutely terrible to tell this persons parents that their child is bullying because they come from such a family

Emeth
November 2, 2025 8:28 am

Well well well… Mishpoha! Here it all comes in: As uninvited guest… Good thing is, Emeth is not waiting for invitations… People that buisy talking about houses that doesn’t belong to them and demanding kids help and understanding demands are spending time to write excuses on web. How cute is that! Remember one thing… God cares a crabs about your “status “ or “papers” and which web rang of hayoley you were when you were 10yo… How about becoming just a Yidden Shtetle? Or to open the door to strangers that you don’t know nothing about to enter your tznius… Read more »

Stop the bullying!
November 2, 2025 8:37 am

Stop the bullying!
He wasn’t just lonely, I guess he had relatives in Israel, he was bullied by his friends!
And that was the reason…
Start educating kids to behave properly and respectfully! And stop the bullying in Chabad mosdos!! And itH next time we can save a life.
Biglal sinat chinam ….

100%
Reply to  Stop the bullying!
November 2, 2025 11:26 am

This is what we need to focus on.

Stop bullying. It should be regarded as completely unacceptable.

Kids need to be taught from when they’re young to be respectful and kind to others always.

Oholei Torah Zal
November 2, 2025 9:03 am

Oholei Torah Zal has constant, plentiful meals every day including Shabbos and Yomtov!

Perspective
November 2, 2025 11:25 am

There’s a vast difference between bullying , and not inviting enough. A previous article highlighted the tremendous pressure many crown heights women feel to constantly host. They are overwhelmed by the non-stop demand. Expecting them to step up to notice the quiet, lonelier ones may sound good- but is not a practical, realistic solution. All schools that have a dorm need to provide all meals. No child needs to search. Older singles and young couples should also get used to making meals and inviting others. The bullying issue must become a major focus in all schools. Students, teachers and staff… Read more »

Parents do their best but Hanhola must be responsi
November 2, 2025 12:44 pm

We too are shluchim in a distant country with many children BH and we too have sent our children far away for Chinuch, many times to Eretz Yisroel. As parents we do talk to our children almost every day, and we do ask them how everything is going, not just scholastically but especially socially, with friends, etc. Not always do the kids tell all, as much as we try to get the whole picture. It is clear that it is the HANHOLA’S RESPONSIBILITY to know what is happening with their students. That means principals, roshei yeshivos, teachers, mashgichim, em bayit,… Read more »

Ahavas yisroel
November 2, 2025 1:14 pm

It’s time for the schools to make bein Odom l’chaveiro it’s top priority instead of teaching Tanya and sichos that the students don’t absorb anyway

Thank you for a voice
November 2, 2025 1:57 pm

As someone who lived away from home for school I can say just how difficult it was to constantly find meals for Shabbos. By Tuesday evening I had to find meals and reach out to people asking to host starting at fourteen years old. It was rare in my school to get invites from the intowner classmates of mine which made it an even harder experience. At a certain point I started to dread Shabbos. What is a highlight of the week for most people can be a stressful time for a lot of teens living away from home for… Read more »

Motti
November 2, 2025 2:59 pm

I live in a large city but in a neighbourhood 30-45 mins from the main frum neighbourhoods. My children go to school 40 mins drive away. Most of their LUBAVITCHER and many SHLUCHIM children in the school who live in frum neighbourhoods hardly ever offer to host. When my kids have a shabbos program we have to beg, borrow and steal to find a place for them to stay. You would think shluchim and anash would know better. It is heartbreaking and very upsetting. Meanwhile my son who went to a yeshivish/modern yeshivah high school had friends who literally kept… Read more »

Yup
November 2, 2025 6:26 pm

I was in Beis Rivka sem alef (and then as a single girl living in ch) I’m not the type to ask for invites and often just pretended I was good cus I didn’t want to look nebach, it was the same 2 families that invited for shabbos meals. I had no families and it was really really hard. I was good socially and had friends I don’t know why girls just didn’t think of it or thought oh other families will invite. Maybe it’s a stress to have guests… I remember a few weeks when I came home from… Read more »

tough
November 2, 2025 7:17 pm

My Modod friends do not get the concept of sending boys away when there are nearby options. Of course, when there are no options and sending away is the only choice, but if there are yeshivas available nearby, then that should be the first choice. Teen years, especially in modern times, are a pivotal time. Boys are left to fend for themselves in a time in their lives when they need the most love and guidance to make them into healthy men, husbands, fathers, etc. However, we take away those influences, especially a female mother figure. I notice in my… Read more »

The main issue burning issue is BULLYING.
November 2, 2025 9:01 pm

This is a very important article. But this is not what we need to focus on in the aftermath of the heart-rending tragedy. The tragedy happened due to years of relentless bullying. Every school needs to go all out getting a proper training on how to enforce a zero tolerance for bullying approach, as well as educating students at all ages what a bully is, power of the bystanders, and how to stop it etc. This as we have seen is literal פקוח נפש. I have personally seen how a school that is unprepared to deal with bullying exacerbated the… Read more »

Excuse me
November 2, 2025 10:25 pm

As a Crown Heights woman/ wife/ mother / host.. please dare blame this tragedy on us. I rarely get a family only shabbos meal in mid July when the world is dead and everyone ( including my own children) are in camp. My kids ask me which bed they are sleeping in before they go to bed because of the constant hosting. This was a clear case of bullying from peers. It’s tragic beyond words and definitely deserves attention yet focus it where it belongs. Back to Middos being a focus. Back to Ahavas Yisroel being the most important mitzva… Read more »

Immediate action needed to stop the bullying!
November 2, 2025 11:35 pm

This heartbreaking tragedy should be a wakeup call to all Klal Yisroel. This bullying is happening every day in our religious and Chassidish schools where we think our children are safe! My grandson, last year, switched to the large Chabad school in Miami. From the moment he stepped into the class, he was bullied continuously by the entire class. In the lunchroom he sat alone, and no one would dare to come over and befriend him. He joined the class in the 7th grade and his classmates felt he should be ostracized because he was a newcomer.! His young Hebrew… Read more »

Crying
Reply to  Immediate action needed to stop the bullying!
November 3, 2025 9:32 am

So so sorry for what he went through. That is awful !!!

So sad
Reply to  Immediate action needed to stop the bullying!
November 3, 2025 11:26 am

Unfortunately, I think I know what school you speak of. My kids are there now. However, they started off at modern schools until switching to Chabad for middle school. My daughter says she is so happy that she got the right foundation and learned how to be a good person from her modern school. I’ve heard from all my kids in various grades and years, that the kids bully relentlessly. I am dealing with this now. My special needs son who has a public school education is now physically bullied in chabad school. He worked hard to have a jewish… Read more »

אנונימי
Reply to  Immediate action needed to stop the bullying!
November 5, 2025 11:08 am

בואו לא נגדיר כך את חב”ד זה עצוב מאד לשמוע אבל זה לאו דווקא אם זה בית ספר יהודי או לא זה יותר קשור למקרים ספצייפים ולילדים ספציפים

Most of us
November 3, 2025 7:51 am

Most of us send our kids away to diff schools – not just Shluchim – our boys all leave town to go to Mesivta

Practically Speaking
November 3, 2025 12:52 pm

On a practical note: As a “Crown Heighster”, I will say that we are inundated with requests for hosting shabbatons, kinus, tishrei, Chof beis shvat, ., etc. Perhaps this is why some kids may be overlooked. For example, if we just hosted a big Shabbos with guests, the next Shabbos we may not encourage our children to seek out friends. It’s not ideal, but the reality for many families. PS. Another new stream of guests is coming in for weddings that are held in CH, not because they live here, but because it’s more affordable. Both sides need accommodations, hosting,… Read more »

Sad
November 3, 2025 2:38 pm

Sad that this needs to be said.

 “Open your homes and hearts to the children of Shluchim studying far from their families.”

And the words “of Shluchim” should not be in the sentence.

Suggestion
November 3, 2025 2:52 pm

Someone maybe write an article on bullying.

Is this a hachnasos Orchim problem?
November 4, 2025 12:26 pm

Listen, at the end of the day parents are the only ones who will really truly be able to give their kids the love and warmth the need. We can’t expect others to “take in” our kids who are away from home. Invitations are nice but they can also very quickly border into unhealthy territories – not saying this is always the case I am just saying it should come with a lot of caution. Sending your young child away from home (not talking about this 17 yr old bochur, I don’t know his situation) should be done only as… Read more »

אנונימי
November 5, 2025 11:24 am

לגביי ילדים שמחפשים מקום להיות,יש לשים לב למי שצריך ולדעת להזמין,אך לא תמיד יודעים מי צריך להתארח ולא תמיד יודעים שהוא צריך מקום להיות בו.. אבל כן,בזכות הכתבה הזאת מאמינה שיותר ישימו לב ויזמינו.ובכלליבלי קשר להזמנות. יש לשים לב לכל ילד שמרגיש בודד ושהילדים לא יתעלמו מחברים שהם רואים שהם בודדים.גם אם מראים שהכל בסדר.. לדעת להיפתח ולא להשאיר ילד בצד,לדעת לא להיסחף אחרי הלחץ החברתי,ילדים בודדים יכלים להגיע לנפש כואבת מן הבדידות שהם מרגישים.לדעת לדבר יפה אל אחרים. ושבהנהלות בתי ספר וישיבות ישימו לב להתנהגויות לא בסדר ולא יתנו לזה לקרות.ולגביי מה שקרה אומנם אולי יש נקודות ציון בדרך,אבל… Read more »

X