ב"ה
Thursday, 18 Tishri, 5780
  |  October 17, 2019

Another Shabbos, Another Assault

For the second week in a row, a Jewish man was assaulted on Shabbos while walking in Brooklyn's Crown Heights neighborhood. Full Story

The Singles’ College Dilemma

Next Story »

Woman Aims To Reunite Family

46
Opinions and Comments

To keep track of your comments, follow a conversation or flag a comment Login
avatar
  Subscribe  
newest oldest most voted
Notify of
Crown Heights?
Guest
Crown Heights?

Wherever it unfortunately may have occurred, it is frightening to think that Jewish people are being attacked – and Hashem should protect each and every one wherever they are, but is Rutland Rd. E. 46th Street in Crown Heights?
Are people now so fearful and taking precautions to the extent of carrying their cellphones to shul on Shabbos? (as it seems this man felt the need to do…)

 not to worry the Nypd will downgrade i
Guest
not to worry the Nypd will downgrade i

Yes indeed 71 pct NYPD style this will be downgraded to next to nothing no one will be caught its par for the course in C h no matter who iss in charge unless we are accused of being the agitator then it becomes an automatic bias incident &hate crime

Terrible
Guest
Terrible

Anyone living down in that neighborhood should be carrying a weapon for protection.

I spoke to the victim
Guest
I spoke to the victim

I know him, he went home and then called hatzalah

To #1: If it's the 71st Precinct, then ...
Guest
To #1: If it's the 71st Precinct, then ...

…for all practical purposes, it’s Crown Heights.
————-
AND: It doesn’t say that this man was “carrying {a] cellphones to shul on Shabbos”! It only states that he called 911: this could have been using the phone of another person on the street, or that he managed to get home and called from there, or a number of other possibilities.

Midwest Cowboy
Guest
Midwest Cowboy

Time to move out of this dangerous neighborhood. Crown Heights is not a safe place to raise a young family.

Yakov Berman
Guest
Yakov Berman

Are you paying attention to these things?

Larry Kirshenbaum
Guest
Larry Kirshenbaum

In tractate Sotah it says that a person who is walking in the black of night in darkness should be afraid of wild animals and bandits.
In this case he was a bandit and a wild animal

I was there
Guest
I was there

I was right across the street and the man didn’t even look so black so I don’t know what’s so wrong

Animals
Guest
Animals

Simply animals

Is it time to relocate
Guest
Is it time to relocate

Maybe its time to move to Israel! Wake up yiddim!! America isn’t for the Jews. Come join yours brothers and sisters in Israel

where is the outcry
Guest
where is the outcry

a fellow yid gets hurt and silence.

what have we come to.

do we only care when its our own brother and sister.

what happened to גאון יעקב.

my heart goes out to the victim.

ohy what a biiter galus. rebbe help

to #1
Guest
to #1

the man did not have a cell phone on him. he managed to make it home and call hatzalah, who called police for him
we should never see the day when jews have no choice but to take cell phones with them to shul on shabbos!

Is he okay?
Guest
Is he okay?

Is the guy who got injured okay?

To number 1
Guest
To number 1

Why do you conclude such about אונזערע?!
Has it accured to you that he probably called from his hl house once he got home

Reply to number 1
Guest
Reply to number 1

He wasn’t carrying his phone, he called when he got home. That area is technically called East Flatbush, where dozens of Jewish families live.

Ouch
Guest
Ouch

He called hatzolah when he got home. Where’s the compassion?

Boruch Hoffinger
Guest
Boruch Hoffinger

Makes $ for govt.
Chase ’em, got ‘im
Lock im, let im go.
Chase im…etc.
Keeps police busy, they get paid overtime
Sometimes…fill the gastank, paperwork, etc.
‘The 7 Noahide Laws’ would reduce crime accross
America by 85% or more.
Boruch Hoffinger

Extra patrols
Guest
Extra patrols

Strange that nearly every article about violence in the neighborhood ends with the NYPD saying they will be adding extra patrols, but somehow I never see more cops out on the streets.

Where are our community leaders now??
Guest
Where are our community leaders now??

Our “community leaders” were so Quick to defend diane Richardson who spews the same hate, probably it’s because of her and the like that this guy had this violent outburst. Where are they now?

Chalereh
Guest
Chalereh

Shvartzeh Chaya ro’eh. Actual behamis

Hilarious
Guest
Hilarious

I’m just here for the entertainment: I love how some of the more intelligent comments suggest that Yakov Behrman is suppose to be Batman-esque crimefighter. Precious!

“Why didn’t Yakov save him?!” He frantically clacked misspelled words into his crumb-clogged keyboard, trembling with indignation.

“With graet pwor comes greta respoiednbty!!!!”

number 20
Guest
number 20

they are busy going to take them out to eat in basil for photo ops

The politicians ruined NY long ago
Guest
The politicians ruined NY long ago

My father, A”H, grew up in the Bronx, from 1914 until the depression years. He said that what ruined NY was that businesses wanted cheap labor. But the locals would not go for such dirt cheap wages. So, what did businesses do? They imported people from out of town, who were willing to do it. But, the big problem was that among this population was a large criminal element. So, lo and behold, is it any wonder that the crime rate ran up so high in those areas where this group lived?

To #1
Guest
To #1

Pathetic conclusion to reach.

Yes we must all make a BIG DEAL about this

To #19: They do the temporary "Dog and Pony" show
Guest
To #19: They do the temporary "Dog and Pony" show

For the next few days, there’s a fancy tower-like device with floodlights on it, to create the sensation that there’s now “extra surveillance.” This lasts for just a few days, and then that’s it: back to normal, which is inadequate at best. While “south Crown Heights” has been an excellent place to live–and still is: and improving, overall, all the time in my almost 15 years living several blocks south of Empire–the area around that stadium has sometimes been a kind of no-man’s land, where many lowlifes feel they can get away with dumping stolen property (including burned shells of… Read more »

Kahane
Guest
Kahane

Every Jew a .22

Kan Tzeeva Hashem es habracha
Guest
Kan Tzeeva Hashem es habracha

Remember these words!

yossi stern
Guest
yossi stern

These two incidents are a sign of a growing situation. Crime is up and police patrols and response are poor. Our community leadership is the worst! I know them all, and they do barely anything to enhance the security in CH. Our leadership is focused on photo ops, networking, and defending the elected officials while our elected officials do little for CH. Did you know the 71st pct had close to 200 more cops in its pct??? They were slowly moved out and we are left with an inadequate precinct. Did you know on an average night there is less… Read more »

The remarks this monster said prior to his attack on the Yid
Guest
The remarks this monster said prior to his attack on the Yid

point directly to the select diatribe made by Richardson at that meeting! Agee with number # 20. Lew Fidler had no possible reason to make up a story about Richardson. We are seeing the results for sure!

YTLM
Guest
YTLM

Why aren’t there elections for a new vaad, community leadership, get the old dogs out. This community has so much dysfunction it can’t even help itself.. so sad… all the current representatives and elected officials must be replaced.

To #22
Guest
To #22

Not a single commenter here has said anything remotely similar to your so-called satire. So we must conclude that you simply have no heart for a fellow Jew (assuming you are one), or indeed for a fellow human being (also doubtful whether you are one).

So I look forward to hearing that you’ve gotten attacked and beaten, so that we do can point and laugh and write stupid “satires” about it.

protest
Guest
protest

how about making a demonstration?

#6, #11
Guest
#6, #11

B”H
The Rebbe was in favor of strengthening the neighborhood, not fleeing and having more patrols.

not ok
Guest
not ok

Why dont the community council take control and make us have more police protection.. and make the black people scared of us they should not have the nerve to hurt anyone!!

 Boro parker
Guest
Boro parker

You can strengthen your neighborhood of crown heights by following the Boro park tactic. 25 years ago certain edges of Boro park were unsafe because large amounts of Arabs left bed there. Not just any arabs but the ones that hate Jews. So in no time we flooded their area with Chinese. Today there are 150 thousand Chinese. Go look at 8 ave. All Chinese. They don’t bother jews. You need to flood all of the crown heights borders with massive chinese as a buffer zone between the Jews and the others. All jewish apartment landlords can do it. You… Read more »

 “Bitachon” Frum Defense
Guest
“Bitachon” Frum Defense

may be now is time to teach our boys,teens and men self defense?

To #9
Guest
To #9

What the actual what?
I hope you are joking.
Or you are a child.
And I hope your parents educate you.

Astonished over lack of cameras and monitors in deterrence!
Guest
Astonished over lack of cameras and monitors in deterrence!

The entire modern world has adapted to continuous surveillance with mounted cameras and monitors to control every crime area.one camera fpr every street,being monitored in the police station.is a needed and practical solution.i
Eretz YISROEL manufactures the best systems. The Chinese government purchased a huge amount of them ,recently.the money needed is worth it.

I

Only solution:
Guest
Only solution:

we’ve got to ONCE AND FOR ALL, get together – ALL of us – and most importantly Check Our Egos At The Door! and with Bitul and common interests and unified purpose, discuss/brainstorm the issue.
THIS will have the desired effect!

The CH community leaders
Guest
The CH community leaders

They ARE the problem!
Barry Sugar cares. We need more like HIM.

Homeless Mentally Ill Anti-Semites
Guest
Homeless Mentally Ill Anti-Semites

Did the perp come from the homeless shelter for drug addicts and the mentally ill or mentally ill drug addicted anti-semtics that are dumped all around Kingsbrook Shul ? Did the perp come from a) Kingsbrook Mental Health Facility – just opened 3 yrs ago b) Salvation Army Homeless Shelter ( Clarkson & Albany) c) CAMBA – Albany & Winthrop d) the mental health facility next to True Value ( ENY Ave across from supermarket ) e) the soon to be opened “Bridge” (ENY Ave next to KFC Utica Ave) – ty Jacob & Jessie – you turned your back… Read more »

Shabbos
Guest
Shabbos

While the victim did not have his cell phone on him, boruch Hashem, maybe the headline of “another Shabbos, another assault” was hashgocho protis and we need to all strengthen in making Shabbos holy.No, I am not saying the victim, who was doing his best to keep Shabbos, but encouraging others in making yheir Shabbos holy.

קוק נישט
Guest
קוק נישט

מ׳גייט אין גאס און מ׳קוקט נישט אוף די בהמות.
בפרט צו זיי עפעס זאגן
אפילו א נוטראל ווארט אזוי ווי גוטן טאג
מקוקט נישט און רעדט נישט צו הינט
אזוי האט מען מיר איסגעלערנט

Long time observer
Guest
Long time observer

Doesn’t it pay to be PROactive instead of always just REactive..?
עד מתי??!

Astonished over lack of cameras and monitors in deterrence!
Guest
Astonished over lack of cameras and monitors in deterrence!

Continuous monitoring surveillance requires only one camera for four streets or blocks when placed at corners.one trained technician can cover multiple monitors.there are no reason to believe that this should not be funded by the city, county and state.If schools , places of worship ,public areas receive funding this should be politically proposed n persauded by capable community leaders n professional political office holders.

X