Rabbi Simcha Weinstein, a best-selling author, wrote the following article for the Jewish students at the renowned New York art school, Pratt Institute, where he directs its Chabad House:
In case you spent your Passover vacation on another planet – and decided to stay there – you may have missed the wedding of Prince William of Wales and Catherine (Kate) Middleton at Westminster Abbey on Friday April 29, 2011.
As an Englishman in New York, I’m obviously interested in the nuptials of Prince William, who is second in the line of succession to Queen Elizabeth II. Like everybody, I remember where I was when his mother was tragically killed (Jerusalem for my first taste of Yeshiva), and I’ve grown up with him. Yet, I did not watch the royal precession, and that has nothing to do with the fact that my invitation may have gotten lost somewhere over the pond.
While Prince William and Kate have personally approved a list of memorabilia, including official mugs, plates, biscuit tins and porcelain pill pots, tea-towels and, of course, the official china, I’m not buying into it, literally.
The wedding hysteria and celebrity publicity hoopla surrounding the wedding is at a boiling point, and as the world agonizes over the dress, cake and honeymoon, I will be serving my own Queen, as we prepare Shabbat Dinner for 50 guests in our Chabad House.
I vaguely remember the royal wedding of Charles and Diana and not so vaguely remember how Camelot fell in the intervening years. With respect to the House of Windsor, they do have a disastrous record when it comes to nuptials.
Let’s face it—what does one expect in a world of texts and tweets, and celebrity fascination? If the fashion police were to analyze my every clothing choice, I don’t think I would fare too well either.
Interestingly, in a few weeks, Jews around the world will celebrate the holiday of Shavuot. The Talmud describes Shavuot, the day marking the giving of the Torah, as resembling a wedding between the Almighty and the Jewish people. The Almighty as the groom and the Jewish people as the bride; Mount Sinai represents the wedding canopy and the Torah the ring on His bride’s finger. Each year on Shavuot we renew our nuptial vows to our Beloved Creator as the word “Shavuot” has the same root as the Hebrew word “shevuah”—an oath.
In a Jewish wedding, after the ceremony, the bride and groom adjourn to a private room called the “yichud” (private) room. The few minutes the couple share alone allude to their new intimate relationship and emphasizes that their absolute privacy be respected.
This is something our dear young royals so badly need.
So if I could give a gift to my dear royals, it would be what Jewish tradition values for young couples in their first year of marriage – privacy. And that’s why I didn’t watch the precession. While I know it didn’t make much of a difference, I didn’t want another set of prying eyes watching them. Instead, I will just say what my ancestors have been saying for thousands of years at times like this: “Mazal Tov!”
— Rabbi Simcha Weinstein is a best-selling author (his latest book is Shtick Shift: Jewish Humor in the 21st Century). He chairs Chabad and the Religious Affairs Committee at the renowned New York art school, Pratt Institute.
My nickname is babbleland and i think that the wedding was even more tzunirsdik then the crown heights crazy weddings(if you dont know what that means than you could look into the rashis of babbleland)and furthurmore whoever didnt watch the wedding has the chutzpah to not learn a very intresting lesson from it about how you could compare this to the realroyal family/wedding.what is the real royal family?well its the family of the labavitcher rabaim. I accuse every person who works for the tv for not asking their bosses or somthing like that to put on the video live of… Read more »
#29 you are wrong he was there
#50it IS a used chruch but he went because of sholom malchus
HER DRESS WAS SO AMAZINGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGG!!! AS WELL AS EVERYTHING ELSE INVOLVED IN THE WEDDING!
WISH I CUD HAVE BEEN THERE!
I can see why anybody would want to watch this wedding- it’s just plain human curiosity.Not everything needs, or deserves, a ponderous explanation or excuse.Having said that, I’m puzzled by why some viewers seem to regard the party as an important event in the history of the world. The fact that Prince William got married may (or may not) be important but breathlessly analyzing the wedding proceedings including what the bride and guests wore, topped by the deliberate release of how much the bridal gown and wedding cake costs is about as vacuous as information is likely to get.
Diana’s maternal grandmother was a Jewish woman who was meshumad and married a goy who was a “lord.” So Diana was “Lady Diana”, who married Prince Charles. Thus William is a Yid… I’m very sure Rabbi Weinstein wasn’t aware of this when he wrote “Mazel Tov.”
Beyond that, I think that all the respect-worthy and symbolic (reminding us of Hashem’s kovod) aspects of royalty are great, and how wonderful it is that people can go to make a bracha upon seeing the Queen in person. Halevai that England, and all countries where Yidden live, should remain a Malchus shel chessed.
i agree wiv ya!! im proud 2 be british….an wats teh use in lief if u dont know wat is happening in teh world round you!!
you are sooooooooooo sad! cant you enjoy something in life instead of darshoning and giving mussar!
thumbs up, u took the words outa my mouth!
lol mazel tov…i guess…;)
Nobody denied that. The issue is not respecting the malchus and praying for their welfare, but either it was appropriate or not to watch that insignificant event for chassidim.
It is a mitzva in the Torah to respect and honor malchus and make a bracha in there presence.
how is a non-jewish wedding inspiring???
i watched teh wedding an i think it was a remarkable site to watch!!
We can learn from the details of the royal wedding DECORUM AND REFINEMENT ARE NON NEGOTIABLE!!!! Let us remember we are also ROYALTY with HASHEM as our KING that makes us princes and princesses . WE SHOULD be aware of presenting ourselves with pride refinement and modest outer appearance with CLASS {no we dont need to be dowdy! We can be eidel and trendy too!} I found this part of history fascinating on many levels! We wish the royals well and hope they too can withstand the pressures of society and as they embark on their journey in the public… Read more »
why cant we watch the royal wedding?
as we are chassidim the rebbe never told us we are not allowed to watch it!
THERE WAS NO REASON WHY NOT TO WATCH IT!!!!
go get a life!!
to # 14 ,I did watch, and so him in the westminster abbey
to # 1,the words mazel tov is now gon in the secular world and used in the frensh ans english langage by all the goyim as it seems to be taken from the movies on tv used by the movie makers
i watched the wedding and enjoyed it immensely. to all of those saying how bad it was to watch on TV it was live on the computer!
the Rebbe said to give respect to royalty and watching it was perfectly okay.
what i liked about it was the friendly atmosphere when everyone got together and someone even commented there how nice it was that all over the world terrible things are happening and how nice it was that we are all comin together to celebrate a GOOD thing. i agree.
GO BRITISH!!!!!!!!!!
its just a wedding!!! nothing special!!! why is everyone making a whole big deal out of it!!! i totaly agree with #51. who cares!! and anyway they are not jewish!!! keep youre exitement for jewish weddings and be happy for your fellow jews!!!!!!!
Her arms were completely visible through her sleeves, her blouse cut just above her chest, but i guess by today’s standards that would be considered modest?
Do you know the kind of clothes she wear in her daily life? We don’t have to be a genius to guess the answer. And do you know the kind of lives those people live? So there is NOTHING good to derive from that stupid event. It reminds me of a story the Rebbe told about a Rabbi who was inspired for his Shabbos sermon after having watched on TV a Christian priest praching. It’s pathetic!
And btw the chief rabbi was there as was rabbi plant with a heter from rabbonim. I saw them on camera. They didnt sing thow. Twas cool to watch. I just wanted to see her dress so its ttly fine.
why is everybody making such a big fuss? writing about wasting time? you are wasting your time by sitting down and writing these comments! the people that watched the wedding have watched it! theres nothing you can do about it, its over! I personally thoughly enjoyed it immensly! it was fascinating to watch. How often does one see such royalty and such an amazing event?? I think it amazing that I had the chance to be apart of such a major event in history. About bringing a church into the home – we watched it online and switched it off… Read more »
I read and saw some news programs leading up to the wedding. They were all waiting with bated breath to see the bride’s wedding gown. British “royal” experts and commentators were saying that for sure the bride is expected to wear a MODEST dress with SLEEVES as befits royalty and out of respect for the church. And indeed, her dress was quite modest…just to show that L’havdil if they respect a church, we must respect OUR G-d who is EVERYwhere and not just in a sanctuary.
I’m not loyal enough to the family that I would get up at 4in the morning to watch it, but it was very tznius and proper, something that doesn’t happen alot in this day and age.
They shouldn’t !
The way things played out in my home, my seven year old was awake at 3 am with an earache and my baby was awake, so we all watched the royal wedding. I thought it would be fun since I have memories of watching the 1981 wedding of Princess Di. But as the scene went from royals arriving at the abby to the actual ceremony, I wanted to turn the computer off. There were so many signs, symbols, people, words…that I didn’t want my kids exposed to. I did end up turning it off, but probably too late. We had… Read more »
how come i had no idea that this was going on?!? not that i could care anyway!
Please don’t feel bad for me! I had a great time & I get up early every day (6:00 AM) to see my husband go off to Shul. Then I daven & say my Tehillim before I go off to work in a Mosod, after which I come home, prepare supper, & watch my husband go back to Shul for Mincha Maariv, & his Shiurim (I go to Shiurim on shabbos) & sometimes we actually discuss inyanei Chassidus. Is that enough for you?
they are ROAYALS!!!! automatic attention- ur set of prying eyes not being there- i promise it went unoticed and dsnt make a dif (until u posted it on coll lol
I really feel VERY bad for you. When was the last time you got up for an early Shiur in Chassidus? Please lets not forget who these “royals” are; decendants of those who expelled Jews from their country AND I wouldn’t be surprised if the Abby wasn’t built with monies confiscated from innocent Jews who were robbed and expelled.
1) it is pathetic to read how many COL readers watched the wedding. 2) People are able to wake up at 4am to watch a stupid event, but when it comes to wake up early in the morning for davening, we have all kinds of excuses. 3) The Rebbe forbid his chassidim to have TV. What we see nowadays is that many people are watching streaming movies and live TV on their computer, but are playing on words saying that it’s not a TV but a computer. 4) We didn’t need to watch that stupid wedding to have an avant-gout… Read more »
who cares about this stupid wedding? they didn’t make a whole deal by my wedding in London and the queen WAS invited to mine! THE WORLD HAS GONE MESHUGA
between the fact that you cant turn down a royal invitation and that it is not a actively used church, he was allowed to enter and im sure he got a heter
Being a shomer shabbos jew i didnt watch the weeding as it took place on friday night in Australia.. nothing to do with TV, Internet, or my association with the royal family
Great article and extreamlry prevalent to today and the coming of shavuot.
I too got up early to watch the wedding! It was a splendid affair!! Loves every minute of it!! When I was a young girl in lubavitch, we were taken to the queens jubilee! We waved flags and made a Bracha. The same Bracha that is made in many shuls to bless the queen!!!!
don’t recall EVER seeing a pic of the queen on the wall of a frum person’s home, for what purpose? I guess it is not as bad as bringing yoshke on the cross into your home by watching and listening to avoda zara in westminster abby, i seem to recall something about yidden dying al kiddush hashem on account of that religion
Rabbi Simcha is the best!!!
I agree with you 100%. seems like unfortunately all those who did see it forgot that point, and from what I read in the comments, that means ALLOT of people.
אל תפנו אל האללים “Do not TURN toward idols” of this week’s parsha makes it an avairah to willfully think about or view idolatry. So says the Sefer Hachinuch (full text below). Watching the wedding in the church called Westminster Abby is thus Biblically prohibited. In addition, watching it brings into our homes THE SIGHTS AND SOUNDS OF CHRISTIANITY! How can any frum Yid in their right mind bring the sights and sounds of the church into their home? Here is the text of Sefer Hachinuch ריג. שלא לפנות אחר עבודת אלילים לא במחשבה ולא בדבור ולא בהבטה. שלא לפנות… Read more »
Many of us have watched him grow up ,privileged he is but as we know hes had his fair share of sorrow,such a young boy when he lost his mother yet hes grown up to be a fine young man ,educated,serving our country,incredible amounts of charity work…he makes us proud and i wouldnt have missed watching his wedding for anything in the world!
It is perfectly ok to see a once to maybe three in a lifetime event and that doesn’t mean you need a tv. You could’ve seen it anywhere – over 2.5 billion people managed to see it and you could too… Congrats to them and the family’s involved!!
I am a full fledged lubavither. born and bred. I DID sit with my chilren for a few moments to show them what royalty is. wht it demands. the respect, the aura, the serenity, the tznius (in behavior – mind you, the bride was quite tzniu’sdik herself). the Queen – what a queen:) Unfortunatley, i don’t have any other real life figures to show them as true royalty. this is as close as they’ll get.
I saw him & the BBC made a point of mentioning him by name & title (Lord Sacks, the Chief Rabbi.) He was sitting with other religious leaders.
the rebbe said you should not bring a church into your house and by watching it on tv OR THE INTERNET (which is 100 percent tv) is acheiving and ignoring exactly what the rebbe treid to hard to put in our hearts..that is.. t have a connection to yiddishkeit and distance yourself from distractions…
it is something to think about..
I watched the wedding and I saw two Orthodox rabbis in attendance at Westminster Abbey – Rabbis Jonathan Sachs and Rabbis Alan Plant. There is no question they were in a church, though when the camera panned over the various religious leaders during one of the hymns, it was apparent that Sachs was not singing along.
we dont have such things here in america…
and America dosn’t
i watched it!!!!!!!!!!!!!!…it was soooooooo cool!!!1
I so appreciate the sentiment. There are more important things for us to be doing with our time erev Shabbos. You had the courage to write the obvious but not necessarily the most popular. It’s not easy to resist the pull of these things, but it helps when we articles that put our priorities back into place.
Rabbi those are great words, U R a great Rabbi that does a lot for the community and and teh Clinton Hill area – Good Shabis the Klein’s – Ice Cream House @ 873 Bedford Ave. Hatzocha Raba
and in any case you can watch it on bbc news!! which is exactly what i did!! it was awwwwssommee!!!
It is not often that you get a chance to see and feel and real sense of Malchus in this day and age. There was a lot of dignity and some very important and inspiring messages, such as the relevance and importance of marriage.
I also think t he couple are very charitable and preferred donations to charities, than gifts, infact Prince William is t h patron of many good causes, parituclarly caring for orphans and bearevement counselling.
Not to the Church! no Rav in their right mind would give and Jew a hetter to go to a church-no matter the reason!
DON’T be rude about the British prince and princess……king and queen to be……..
the wedding was AWSOME!!!!! i personally wayched it online!!!
As an English woman I was very interested to see history in the making. I also highly respect the Queen – she is totally devoted to her role, has never put a foot wrong and allows us Yidden to live here in peace. My shabbos was all prepared well in advance and I can truly say that I was completely moved by, what we call, the pomp and circumstance. IT WAS MALCHUSDIK. And on the contrary it has filled me with great anticipation for the day when we will all witness our true and only king, Moshiach. May it be… Read more »
he doesn’t hate his fellow humans. he is saying a Jewish concept one which while you may not be comfortable with or agree with doesn’t actually make him a hateful person. i’m sure he treats every human being with respect.
i heard alot of frume idin have the pic of the queen hanging in their living room !!!!
Rabbi SImcha classes are awesome, he has changed our campus
I watched it online. Simcha, I too am an ex-pat (from your neck of the woods actually) & let me tell you, you missed pomp, ceremony & majesty like only we Brits can do! It was great! Your loss, but nice sentiments. I’m sure Their Royal Hignesses the Duke & Duchess of Cambridge, not to mention the ganze mishpacha & the machatonim, appreciate your brachas 😉
Here in London our schools were all closed and yes the family watched the wedding. The mistake was that I never took the children to stand in the streets and all make a Brocho together. I told the children about Royalty and the royalty we will see when Moshiach comes will be far greater!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Yes we saw the chief Rabbi!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Good Shabbos
watched it and found it beautiful, it will deff make history. Stop being so negative about it, as a British ppl it’s something to be proud of
IT WAS AMAZING!!
To preface, I am American, and realize that my non-frum background influences my opinion on this subject. Also, let me say that I do not have a television in my house, but do have a computer with the internet and therefore access to the wedding. That said, after some deliberation, I did watch the majority of the wedding (muting out the singing, the speech from the minister, and the prayer from the royal couple). In the end of the day, I chose to watch because I felt that this was a significant event, and one of the few historically epic… Read more »
i agree. the costums were deff unusual
Rabbi, I’m quite young and I may be speaking out of ignorance, but I’ve B”H witnessed the marriage of a few of my siblings and from what I understand, the newlywed couple being in the public eye is part of a Jewish Marriage. Our ceremonies (lehavdil) are typically attended by many people and throughout the Sheva Brochos we try to keep the couple out in the open – every meal is a “Seudah” etc… Are we really “prying eyes”? don’t you think that if the couple wanted a private wedding they couldn’t have had that? On a side note, should… Read more »
today i was most defonatly proud to be british and our royal family !!! i most defonatly watched the wedding it was absoulutly beautiful
wishing our royals all the best in there life ahead and most defonatly a big MAZAL TOV
i watched some of it and it was absolutely breathtaking!
looked like a fairytale. unreal. beautiful.
totally worth watching.
oh and Her Royal Highness Princess Catherine Duchess of Cambridge looked stunning and very modest. not too overdone.
we can all learn from her.
i dnt hav a prob with rabbi sacks going, om just curious, how do u know he went?
It’s all a bit of fun!!! In times like today a little light hearted entertainment goes along way. And for the record the majority of attendees dressed more
Tzniusdik than at our crown heights weddings
if you hear that millions of people watched a royal wedding you know the world is ready for royalty and craves it.
king moshiach we are ready……….
The Rebbe also said to hold respect for Royalty. Isn’t there a blessing to say? I watched it and found it beautiful, it will deff make history. Stop being so negative about it, as a British ppl it’s something to be proud of
this was written for his secular students to learn a positive jewish message. point well made!
Number 1: Please climb out from under your rock. The hate towards your fellow humans is breathtaking.
i got up at 3am to see the first guests arrived and watched until 10:30am. i was so inspired i wish i was there in person.
A pure waste of time. What does it achieve watching their wedding ceremony, as if the Windsor family had a lifestyle that is worth to be envied, as if they were role model? I’d rather watch videos of Hasidic weddings to share in the simcha of my fellow Lubavitcher or videos of the Rebbe and his inspiring sichos that are above the time, and other videos that inspire. But a wedding in the Windsor family? Pfff
I didn’t watch because I have no TV at home, it is a waste of time and such events are not worth to be mentionned when you are a chosid, dnd it does achieve nothing as far as our mission is concerned: bringing Moshiach Now, as the Rebbe told us “Do everything you can to bring Moshiach Now”
BTW, a well written artiicle.
It’s was all over the Internet live!
i went to a guy in my shul to watch the wedding!!! it was awesome!!!! they have weird customs thow 🙂
the chief rabbi Lord Jonathan sacks was there with permission from specific rabbis the world over. it was amazing.
Actually, the wedding could be viewd on youtube and clips of it appear on many other news sites such as CNN, etc.
Because, as the Rebbe asked in the 70s we do not have a TV in the house. and that should be the same reason why everyone else did not watch the wedding.
Good Mazal – in Jewish terms is reserved only for the holy nation, namely Jewish People. Even the lowliest of the lowest rashas ch’v, Mazal Tov can be recited over. A Goy – at the most – out of respect – can be Congratulated… Congratulations!!!