ב"ה
Thursday, 15 Nisan, 5780
  |  April 9, 2020

Jewish Girl Verbally Attacked on Subway Because “You Vote Trump”

A 19-year-old Orthodox Jewish girl was the victim of an anti-Semitic verbal attack on the NY Subway when 3 black youths hurled obscenities at her and threatened to harm her; “You Jews vote for Trump.” Full Story

Photo: Wikimedia Commons

Watch: Rosh Yeshiva Addresses Bochurim

Next Story »

The High Stakes Effort To Free My Uncle

39
Opinions and Comments

To keep track of your comments, follow a conversation or flag a comment Login
avatar
  Subscribe  
newest oldest most voted
Notify of
This is what they teach in school
Guest
This is what they teach in school

If they are ever found, which I doubt will happen because the police don’t seem to be taking it seriously, they should start by investigating their teachers.
This is what the identity politics of the progressive movement which is being indoctrinated into children in schools leads to, hatred of anyone who isn’t black, particularly Jews.

Actually they hate blacks too
Guest
Actually they hate blacks too

You can’t miss articles every day in the news about how they shoot and kill each other. They enjoy hurting and damaging and, in cities like NY, where I’ve almost never seen a cop on my subway, have been given no reason to expect consequences. Criminals like the ones on that train are just ugly people who hate everyone, including themselves and while very egotistical have no dignity because they lack that level of self control that distinguished the human from the animal.

Stinks of racism
Guest
Stinks of racism

You can’t say “they” because the crimes of some, even a majority can’t be factually correlated with their skin color. All goyim, no matter race, have some degenerates, usually uneducated.

Unfortunately it IS the majority
Guest
Unfortunately it IS the majority

So, unfortunately, I will protect myself by assuming the worst of people who commit the overwhelming majority of harrassment incidents, violent crimes, including murder – unless an individual by their own merit can show that they are NOT that way. Then I am perfectly willing to think the best of them. Until then, I won’t be a fool.

Mr Steven Gold
Guest
Mr Steven Gold

Hopefully they are found and jailed ASAP !!!!

Jailed?
Guest
Jailed?

This is New York. 3 in 4 anti-Semitic assaults have no consequences.

Or you are Jewish or you want to be Jewish
Guest
Or you are Jewish or you want to be Jewish

We have to start fighting back and The bigger they are the faster and harder they go down.

Fighting back
Guest
Fighting back

The only way to address this problem is to fight back and not with words, or going to the police or the media. Learn to protect yourself by any and all means necessary, both legal and illegal if necessary.

Concerned.
Guest
Concerned.

Unfortunately, legally, it’s not an assault unless they physically harmed her. This is harassment and nothing else can be charged. BH She is ok.

WRONG
Guest
WRONG

It is a hate crime and that can, and hopefully will, If justice is done, be charged.

Not invented yet
Guest
Not invented yet

Unfortunately, they haven’t invented a hate crime classification for verbal harassment, as far as I know.

WRONG AGAIN
Guest
WRONG AGAIN

IF ITS IS not AN ACTUAL CRIME …THEN IT IS NOT A HATE CRIME

This being NYC nothing will be done about it.
Guest
This being NYC nothing will be done about it.

POC are no longer responsible for their actions because of all the white guilt from democrats & liberals running this city. The No Bail Law is a testament to their guilt. Being poor is not a crime. Committing crime is a crime just not in NYC anymore.

Not an actual crime?
Guest
Not an actual crime?

Since when intentional infliction of emotional distress or threat of violence are not crimes?

Is it assault?
Guest
Is it assault?

In the UK, making a threat (which they did here) constitutes assault and the physical follow up constitutes battery. Is it different in the USA?

WRONG AGAIN
Guest
WRONG AGAIN

as a former law enforcement officer allow me to elaborate… most countries laws differ in the United States the law differs from state to state ie; in florida assault is not an arrestable offence unless witnessed by a Law Enforcement Office in other and is defined as verbally or a motion to assault or threaten a person, in other states assault is defined a s a battery ie; unlawful touching or striking a person against their will….like we explained each state is different and additionally the jurisdiction within the state has to willing to pursue the charges, not just the… Read more »

This comment comes from an anti semite
Guest
This comment comes from an anti semite

It creates a not so subtle culture of justification for crime whether or not it openly purports to do so.

WRONG AGAIN
Guest
WRONG AGAIN

…unfortunately being an anti-Semite is NOT illegal, just like being a member of criminal street gang id NOT illegal in USA, however committing a criminal act IS illegal and can be arrested / prosecuted and even enhanced penalties for the above examples. In short the constitution works to protect even the rights of reshaim.

WHAT A DISGRACE.
Guest
WHAT A DISGRACE.

Witnessed? These thugs do this when there’s NO officer around… It’s a lousy system and now: NO BAIL? What a pathetic joke. BUT no one gets away with anything under the eyes of The Almighty.

Mr Gold
Guest
Mr Gold

Verbal assault is still assault plus violence WAS threatened!!!!

Hate crime
Guest
Hate crime

Actually, it is a hate crime to verbally abuse a person because of their race ethnicity or culture. It does not have to be violent to be considered a hate crime, but you need proof so video tape them.

Where are our leaders?
Guest
Where are our leaders?

Ok. So as an outsider please allow me to comment on the latest on-goings of Anti-Semitism in Brooklyn. We are all outraged at the outbreak of attacks. Chassidic Jews in Brooklyn (and elsewhere) are physically afraid to go about their day to day business without some form of abuse. It is also very worrying that the MSM has only minimally covered this and some local politicians haven’t even made a peep. Why? Many (or most) of us remember the Anti-Jewish Riots in Crown Heights in Aug 1991. For 3 days and nights straight there was what many called a pogrom.… Read more »

Oy! Teenagers said Not Nice things to a Jew!
Guest
Oy! Teenagers said Not Nice things to a Jew!

I hope the Police use all their resources to find these teenagers. Saying not nice things to a Jew is a huge crime.

Hmm
Guest
Hmm

And threatened her

not to be entirely fatalistic
Guest
not to be entirely fatalistic

I’ve have things shouted at me “hitler did nothing wrong” or “god bless hitler”. I imagine most distinguishable Jews have some sort of experience at some point in their life. I’ve also been punched, which is less common, but the point is these things are probably just going to happen and there’s little we can do to change it.

Reverse discrimination
Guest
Reverse discrimination

Well if it were 3 white kids on a black girl………they’d be in jail in a heartbeat….Anti Semite need to stop…..We can Thank Obama and Congress for spreading more violence that people can now get away with especially if they are of color….like the beating of the whit kids on a bus by 5 black students caught on film….they were let go saying it wasn’t a hate crime that he was wearing a hat they didn’t like….

oh no
Guest
oh no

and Jews were only attacked in Monsey with a machete instead of a ‘real’ weapon like an ‘assault rifle’…
Enough with the excuses and do something against this phenomenon of hate.

More Video Cameras on Every Subway Car
Guest
More Video Cameras on Every Subway Car

1) Put more video surveillance cameras on each subway car of a subway train. Put more surveillance cameras in station. 2) Create a Metro Card which is specific to the individual person, so repeat sex offenders and repeat subway harassers cannot enter station and ride train. This would solve Gov Cuomo’s problem of how to ban sex offenders from subways as per his recent proposal. 3) Install CONTACT POLICE Buttons on each subway car. – If pressed then MTA police are alerted and stand outside of subway incoming subway car. The specific subway car can be text messaged to the… Read more »

They don't pay
Guest
They don't pay

They hop right over the subway turnstiles and they go in the door gates when other people are coming out. The employees sitting in the booths can’t do anything. Everyone sees it happening. On the buses, they go in the back doors and do not pay there either.

WHAT A DISGRACE.
Guest
WHAT A DISGRACE.

EXCELLENT IDEAS!! THIS SHOULD BE PROPOSED.

yemach shemam
Guest
yemach shemam

Hashem, please protect us from these…

And we will
Guest
And we will

Continue to vote Trump

TRUMP 2020

Mike
Guest
Mike

Trump voters are anti semitic. My Jewish friends see him as ‘Hitler’. I was chatting to a lady who lost her folks in the Camps in 44, managed to escape via Belgium. Starts shaking when the name Trump appears, so sad!

we need to
Guest
we need to

we need to educate these poor people who clearly are being poisoned by the liberal media, and don’t know better.

What about the other passengers?
Guest
What about the other passengers?

The thing that scared her the most, the father said, was that aside for one passenger, none of the riders on the train, which was packed with the afternoon rush, said or did anything to protect his daughter.

Very scary! Do they secretly condone the harassment?
Like the 1930’s in Europe.

Mrs Pamela Hackner
Guest
Mrs Pamela Hackner

I have written so many times, all Jewish communities must learn Self Defence, if these sub human creatures know we can defend ourselves these attacks will stop. As the train was so fall, just shows what cowards they were, only one lady could help, can’t help thinking they are all the same as these subhuman. Time to make Aliya, getting like nazi Germany.

public transportation
Guest
public transportation

No police ever present they are a joke sitting in their cars blocking the bus lane and playing with their phones or drinking coffee a real third world country and with our mayor things getting worse

The solution
Guest
The solution

Will this girl victim register to outvote the democRATs. As long as you got these democRATs in power you will see these attacks. Simple Let’s all vote Trump 2020.

Other passengers
Guest
Other passengers

There was not one other Jewish person on the train who could help her? Going through that area I am sure the train had many Jews on it.

X