ב"ה
Wednesday, 26 Adar I, 5784
  |  March 6, 2024

It’s Impossible Not to See It

From the COLlive Inbox: "With what happened in Miami, Givat Zeev and Meron... It feels like Hashem is talking to us really loudly, and we need to hear it, and we need to DO something..." writes Shlucha Rivky Wilansky. Full Story

Yeshivas Hashluchim Manhattan Celebrates Smicha

Next Story »

The Rebbe Said “You Will Hear Good News”

Subscribe
Notify of
42 Comments
oldest
newest most voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Exactly
June 27, 2021 12:13 pm

Amein!!

Thank you for sharing your thoughts
June 27, 2021 12:21 pm

I too could not wrap my head around it .. 3 incidents of crushing..
Hashem is definitely trying to send us a message.
I wish we could know forsure what it is

But regardless- its definitely a wakeup call to increase in good ..
Bli neder I will hold myself back from speaking loshon hora today

Amen!!!
June 27, 2021 12:25 pm

Amazingly and beautifully said! Thank you!!

Amazing!!
June 27, 2021 12:38 pm

MOSHIACH NOW!!

Also
June 27, 2021 12:41 pm

The cable falling on Italy
Just this awareness is making a big affect!

Also
Reply to  Also
June 27, 2021 2:50 pm

She forgot to mention Eretz Yisroel being bombed

our comfort zone
Reply to  Also
June 27, 2021 5:25 pm

thank you for mentioning the cable car tragedy in Italy..and so much more heartache that we don’t even know about. perhaps I should call my mother-in-law. that for sure is going against my nature…this is what we got to do now. going out of our comfort zone in order to make another person happy. it’s not about us as individuals anymore… it’s about the welfare of the OTHER person………..am arousal from below will elicit
an arousal from Above…………..

If one person really wanted Moshiach, he’d be here
June 27, 2021 12:44 pm

great words do not Moshiach bring.

The only way to learn and inspire is through words

Look how many ‘words’ are written in the Torah
And said by the Rebbe
Of course the goal and the point is action
But it usually must go through thought speech and action before it gets to action
So you can perhaps thank and appreciate words

True

But unfortunately it end up staying…… just words. The Torah says, the Rebbe says – question is: do the chassidim do? Without the doing, face it, we are 27 years after gimmel tammuz! And the Rebbe said words:DO all that you can! Have we?!

Hmm
Reply to  True
June 27, 2021 5:08 pm

Idk if this is the same person as the first person who commented… but my response to u is: so WHY don’t you do it!
Thanks for making it seem so easy 🙁

No it's a different person
Reply to  Hmm
June 27, 2021 6:01 pm

Why dont I do it? Because the Rebbe pointed his finger at YOU too! I didnt say it’s easy, I said we have to DO it, instead of pointing fingers at someone else (which has been going on since before gimmel tammuz) . And if no one does it ( since being busy pointing fingers at everyone but themselves and just “words, talking” about it) then the original commenter is correct. ( the truth hurts, I understand but people have to stop talking/whining why is it not here when they dont do anything to make him come. It’s like screaming… Read more »

Mindset
Reply to  True
June 27, 2021 6:10 pm

Looking at how far we are doesn’t bring Moshiach, it makes us do less. What can I do, not my neighbor and not my friend, what will I add at this moment to bring Moshiach is the mindset we must have.

I agree with the mindset
Reply to  Mindset
June 27, 2021 7:35 pm

But unfortunately it just stays an idea. People have to want it not just keep it as an idea or words. If I do a mitzvah and I go to someone and encourage the person to do one more mitzvah to bring moshiach, why am i being “slapped” for it? And not just by one person. You see it time and again, then something is highly wrong in the chinuch system. It’s a great mindset but reality tells you otherwise.

Non expert

And your suggestion is…..?
(We can definitely not ignore these occurrences!)

Great Words bring Moshiach!

A desire and yearning for Moshiach does not come from nowhere. One must sow and cultivate a longing for the Geulah, constantly! The first step is to learn. Learning is done through great words.

Hashem doesn’t expect what we cannot do. We each just need to start with something.

... MAYBE NOT, BUT

THEY CERTAINLY CONTRIBUTE TO HASTENING HIS COMING;THAT IS, IF THE WORDS COME FROM THE HEART, AS THIS SHLUCHA’S WORDS OBVIOUSLY DO. WORDS ARE HOW PEOPLE COMMUNICATE, ORGANIZE, SHARE IDEAS THAT HELP REACH GOALS ETC. ETC. WORDS ARE WHAT THE MINHA’ENUSHI/ THE MIDAHBER HAS OVER OTHER CREATIONS.OF HASHEM. USE THEM CONSTRUCTIVELY AND THEY WILL, INDEED, HASTEN THE COMING OF MOSHIACH. BTW, AS MANY HAVE HEARD AT VARIOUS SHIURIM,,THE WORD “MOSHIACH” IS CLOSELY RELATED TO THE WORD “MAYSIACH” I.E. BY CONSTRUCTIVELY SPEAKING ABOUT THE INYAN OF MOSHIACH WE CAN MOTIVATE PEOPLE TO HANG IN THERE AND WORK TOWARDS SELF-IMPROVEMENT, WHICH, IN TURN,WILL… Read more »

everywhere
June 27, 2021 12:52 pm

This is all just so crazy. I always think about ahavas yisroel. It’s so important and so lacking. Schools, shuls, everywhere.

Who is a Jew
Reply to  everywhere
June 28, 2021 2:56 pm

Better to see the good in others.

there still needs to be more connecting of the dot
June 27, 2021 1:04 pm

The words you wrote are reassuring – having said that there still needs to be a greater movement to take the words to the corridors of power including all sectors of influence – to me it is a race of how far will Hashem allow us to potentially attribute all the things that are happening to man versus Hashem sending loud messages as you properly stated that Moshiah is desperate to come NOW – we just have to mobilize the “influencers” to elevate the We Want Moshiah NOW outcry and no more disasters

To me it seems like the same concept as a siege
June 27, 2021 1:08 pm

Before H destroyed the BHMK there was a siege on Yerushalayim The deeper meaning is: if you can’t get along, I’ll stick you all together — the solution is togetherness Like being stuck on an island, or in an elevator, with the most annoying person — you’ll have to figure out how to get along The same thing with the crushing We’re being pushed together We’re being told to stop running away from each other and to stick together Just like Hashem bound us together in a siege before destroy BHMK Hashem binds us together in crushing We need to… Read more »

Very Well Thought Out Article!
June 27, 2021 1:25 pm

Rivky, I don’t know you, but Yasher Koach on writing so beautifully and expressively from your heart. You were able to give voice to what I (and probably so many others feel) but could not capture in words as poignantly as you, especially as we search to find meaning as to so many tragedies befalling the Jewish people and the world in such a short amount of time. You gave me a “WOW” moment connecting the “crushing” with the olives. Gives me a lot to think about. Wishing you and your family and K’lal Yisrael well and…MOSHIACH NOW!

Well written
June 27, 2021 1:46 pm

But we have to practice what we preach. People have to WANT the hisgalus of our Rebbe MHM. And for close to 30 years they have learned every single sicha, mamaar etc… but do they WANT IT?! Our Rebbe in koach nissan left it upto us – to do all that WE CAN! Obviously we didn’t otherwise we could have been with our Rebbe again. We left it upto our Rebbe before gimmel tammuz and our Rebbe left it upto us. Conclusion: nothing changed! face it, just in the parasha of shidduchim, what is REALLY going on?! Are we REALLY… Read more »

Do good!
Reply to  Well written
June 28, 2021 12:59 pm

Judaism is much much much more focused on actions, rather than beliefs. The need for Torah and mitzvos, gemilus chasadim etc. is everywhere. It is not a hidden challenge, it is not something impossible to do or figure out what is needed. Learning in depth, doing mitzvos will definitely help people grow in their faith, but a pashut faith in Hashem, while accepting not understanding everything but knowing Hashem asked us to have ahavas yisroel, study torah, do mitzvos is not what is holding up moshiach, on the contrary. Also, it is not all or nothing, Hashem put us in… Read more »

Passion
June 27, 2021 1:55 pm

I salute the passion and effort of this post writer. I also acknowledge that we are hungry for reasons, and that we must be able to influence things that seem beyond our control. But the fact that we are desperate to be able to control, and that we then conjure up some super force to which we decide we have connection, does not necessarily make those things factual. It does create within us the desire to try, and often the human can do things we thought we couldn’t. And since nature includes things we consider bad and good, both happen.… Read more »

Tante malke and uncle yosie
June 27, 2021 2:18 pm

So very well written, as usual! Rivky, u can mamesh write books! Bh.

Amen!!
June 27, 2021 2:54 pm

Thank you for sharing!

One idea
June 27, 2021 3:11 pm

Thousands of police and soldiers are gathering in evyttar as we speak to uproot Jews from the land of Yisroel, which the Rebbe said to settle….while Arabs are building on every inch of land without paying and without prohibitions. So yes, there is a little more you could be doing besides writing words that stoke emotions but in the end, have no substance or ability to effect change. Too bad we have to be crushed and can’t merit the geulah without being crushed. The words are not the problem….let’s think though about shouting them in these hallowed news sites before…and… Read more »

Ahavas Yisroel
Reply to  One idea
June 28, 2021 9:56 am

I am unsure why this commenter writes there is little one can do.

There is plenty to be done and that each individualcan take upon themselves!!

The mission is to bring Moshiach!
This is accomplished through Tefila and Tzedaka and Ahavas Yisroel.

If one is doing aveiros with their mouth and harming a fellow Jew by speaking about them – we are not only not moving forward we are bringing tragedy upon Klal Yisroel. The same mouth that is used to hurt people their Tefilos are not easily accepted.
#Think B4 U Speak
#Mission Ahavas Chinam

Another?
June 27, 2021 3:30 pm

“ותלחץ רגל בלעם אל הקיר”
ותלחץ can be translated as pressed or crushed.

Ahavas Yisroel
June 27, 2021 4:44 pm

Thank you Rivky. It’s important that we take to heart these horrific tragedies in our midst. Ahavas Chinam is our goal Eradicate Sinas Chinam, which is why our holy Beis Hamikdash was destroyed. If we want to bring Moshiach we must focus on how we treat our fellow his, and mitzvos Bein Adam l’chaveiro. We had a terrible mageifa, we had to cover our mouths. What more do we need a sign that it is long overdue to study and practice Shmiras HaLashon. We are united by tragedy. How sad that Hasheem sees people talking behind their neighbors, brothers, mothers… Read more »

Go back to the basics
June 27, 2021 5:54 pm

All what was written may possibly be true, but it is in addition to what should be obvious. Before we go looking for deeper and hidden reasons, we need to see the Pshat. What is before our eyes,what is obvious. We just need to be much more careful!! Midat Hazehirut! All of these terrible accidents could have been prevented! If only people would listen to professionals, to engineers! Take advice! In 2018 the building in Surfside was deemed unstable. In Meron for years people have been warning about the dangers. People weren’t careful enough about the Corona virus either… Etc.… Read more »

Disagree. Missing the point.
Reply to  Go back to the basics
June 27, 2021 8:10 pm

These tragedies are sent from Hashem. Dont look to blame and say it could have been prevented.
Hashem is sending a loud and clear message to each and every one of us.
The Rambam said it clearly that we should not see a tragedy as Happenstance. It is a wake up call.

Do Teshuvah!!

A connected article
June 27, 2021 6:23 pm

Well written and and the spot. Here is my weekly article of last week:                                                                                                           BS”D REESTABLISHING THE CROWN TO ITS      FORMER GLORY…AND MORE   Rabbi Yeheskel Lebovic   WHY KING DAVID?   “I will see him, but not now, I will look at him, but not at a proximity, a star will shoot from Yaakov and a scepter will arise from Yisroel, and he will smash the corners of Moav and eradicate all the children of Sheth” (Numbers 24:17, in this week’s Sidra of Balak). The Rambam (Hilchos Melachim 11:1) writes that the repetitive, double terminology of this verse is… Read more »

C M
June 27, 2021 11:16 pm

Beautiful.

Youre words are heartwarming.

We must take a stand as a community and do all we can to bring Moshiach now.

Golus is not for us.

Encouraging
June 28, 2021 4:46 am

Beautiful answer from the Rebbe

The physical
June 28, 2021 3:13 pm

All of the incidents happened because there were physical problems that should have been corrected. We have to care about the physical world and not ignore what needs fixing in it. This is not attributing the suffering to the ways of the world. It is a mitzva of putting a fence on one’s roof. It is the summertime. People will be going on trips and going swimming. B’ezras Hashem, everyone should be safe but people have to be careful. Moshiach now!

Ahavas Yisroel
Reply to  The physical
June 28, 2021 8:54 pm

There is nothing wrong to be vigilant in safety. It is not contradicting that there is inner work to be done. When a tragedy occurs it is for a purpose.
Nothing happens without Hashems will.
Every person should open their eyes to tragedies befallen Klal Yisroel and look to end Machlokes. Be careful not to say s/t (or text s/t) that causes pain to another yid.

We must improve on our midos.

It says “B’Shalom Teepadeh”
We will merit the Geula through being united.
#United against Lashon Hara
#Ahavas Chinam
May we merit Moshiach NOW!

Beautiful words you shared!
June 28, 2021 4:09 pm

I would also put a large emphasis on Ahavas Yisroel. Moshiach will come regardless of whether or not everyone is perfect, but by improving in Ahavas Yisroel and Shalom, we likely will avoid other such tragedies. It is a fact that Shalom brings Brachah!!

Since when?
June 29, 2021 8:46 am

… can one atribute 45 people being crushed to anything? … can one atribute 2 people dying to a message? ….can one atribute a building collapsing and killing individuals to anything. Although hashem has a plan who are you to say why people died? how can you say that Ploni Ben Ploni dies because of E.g.? What gives this individual the right to justify death by saying hashemn is sending a message. the reson hashem let these people die is for a reason i will never know and neither will you till moshiach. i pray everyday that moshiach will come,… Read more »

The Rambam writes about tragedies
Reply to  Since when?
June 29, 2021 10:59 pm

It is very tragic and painful for our brethren to have such a calamity strike. We do not have prophets anymore. And no one is saying what caused it. However, the Rambam specifies that when tragedy occurs to our fellow jews, it is incumbent on every jew to look into their own deeds and not take it as Happenstance and to realize that a tragedy in our midst is a message from Hashem. The Rambam further states that one should look to improve on Mitzvos between man and G-d and Mitzvos Bein Adam L’Chaveiro, especially to focus on Ahavas Yisroel.… Read more »

The message??
June 30, 2021 10:27 am

I understand your frustration that it soun6like people are justifying that people deserve this calamity due to specific Aveiros. That is not what is being said. Every occurence in someones life is Hashem’s will and no one can claim to know why s/t tragic happened. Yet, there still is a message being sent. The message is to take a message from the tragedy. Your own personal message on what needs improvement. Ahavas Yisroel is a good suggestion but it may be that you exemplify in this midah. So basically, open your eyes, heart and mind to take the horrific event… Read more »

X