VIDEO
Is Using WiFi Considered Stealing
Rabbi Nachman Wilhelm of Online Smicha: Is connecting to unsecured WiFi considered stealing according to halacha? Video
Rabbi Nachman Wilhelm of Online Smicha: Is connecting to unsecured WiFi considered stealing according to halacha? Video
since most people dont know much about I.T or tech in general let me break it down WIFI internet or internet in general works in limited environments so you cant have unlimited amount of data per secound. To simplify lets compare it to shipping company who has a limited amount of trucks going from Nyc to La each day. and can only handle 500 boxes. can I now sneak some boxes on to a truck because the trucks are going any way? obviously not since I am occupying space that belongs to someone(if i load 10 boxes he can now… Read more »
why according to the Raavad would we say that he would consider taking Wi-Fi as gneiva, he brought a pasuk from
“yom terua …lachem”, i.e. this is a special pasuk which shows you have to own the Shofar. How do we compare that to Wi-Fi where it does not say “lachem”?
Which Kuntres was the Rabbi quoting from?
There are places that provide free wi-fi to attract customers using computers — public libraries or Starbucks
Public wifi like optimum wifi and Let’s say Target wifi are probably not an issue.I have stopped logging on to other wifis since it might be a problem
From the 10 minute video one cannot and should not come to any Halachik conclusion. The only purpose of the video is the give you enough understanding, that there is a problem with just hitching onto any WiFi that is open. One must ask their Rov, before even attempting to use someone’s internet without permission.
The rabbis recorded classes are no longer then ten min, I know that everyone can find 10 Mn in their day for the shiur
Encryption does not slow down the flow of internet. Wireless devices are made to handle it.
– IT Guru.
the answer is: machloket. great, i love those answers,
because that means that i get to choose.
obviously not.
Can we have a summary of what he said for thos that don’t have time to watch the video?
1) how do you knowhat he is not using his internet ? 2) are we saying kofin al midas sdom on a goy? 3) sometimes stores are giving free service BECAUSE they are getting business from you, they surely don’t want this kind of parasites… 4) MAYBE the wifi waves belongs to the internet company and they are giving permission to their customers to use according their plan they are paying for and if so, it’s not up to your neighbour to decide whether he gives permission or not, the company owns the wifi waves and they BEFEIRUSH don’t let… Read more »
There is a third possibility that someone does not even know, that a password is needed, and that person, if told that people are using their internet, he will block it. There is even another reason why someone leaves the internet without password, as to speed up the internet. (Through the use of a password, files, and internet are encrypted and de-crypted) slowing down the flow of the internet. Therefore, there is the possibility, that he is Makpid. Also, how does one know when the internet is used? Day or night, and furthermore, IF the paying owner of the internet… Read more »
‘Todah’ Rabbi Nachman Wilhelm & COLLive.com