By Rabbi Levi Browd – Director of Yagdil Torah
If you thought Peta was bad wait ’till you meet this nemesis. Sly, incipient, creeping and greedy. And many don’t even know it’s there. How can we protect ourselves against such an invisible force?
Many of us experienced outrage over the three or four different groups that came to Crown Heights this erev Yom Kippur to protest a sacred minhag.
Though their presence came as no surprise to us, as they have been making an annual practice out of condemning kapporos, it incensed us nonetheless.
“From where do these modern day organizations find the authority to denounce an age old Jewish custom?” we mused, as if there were any credibility to their preposterous arguments. They know as well as we what the Torah has to say against animal cruelty, yet they had the nerve to try and undermine kapporos’ source in the Torah; turning our own sources against us!
Imagine, if you will, a similar force, assaulting and questioning the very fabric of your life as a Jew. Though this force doesn’t take on the form of a public activist organization, but rather it is a silent killer. How would you react upon discovering a force within your midst that has been slowly but surely planting doubt and cultivating disinterest in the things that a Jew holds most dear and meaningful? Outrage, disgust, horror?
It may be time for some of us to take a deeper look to verify that such a force had indeed not crept into our lives and taken hold of our schedules. Are we sure that the allure of modern day, secular culture has not distracted us from what we essentially know to be the most productive way to focus our minds and our time?
Have we, perhaps, allowed the constant struggle to keep up with the latest that our society has to offer overshadow the importance of what has really kept us together for centuries? Has the internet, the Iphone, the GPS, replaced timeless pages of gemora for us?
Does the job, the gym leave time for a shiur in our day?
While the world around us and all of its tempting glamour may not be as outspoken or deliberate as, for example, PETA’s attack on our religious practices, its effects can be all the more damaging. Precisely because it is silently chipping away at our priorities does it successfully escape our radar, replacing whatour most valuable and treasured lifestyle for fleeting moments of gratification.
Chazal and Chassidus are replete with powerful statements that describe both the obligation and privilege of Torah learning. StatingSaying that it is the purpose of for man’s existence, comparing it to all other mitzvos and depicting the unity with Hashem that it brings about.
In HaYom Yom, the Rebbe went so far as to say that “Daily Torah-study is crucial to life itself. This applies not only to the soul of the one studying but also to the souls of his family. It is through Torah that the atmosphere of
the home becomes an atmosphere of Torah and piety.”
Let us preserve what is most precious to a Yid’s being, without allowing any outside influences to encroach oin a Torah true lifestyle.
When we do this, we are assured blessings in all critical areas of life such as parnassa, health, peace, etc.
“Torah iz di beste schorah”
kol hakavod to Rabbi Browed!
These people are sooo dumb!
I’m dumbfounded! They all eat meat, I’m sure.
These chickens are being shechted anyway, so they may as well be done for Kapores…
I do my chitas and rambam on my cool iphone.
Yeah!
#19,
you will be able to tear yourself away from the computer to say shema with your children if you think of who they might be in 15 years from now, with or without your loving input. They only have ONE mommy to do this. Nobody else counts to them!
1000 per cent true. i asked my husband not to get an iphone for exactly that reason. yes there are advantages but what are the subliminal messages our kids are receiving.
..and you believe that? I guess you haven’t seen Kapporos in CH…(I know that’s what’s supposed to happen but it’s not the case..
for some reason i always regret eating chinese bout 2 hours later:)
and what’s wrong w/ being musserdik? why do we have have to walk on eggshels ? where were in CH the talented speakers instilling in us awe prior to Y’K as done in othet communities? Do you think that the RAMBAM was being too musserdik when he tell us (Hilchos Teshuva) to wake up from our tardema???
Couldnt agree more!!! chinese food is taake a gishmak…
chinese food rocks!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! especially sweet and sour chicken
good stuff. im leaving this computer now.
those are words of the yetzer hora enclothed in a zeidene kapute its called laitzanus (defined as pushing away a word of rebuke because of some silly detail)
I really have to agree with this op-ed. Though I myself am not 100% perfect, it still hurts to walk down the streets of the Rebbe’s Shchuna and see things that I wouldn’t want my children to see. This op-ed is just so true- it’s so hard for me to tear myself away from the computer just to do the shema routine with my children. I really have to think about this every time something like that gets in the way. Kol hakavod!
A bit too Musser’dik sorry.
totally agree
kol hakavod, Rabbi Browd
chazak veamatz!
I guess u consider yourself part of the choir. B”H u have kvius in learning every day, and may everyone follow in your footsteps
PETA is an organization that refers to fish as “individuals”, I’ll start to take ur points seriously when we start to produce those kinds of kooks ourselves
Rabbi Levi Browd wrote: “They know as well as we what the Torah has to say against animal cruelty…”
Yes, so participants should adhere to these laws and principles. The way kapporos is now conducted on a massive industrial scale has led to egregious violations of tza’ar ba’alei chayim.
The chicken shouldn’t see other chickens being slaughtered. It’s ‘Halacha.’
Seriously…cover it’s face or something
The chicken ‘seeing’ is ‘tzar bal hachai.’
What are you saying is chipping away from within? The midos? Recently I was shocked at a simcha when a former Bais Rivka girl now woman, arrived in a short black dress. I did a double take because not only was it really unattractive, it was the length I use to wear when i didn’t know any better. They are so smug about it now, but will regret their foolish attraction after its too late. So sad.
soon, because of PETA it will be forbidden to kill a mosquito that keeps us from sleeping.
And btw, I’m 100% in agreement with this op-ed. Very well written.
These people have no problem having abortions but have a problem with chickens. What a farce! Just listen to the Torah and you’ll know whats right!!
they care more about bloody chickens then about humans!! they pur rubashkin in prison!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
peta did have an effect on me
i have been struggling with the idea of holding the chicken
i cant deal with it
this year, somehow i thought,” enough, i tried.
i’ll do money instead”
then it came to my attention how the Rebbe held the chicken by Kapores.
ever so gently and respectfully
gaba kook
it may change your K experience
it did mine
thank you P for helping make my K experience more meaningful.
🙂
it’s a good point!
and to #1 – truth hurts!
“maybe not through out all the chickens”
theyre not thrown out, theyre used for ppl that need it
There is a story (just the highlights) where a maagid comes to a town and tells the people all the bad things they are doing. The Baal Shemtov castigates the maagid as these townfolk are fine people full of merits. This article comes in light of kapores. The author calls this an age old Jewish custom (as far as Jewish custom goes – Kapores is really not that old). Here we have all these very good people who come in the middle of the night, the day before yom kippur to twirl a chicken in the street in the hope… Read more »
beautiful and well brought out
I’m disappointed with this “bait and switch” in the headline. I know this is common practice in the media but I was personally let down. Although I’ll give him credit cause it worked.
When I saw the headline I got excited that there was actually somewhere out there that was being open minded and perhaps taking some lessons from the demonstrators i.e. maybe we should make some improvements to the kapporos conditions, maybe not through out all the chickens. Then all I saw was the same preaching to the choir.