By Aliza BasMenachem
I got to the designated area well before the scheduled time of 7a.m. The website had said to come early. It was colder than I had expected. I dressed for the reported 40 degrees, but not for the intermittent chilling winds.
This was not the first time I had rallied with Trump supporters. I have been to Trump rallies, Pence rallies, and to an event hosted by Women for Trump. A major part of the reason I like to attend is the good energy. It’s invigorating. The cold temperature on the 6th had a sobering effect on the people, but the good energy was still there.
With the exception of a few eccentrics, whom I consider add interest to the gatherings, I find Trump supporters to be wholesome people. They have what I consider to be American values. They respect families, they respect law, they like to have friends and have a good time. And if a good time is not provided for them, they know how to make a good time happen. We were outdoors standing around for hours, and people were cheerful and hopeful. They embodied positive attitudes.
I met two groups of people from Idaho, people from Texas, South Carolina, Maine, North Dakota, and Ohio. Those are the states I can remember.
There were so many flags! People really appreciate Trump and like to express that appreciation when they get the chance. And not just flags. They wear all sorts of Trump products. But the flags are the most visible.
The subway station I used that morning was close to my hotel, and there were a number of us setting out together. No one really knew where we were going, but when we got to our desired station, we stepped off the train and just followed the flags.
As dawn was breaking, we watched as streams of flag carrying Americans could be seen coming from all directions, merging into one large avenue that had been blocked off to accommodate them.
I came early and I left early. So I wasn’t there when the Capitol building was stormed.
The rally involved so many people, hundreds of thousands, bordering on half a million… had they been angry and aggressive, the results of the attack would have been even more catastrophic than what actually happened. But the crowd was not angry. I find that amazing. People were concerned. They traveled and stood in the cold to show support for their President. But they were orderly, responsible, respectful individuals. That is why I am glad I was there. To me a Trump supporter is not what the media is portraying them as. They would never dream of doing what will be remembered on January 6th, 2021.
Once the speeches started, from where I was standing, there was a hush so we could hear over the speakers. Behind me, a man shouted out, “We should storm the Capitol. We outnumber them. They can’t stop us.” That was about 10 a.m. It was hours before the actual storming.
Hearing this incitement, I looked around, curious to see the reaction to such a call to arms. The reaction was a strong non-reaction. No one took the bait. I wondered if the man was a ‘plant’. Someone looking for recruits, so storming could be staged, making it look like Trump supporters were storming the Capitol. From the lack of reaction, I was sure it wouldn’t happen.
But it did happen. And I believe there were Trump supporters involved. But I also believe the video evidence and personal reports of a coordinated initial breakthrough, and then Trump supporters getting swept in without prior intention.
When I first heard the call to action by the man behind me, I couldn’t help but think he was right. The idea was right. But carrying it out would be wrong. I believe there is tremendous corruption in the Capitol. To get to DC I had driven across Pennsylvania. I never cease to marvel at well cared for farmland. Huge fields that require tremendous work, and they all look cultivated and ready for each season as it comes. I was driving past these fields the day or so after the Congress had made some declaration about not using words like mother and father. And then the person saying the opening prayer says amen and a woman. I wondered if Congress even knew that farmers in Pennsylvania existed. I never asked the farmers, but I doubt they care about the words being ceremoniously used or not used. They use cow dung to fertilize their fields, not for virtual signaling. My point being, the Congress is not serving the people well. Our institutions of education, entertainment and media are tainted with destructive leftist ideas. And now there was a stolen election, as known to anyone who took the time to avail themselves of what Mayor Giuliani and his team had uncovered. So the question becomes, why not storm the Capitol?
To be successful, the storming would have to be done with a plan. If the only plan is destruction, then the results are self destructive. The January 6th inciters knew that. The people who got swept up at the moment couldn’t see past the moment. The result was chaos and confusion, which would be followed by a smear campaign against President Trump and the hundreds of thousands of American patriots with American values who would never dream of storming a government building.
At previous rallies in DC, Antifa was visible. At this rally, there was no visible Antifa. They could easily have been embedded in the crowds, appearing to be Trump supporters.
It reminds me of the evacuation of Gush Katif, when pro-Disengagement thugs mingled with the settlers. It also reminds me of 1994 when the world turned on “settlers” because of the interpretation of what happened with Boruch Goldstein in Hevron. The one who controls the media wins the alleged reality.
I don’t know how I would have perceived January 6th, 2021, had I not been part of that massive crowd and felt its goodness, calm and optimism.
I am writing this from my hotel room. The downstairs lounge is closed because of the Covid response. I am under curfew until 6a.m. We have no chance to gather with others and casually share out thoughts.
I have no idea what the next few weeks will bring. Now is one of those times when Emunah is especially comforting.
I do expect that fresh, powerful, good, conservative leaders will emerge. I’m impressed with some of a new group of women elected to Congress under the label of Republican. I am hopeful a few of them will raise their voices together and create a favorable impact. I saw James O’Keefe of Project Vertias operating near the rally. He posted a short video after the storming. His words were encouraging and based on action, not just empty words. The time is right for people who might otherwise not become public figures to rise to the occasion.
What happened on January 6th, 2021 is confusing. I personally appreciate what Trump has done and that he has done his job with a pleasant demeanor. I fear what a leftist government can do. But I know Hashem has a plan. And it is not chaos. I trust that Moshiach is the true globalist leader who will bring goodness to the world. Please Hashem. This time we mean it. We really want Moshiach NOW!
Yes, most of the people there were good people – like you. But please don’t leave out the part where the president whom you came to support was said clearly and openly to march to the Capital, to ‘be strong’ and not be ‘weak’…what do you think he had in mind?? Is he so stupid or so delusional that he didn’t know how at least some of his supporters in that group would take it?? He wasn’t talking to you – you don’t matter to him; he was talking to the backpackers who brought arms! He was talking to the… Read more »
THE TROUBLE MAKERS WERE ANTIFA AGAIN. BUT NO ONE WILL TALK ABOUT IT AS ITS NOT THE NARRATIVE OF THE HATEFUL LEFT
Sidney Powell posted evidence: https://parler.com/post/88d4c6020ce449548240c18392e5d9be
Im afraid youre buying into the CNN narrative that the instigators of violence and property destruction would want to stick as the indelible take-away message of what happened. Nancy Pelosi, whos admitted holding-back financial relief to people who lost their business to riots (where the arsons were released with the funds given by Kamala Harris) is even bringing a motion to have Trump impeached today. We cant join their narrative. When Trump was pleading for strength, what he meant was expressed by Senator Ted Cruz from Texas: There were 6 States which were contested because of significant findings of systemic… Read more »
Although we respect and admire Trump as “Friend of the Jews,” he tends to speak before his brain engages. Unfortunately this gives fodder to the Left when thy attack him, and tends to get him in trouble. He made some wonderful decisions but for whatever reason Hashem chose for him to serve for 4 years, and a return to idiots to be in charge…
I personally appreciate what Trump has done and that he has done his job with a pleasant demeanor.
Are you for real?
Thank you for writing this.
Amazing to see how people have forgotten about the Antifa/BLM violence and looting several months ago that caused over a billion dollars in damages and vandalized almost a dozen shuls around the country.
At previous rallies in DC, Antifa was visible. At this rally, there was no visible Antifa. They could easily have been embedded in the crowds, appearing to be Trump supporters.
Maybe people are who they say they are not everything is a false flag
You were one of thousands at a rally. You obviously were looking through rose colored lenses. Those of us who followed on the internet or radio were horrified and even terrified. Probably no frum people participated in the attempt to overturn our democracy. At least I hope so.
Speaking of rose colored glasses, I personally know quite a few frum people who attended.
This isn’t something you should brag about. I’m so embarrassed that frum Jews participated in this terrorist attack.
Just a note; I didn’t read the “To Bubby” commenter as bragging about the frum Jews who participated. I thought they were informing “Bubby” that indeed, there were frum people there, sadly. I usually refrain from even scrolling down to the comments on COL articles, but was just too curious about this one. I’m relieved to see that at least some people here are against all of Trump’s outrageous and despicable behavior. I wish more Jewish people would see through the cloud, and beyond just what the president does for Israel and regarding Iran. Is your president moral? Is he… Read more »
” Joe Biden and Kamala Harris are lightyears ahead of Trump in moral character and competence to run this country.”
Give me a break. just because you don’t like Trump doesn’t mean that these clowns/crooks are any good.
This is probably one of the most pathetic lines I have read.
I actually feel sorry for the naïve delusional person who wrote this, so so blinded by what the media tells him/her to think.
Hahah those of us that followed internet and media? Are u delussionedddd.. thats where the fake news is lol. they have like black glasses on or something
Because “the internet or radio” tell only the truth, and don’t slant anything, right?
And no one was trying to “overturn our democracy” (we’re a republic, by the way, not a democracy), but to exercise their constitutional right to protest (and not the kind of “protesting” that means looting and arson, either).
Talking about looking through a censored glass, how can your argument possibly be, “those of us watching on the internet/radio” vs someone there on site, don’t be blinded.
I would never defend the violence, and won’t blame it completely on antifa.
But please do not use the media as your reference to argue with this women watched first hand.
To the author, thank you for the perspective, was not a feel good day yesterday, and it some conciliation knowing that thousands of trump supporters had this organized.
The internet and radio have the distinct advantage in that you can see many different locations and from several angles at the same time, and thus get a “bigger” picture overall!
As a media professional myself (though not a news one), I agree with this. Multiple cameras represent multiple sets of eyes. Collective commentary is tantamount to “two heads are better than one,” and edited media is (potentially) intellectually greater than the sum of it’s components. That’s why we have it. I’m not saying the media has no slant and that it doesn’t sensationalize things (they do want to keep you watching), but referring to the media as one whole Leftist force against humanity is nothing short of a CONSPIRACY. Don’t fall for it, people, you’re better than that. Besides, it… Read more »
The very idea that one person’s account/perspective should be held to a higher standard than the reportage of the day is ill-thought-out. The reporting takes footage from many vantage points whereas the individual only has their own – a single shot of the day’s events. I’m glad she didn’t run into any of the Proud Boys wearing those Anti-Semetic shirts. And I’m glad the media was able to gather enough footage to capture that image for the world to see. Otherwise, how would she know who her fellow marchers were? How would you? Although, I’d expect that you’d say they… Read more »
Nuance is important. Yes not everyone wanted to storm the capital. Not everyone was angry and violent.
But at the same time it is very clear what happened here, by propagating completely debunked conspiracies about election fraud trump invited these ppl to the point where they became violent.
He told the crouds of ppl chearing for him to go to the capital and protest.
Problem is when you rise the temperature that much you can no longer control the outcome.
But he is fully responsible
And who is respomsible for the antifa and blm protests? The one and only Joe Biden.
was he the one that killed Floyd?
I don’t remember Biden telling anyone to fight a war or organizing a protest telling anyone to charge a capital. He repeatedly called for peace.
No, he just called Antifa “an idea.” As if “ideas” burn things down. The “peace” he’s calling for is the kind that abusive spouses demand: you won’t get hurt if you just do as I say.
but Kamala sure did. she is the poster girl of everything we don’t want in a vice president..
Biden is a garden variety politician crook who lines his pockets and is sadly moving towards dementia
Who exactly debunked the fraud.No court l heard the case because they’re afraid of Antifa and riots. Numbers don’t lie. It’s a statistically impossible that Biden won. Don’t deny the science.
but conspiracy presidents do. if you haven’t seen yet, mike pence admitted defeat. literally every republican has, besides for trump. and it isn’t statistically impossible for Biden to win.
peggy6824 writes: • Ballots that were preprinted for Biden per Jovan Pulitzer. • Thousands of affidavits from both Democrat & Republican witnesses (across the nation) who have attested to the fraud committed by Democrats as well as video recordings. • 200,000 more ballots cast in PA then the number of people who voted. • 460,000 absentee ballots in GA that they are unable to account for. • Two different ballots printed for Democrats & Republicans in GA by Runbeck Election Services in AZ. The Republican ones with a barcode, the Democrat ones without & using the Winkler+Dünnebier BB700-S2 inserter (linked… Read more »
How come every election case was thrown out of court?
Please stop reciting conspiracy theory, there was ample opportunity to show judges this “evidence” and convince the various courts.
Says woman who supported the “Leopards Eating Peoples Faces” party.
Did you not see the many photos of people wearing clothing with openly anti-Semitic rhetoric? Do you feel that they, too, “add interest to the gatherings”?
True. Why do some here support such an openly racist and anti-Semitic group, anyway?
Are you aware that this Senator was denounced by several rabbis for antisemitic rhetoric?
You should be ashamed of yourself. That at this stage in the fiasco of the trump experiment you still stand by this rhetoric and attitude is beyond comprehension.
” I also believe the video evidence and personal reports of a coordinated initial breakthrough, and then Trump supporters getting swept in without prior intention.”
SO???
I was there right up front at the back of the Capitol building what I experienced and saw we’re a lot of people wanting redress and all they got from their representatives was silence they needed an excuse to not hear the evidence about election fraud so they let those people into the Capitol building to give themselves an excuse and then they call it riots storming of the Capitol building I was there it didn’t happen those people were let in by the Capitol Police and admittedly some of the planted people who wanted to make the Patriots look… Read more »
Thanks well written
This reminds me of queen Elizabeth of England. When princess diana died the queen was afraid she would been thrown off the throne for what she did to diana and yet the country allowed her to stay and let her rule over them. Horrible! Same is now. But at least here the people fought till the end. Like President Trump said – biden will be president but we fought as warriors! There’s just gotta be a way to throw “higher people” out. We’ll fight with all our might! People will disagree with my comment, it’s sad because you certainly would… Read more »
“What happened on January 6th, 2021 is confusing.”
Confusing. CONFUSING. ARE YOU OKAY?!
What happened yesterday was a terrorist attack against democracy. Someone died. The capitol was stormed. There was a confederate flag in the capitol.
This wasn’t confusing. This was insurrection, and Trump and anyone who voted for that awful sad excuse of a man is guilty of yesterdays crimes.
You fail to mention that that “someone” was shot by the Capitol police, not by the protestors. Are you leaving out that detail out of ignorance, or out of malice?
The confederate flag is the Democrats flag
History people
The confederate flag was in the South. We fought a war to remove it from the Capitol. Yesterday white supremists dragged through the Capitol building. The Democratic party of today is not socialist. It’s liberal. Liberalism isn’t socialism. The Republican party of today has changed tremendously. It used to be moderate. Now it’s become extremely right wing. The Torah teaches us that we should not be extreme.
…Are you being willfully ignorant, or are you completely blind to reality. Their most outspoken members are Marxists, socialists and outright communists! The Republican Party has become the true moderates!
The Confederate flag never was in the Capitol anytime during the Civil War, so no, we did not “fight a war to remove it.” Some “history buff” you are. “Liberalism isn’t socialism”? Really? Then why do the socialists – Sanders, de Blasio, AOC – find their natural home in it? And maybe you can explain what’s “extremely right wing” about not wanting babies killed in the womb, saying that marriage is between a man and a woman, and so forth? Your “Torah” may say that “we should not be extreme,” but the actual Torah says that when necessary we act… Read more »
Section 3 of the 14’th Amendment to the Constitution of the United States states: “No person shall be a Senator or Representative in Congress, or elector of President and Vice President, or hold any office, civil or military, under the United States, or under any State, who, having previously taken an oath, as a member of Congress, or as an officer of the United States, or as a member of any State legislature, or as an executive or judicial officer of any State, to support the Constitution of the United States, shall have engaged in insurrection or rebellion against the same, or given… Read more »
I really dont trust bias media anymore:( you can’t pick and choose what to cover . Not excusing the behaviour of a bunch of crazies.
I feel silenced because we have unfortunately no say anymore in anything. Whatever government decides that’s the new law. I hope you will take care of your neighbors when they seem fit to detain a ‘public health threat’ when they refuse the dangerous vaccine . No treatment? So how come HUNDREDS of respected Dr are saying otherwise??? Oh wait ,the media didnt say it so must be fake right?
Thanks for going You said very beautiful I read every word you said trump did a Lotta good for Israel he did a Lotta good for America America realize it in the next couple of years they’ll be begging for Republican leader republican president
According to the Tanya, if a non Jew does something good, it is because it benefits him somehow. We undoubtedly have Trumps frum daughter and son-in-las to thank for any real good Trump did for the Jews. Of course Trump took the credit for himself.
Where does the Tanya say anything about not thanking said non-Jew for the good that he did do, even if it was for selfish motives? Hakaras hatov is a very basic value in Judaism, and a lack of it leads to a lack of hakaras hatov to Hashem too.
We dont need either!
Hashem we only want Moshiach!!!
We want to connect to you in peace
President Trump has been a great president thus far. He’s been great for the USA and great for Israel. These Leftists, I fear, are going to do irreparable damage to the USA.
Is very different then saying March to the Capital and take it over. 3k nut jobs don’t represent 400K people that were there. Every group of people have nut jobs, like no exceptions. Oh and by the way he condemn the violence and told people to go home. Still waiting for Binen/Harris/Obama/Clinton to condemn the crap that went down during the summer. TRUMP is the only sitting President to condemn both
He did NOT condemn the violence. He said go home, but this was after he said that he loved them and that they are right to be angry and that they are great patriots…etc. He most certainly did NOT condemn them. He just said: ‘we don’t want to play into their hands” – w hatever that means, and said to go home.
In fact, he never condemned any of the hate groups who like him!
I can’t believe there are so many Democrat Chabadniks. Dare I say, maybe they are trolls? Just remember, your grandparents escaped or died al kiddush Hashem in the Soviet Union. And the Democrats are gonna do it all over again. Yes, the storming of the capital was insane and done by a couple hundred MAGA morons, nazis and possibly ANTIFA members. Yes, stupid people twist Trump’s words and say he incited a mob. You can twist Trump’s words to mean anything. And those same stupid people applaud BLM violence that was going on for 6+ months. (Just look at Deblasio,… Read more »
A couple of them even arrested the Frierdiker Rebbe. Nothing much has changed.
There are a lot of cold souls in our community; the way they ‘fire up’ is via leftist agendas.
There are indeed liberal Chabadniks and not every conservative Chabadnik supports this president and his actions. We are not “trolls” but living right alongside you and cannot wait for this insufferable time period of Trump worship to end. Don’t panic, it’s not the end of the world, it was just an election. And if one believes everything comes from Hashem, one should act accordingly.
since there’s no actual “Trump worship” at all, just defending the guy, then you’ve been waiting in vain. Now, the Biden worship, on the other hand – the notion that for example he’ll somehow magically “heal” the country – now that’s something else altogether.
I can’t believe there are so many Democrat Chabadniks, therefore they must be figments of my imagination.
Nobody is twisting Trump’s words. He told them to go to the capitol. Giuilani said there should be trial by combat (which indicates that he’s having trouble differentiating fantasy from reality but that’s a different story). There’s no twisting words here.
Funny, i thought chassidishkeit was defined by learning chassidus, fulfilling mitzvos behiddur and following the Rebbe”s horaos. Never heard that supporting Trump had anything to do with it. Here’s a thought: if you conflate chassidus with Trump support, maybe it isnt G-d that you’re worshipping
For going on crowded busses where masks weren’t mandatory and then going to a huge rally with tons of people mainly without masks and then coming home and possibly infecting us.
Just so you could march with people like the proud boys who hate us.
And so you could be part of a group of people who think it’s okay to storm the capitol and try to stop our legislature from doing what they’re supposed to.
Thanks so much!
You have hit the nail on the head. I totally agree with you!
Your proud of participating you don’t present Lubavith in any shape or format the Rebbe would not incorage such participation
Why do you feel the need to support and defend Trump and his supporters? They don’t care about you. There are more important things in your life anyway, or at least there should be. Torah, community, health and safety, peace of mind… just a few I can think of. Time to grow up.
This article should be publicized and posted on Foxnews etc. Of course the leftist in the media hate anyone who is not with them. So they wouldn’t want to read and consider the content of this article. But even right leaning media are afraid to defend Trump supporters right now. Suddenly 70 million people are being condemned because of what a few thousand did. Most people would not storm the capital building. Alas the truth continues to be buried in lies (from both parties). Moshiach is the only and true answer. We’ve reached a point in time where it is… Read more »
Stay out of this fight. Both of you….our job is to spread Torah and mitzvos
It is the job of every individual to stand up for justice. Staying out of a fight makes you a bystander. If you do not stand against yesterdays attack, you are guilty.
There were four people killed yesterday,r’l in Washington D.C..
Why was the police allowed to use live ammunition against this crowd? Why is there no outcry against this? Contrast this to the Antifa and Black Lives Matter riots when so many in positions of authority bent over backwards to justify the pillage and violence.
Our concern should not be about politics, but about chinuch, which was what the hayom yom yesterday was about. The Rebbe wasn’t concerned with only the chinuch of Jewish children, but of all children. What can be done for the children of this country to teach them Torah values?
In addition to book learning, it is important to apply the learning to frame a Torah perspective on the world around us. That is what this article does. It observes today’s HaYom Yom. It is not about politics.
I find it shocking that people are quick to condemn established media like NBC CBS etc, and yet believe and support Foxnews! and Social Media. Why does anyone imagine that Fox news and Social Media speak the truth? Incredible
to anyone who’s been saying that they necessarily speak the truth either? But you’re certainly not going to get the truth from only one side, the Orange Man Bad side.
Established media for the radical left. Main stream media is just the propaganda arm of the Dems. If you’re Jewish and backing the Dems, you’ve joined a party of radicals with a plethora of anti Semites in their ranks. You’ll soon see how radical and anti Semitic they really are. The so called “Shomer Yisrael” Schumer will be their “court Jew” to divert any anti Semitic accusations. There will be other Jews in name only who will willingly back the insane radical policies. We need divine intervention. HaShem runs the world, not feeble, 78 year old, cognitively impaired, corrupt career… Read more »
I attended the J’ouvert parade. Farrakhan’s and Sharpton’s just added to the interest. Nine people were shot but I wasn’t there when it happened. Most attendees, like me, were very friendly and well-behaved.
Nuf said.
Where can I find the video from Project Veritas that you mentioned?
Thank you for showing support to the best friend that the Jews ever had in the White House. Showing gratitude is so important.
How frum yidden can stand shoulder to shoulder with people wearing 6MWE and “Camp Auschwitz” shirts and talk about the lovely atmosphere.
Hashem Yerachem.
Anyone reading all these comments and commenting, did you finish Chitas and Rambam today yet? There are some more important things to do ; )
Yes there were Trump supporters that we’re in the capital, but it was not their idea they were egg on by antifa members, who obviously coordinated with police to allow this to happen, video on this matter is clear, protesters are seen allowed into the building with no resistance, this just doesn’t add up.
I can’t wait to see all those antifas who broke into the capitol identified, arrested and charged!
Very well written, I was there as well and it was a powerful rally.
Because I thought virtually all Lubavitchers were Trump cultists. Seeing these comments gives me hope. I’ve had ties to Chabad (my great-grandfather built the house the Rebbe chose for Machon Chana, among other Brooklyn connections). I enjoy my local Chabad shul and was looking forward to attending the cancelled shabbaton in Crown Heights. What has stopped me in my tracks is the community support of this monster. I feel a bit better now.
While in the past four years Trump has been especially good to Israel and we will never forget that, his incitement of what happened on Capital Hill is inexcusable.
Any thinking person knew the hidden agenda and it came true. Aliza while you may be a supporter of Trump, as a thinking, Torah observant Jew, pretending you didn’t know what was going to transpire is very sad. Four people were killed on Wednesday. That’s ok because everyone there wereTrump supporters?
I blame the liberals for the capital invasion. The people involved saw footage all summer long of people rioting and invading government buildings.(and worse) There was no strong condemnation of that behavior. There were no serious punishments given out to those involved. They naively thought they would be looked at the same way. They didn’t realize that (1)the capital isn’t just any government building(at least of this writing that is the way it became. When the liberals were storming the senate floor and disrupting the Kavanagh confirmation hearing no one expressed any outrage ) and (2) they was doing it… Read more »
As you say, you weren’t there for any of it. I fully support the right to assemble PEACEFULLY and LAWFULLY as you describe in the beginning. Regardless of what one believes, they should support and defend another person’s right to their opinion. That said, spreading falsehood and stating opinion as fact is dangerous. And I really really can’t understand how anyone can think that storming a government building with violence is remotely okay. shaking my head