ב"ה
Tuesday, 16 Shevat, 5786
  |  February 3, 2026

Growing Up with Strict Parents

An Australian teenager sent COLlive a poem based on the difficult lives some children go through under overstrict parents. Full Story

Rebbe Dismisses The Sickness

Next Story »

Mikvah is Finally Restored

109 Comments
oldest
newest most voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Balance
March 26, 2012 9:45 pm

I think that this gives a very good insight into the importance of showing love towards our children, but reading the comments also shows that we DO NEED TO SET BOUNDARIES. Everything is a balance.

........
July 2, 2011 9:22 pm

so sad…

#103
June 30, 2011 6:10 pm

I agree that it’s helpful and hopeful for children to open up and talk to peers and role models – excellent idea. People should also be aware that some of us growing up in abusive situations were threatened with abandonment/disassociation and intimidated into not telling anyone about our situation. On top of the abuse, the prospects as a child of being alone/having no where to go/live is both frightening and humiliating. And these feelings that maybe others can do this to you, too, are hard to make go away in adulthood, but very possible I can say personally. I’m grateful… Read more »

To #105
June 30, 2011 5:38 pm

Yes, and, bezras Hashem people from these upbringings find loving people to influence them (the “growers” you mentchen). Related, so not to risk losing these people from the derech c’v, I’d like to see advertised a group of mentors offering free yechidus, randomly, for anyone who schedules, anonymously. Without supportive parents, I wonder from who, where, and when these kids are going to have opportunities to receive and be exposed to healthy, loving guidance/direction & values long before marriage .

children are helpless
June 30, 2011 2:36 am

children who live with abuse are helpless. when they are adults and are surrounded with loving healthy people who are “growers” this will influence the adult to become powerful and start healing which takes a life time!

89 (it's the australians) seriously??
June 29, 2011 11:53 pm

you can’t be serious, it’s the australians? Just because you are Aussie too and had a similar experience. You think no Americans or English have these issues as well.
Your post is just plain silly
Besides I think it’s become pretty obvious that her alledged nationality is dubious being as Summer holidays in Australia are SIX weeks not 8!

speaking as a fellow Aussie

agree
June 29, 2011 11:38 pm

I have gone through all of that and i totally relate. i have gone through all of that, and then some. I understand where everyone is ocming from when they say “oh it’s not so bad” cuz unless you are sensitive enough (which comes through living through it) it doens’t seem as bad as it says. Yet when you live in a unloving abusive neglectful home…. Your attitude towards so much shifts, On the one hand i do not wish it upon anyone else, yet boruch hashem i see where it all came in from and i see where i… Read more »

To #100
June 29, 2011 10:54 pm

Exactly, yes. Thank you.

It's got to be England
June 29, 2011 10:29 pm

Who said Australia? They call their mothers,”Mummy” in England plus I could imagine a plain navy “proper” skirt being the English “uniform.” I hope she goes for therapy. What about encouraging her siblings to seek help too.

Cool - 100th comment! ;):)
June 29, 2011 12:34 pm

Alright. Even though I thank Gd did NOT grow up in a home like that, I know a boy who went through something like this pretty well.
If anyone knew what they were talking about, they would speak like comment 93.
These kind of kids don’t get to make much decisions in their lives. So whoever says they should seek therapy, they should think again…
And the ones who said the parents should, does it look like the parents know they’re doing something wrong?
Think about this please…

My parents are divorced
June 29, 2011 3:06 am

But they are normal!

They both let me talk while we had breakfast and… nothing crazy like this.

So you see, don’t be quick to turn me down… you never know who comes from the crazy family after all…

Any mirrors in your house?

Imago therapy is used by many frumkite
June 28, 2011 7:08 pm

It says marriage is a safe place where spouses work together to resolve issues still present from childhood

#93 well-said, thank u
June 28, 2011 6:56 pm

Plus therapy is an ongoing endeavour. How long is one supposed to wait for kiddushin?? And who determines the “right” time when somebody’s considered “healed”/”kosher” for marriage??

author
June 28, 2011 12:27 pm

Hi – I just wanted to let you all know that his poem is not based on my life but someone who I’m very close with.

this story is true
June 28, 2011 5:25 am

and meny of us have lived with this upbringing , meny parents continue , the way there father rasied them , and meny were and are wrong , treat yr kid like a precious gem . and talk to him nice . dont put him or her down , and knock them inn public. dad may u rest in peace, i try to move on

stop blaming the aussies
June 27, 2011 11:04 pm

STOP blaming the aussies there are crazy people in all countries and if anything australians are too laid back

to all those THERAPY comments
June 27, 2011 10:37 pm

its not so easy for a girl in this situation to just pick up and go to a therapist. im sure the parents would never allow for such sort. and if she would try to pay for it on her own how would she ever afford it? with those type of parents she would never be able to hide her ‘secret ‘ visits to therapy. would if her parents don’t let her go babysitting and earn some money…. this girl apparently has no freewill and independence. she should try to speak to her parents in a very calm demeanor about… Read more »

ashreini
June 27, 2011 8:26 pm

Thanks G-d for my strict parents

to #81
June 27, 2011 5:39 pm

what on earth are you going on about
it never said a word about tznius
all she said was that she HAD to wear the blue skirt and pink shirt that her mother chose which she thought was nerdy!!!!
and to the author; hatzlocho rabo with your future and im sure you have plenty love inside you for your husband as well as your future children.wishing you all the best.

To no.19
June 27, 2011 1:00 pm

Don’t wait for your parents input in finding someone for you to marry; there must be someone who you are close enough to, who can be there for you, and guide you during this part of your life; And no, marriage is’nt always the answer, but neither is staying at home any longer and waiting for your parents. Move on with this , somehow without them its been done before, you won’t be the first; Hatzlocha, and may we hear good news soon! When you’re engaged , let us know on COL, we’d love to share the news with you!!

its the australians
June 27, 2011 12:31 pm

i find this poem to be very interesting as it is the story of my life.
i used to think marriage was the answer but then figured out there was so much i had yet to learn that my parents had hidden from me.
it should be noted my parents are from au as well.
someone should tell those auzies to lay off the booze!

yup this is true and sad
June 27, 2011 11:54 am

this is the reality of MANY kids and families! what ppl need to realize is in order to have a good marriage and be “free” ypou need tharpy!

Rashi on Shema
June 27, 2011 7:10 am

On the word ‘ v’ahavta’ in the shema, Rashi says that if one serves out of fear, then when it gets difficult, he will leave.
We have to help our children develop a desire for Hashem and Yiddishkeit so that they will be motivated by love for Hashem. They will then be able to make the right choices themselves. Children look at their parents and teachers as representative of Yiddishkeit. Read the book ‘Off the Derech’. It should be required reading for parents and teachers.

Thank you #58
June 27, 2011 2:45 am

I can’t understand why I had to read 57 comments to get to the fact that It is not about Yiddishkeit but about abuse. The parents used yiddishkeit as an excuse to get away with it. SICK.

NO 81
June 27, 2011 2:24 am

Youve got the total wrong end of the stick!!!!
Who mentioned that Tznius is the issue here?????
Its regular basic normal stuff, that we’re talking about over here,jusr regular basic normal LIFE, no more , no less. . if you dont know, then dont judge and dont talk, this is not your regular run of the mill structure that is being discussed here. . . so grow up and think b4 you pass judgement about things that dont belong in this whole sad story

#28
June 27, 2011 1:56 am

Your comment is Right On!

to # 80
June 27, 2011 1:02 am

i have been through the same thing as a child too! it all depends on the parent, since you are a bochor you may want to talk to someone older whom you trust ad discuss the situation in detail… because sometimes a parent isnt even aware of what he/she is doing to the child, other times the parent doesnt care, or a parent could say that its not true, because its too painful to face the truth about themselves. what u cn also do is be a “big brother” to the victum. i remember always being stuck at home and… Read more »

ive been through a very similar thing....plus worse.
June 27, 2011 12:55 am

please all parents… i beg of you! please speak to your children like they are humans. they have feeings. children that are abused have scars that last FOREVER, it can go away to a certain degree but the pain will always be there. its one of the hardest things to have a parents that dont show love.( even if they love you on the inside, it has to be brought out.) without love in a persons life, life is just not worth it! so please if you think you may be a parent that doesnt show enough love to your… Read more »

shocked
June 26, 2011 10:41 pm

omg i am in shock…this is pathetic….since wen is a mother installing tznius in her child called strict…what is this world coming to…i am a teenage girl and i respect parents who install these basic foundations of tznius into their children… yes it isnt easy to accept as the child but it has to be done. i think there is a lack of love and warmth… and why put down important concepts like tznius??? if only we all dressed like ‘nerds’ !?!?!?!

nos
June 26, 2011 10:30 pm

im a bochur in touch with a kid going thru it is there a way to help him or to get the message to his parents with keeping to the “:mind your own buisness phenomenon” how can i help him

Leading to the Chuppa
June 26, 2011 6:44 pm

2 points
Ponder: What type of children will the author lead to the chuppa? Your pain does not necessarily provide you with the correct alternative.
Consider: Multiple influences form the person. Is it only the strictness of the parents at play here?

from london
June 26, 2011 6:42 pm

its happening to lot of family but most the kids keep it to them self and don’t speak out and the kids don’t feel any love so why do you think many of them don’t wont any think got to do with there family’s and there all damaged for life some more then other

Author
June 26, 2011 6:29 pm

I really do thank you all for your comments. It’s such an amazing feeling to know that there are so many people out there who feel and care for a complete stranger.
Thank you and keep writing!

The conscious wrote
June 26, 2011 4:34 pm

To #38

Indeed אין החכם כבעל הניסיון: The ability to learn from your life’s adversities only on how to better yourself, the power to harness the bad as chariot for good, is surely a tremendous virtue; however, it has nothing to do with this discussion.

Implying in the last few lines of the poem that marriage was a way of an escape – note, “escape” – is certainly not the proper and healthy approach!

Much success.

few changes
June 26, 2011 4:28 pm

just a few changes, and sadly this poem can actually fit the description of many marriages I know!

leaarning curve
June 26, 2011 4:17 pm

It’s good for parents to keep in mind that that when you think you have to be strict to ‘teach them a lesson’, the lesson they learn is seldom the one you meant to teach! The real lesson they learn is what they perceive in your actions, not what you say.

to 8 & 19
June 26, 2011 4:15 pm

stay strong and G-d will surely help. I don’t understand how parents can be like that to their own children!!!!

N0. 68
June 26, 2011 4:13 pm

N0. 68, everything you said was right, but you forgot one very important ingredient, actually the most important, i woild say, in todays world . . . “Communication”, without which , no child can function, regardless of age stage or situation. Hear where your child is coming from, relate to what she is saying, BE THERE FOR her, and let the lines of communication ever be open; that way no child can be hurt and left so vulnerable as this child is; Its still not too late . . Its actually wonderful to see what an amazing response she has… Read more »

wow
June 26, 2011 3:17 pm

i think it is completely amazing the way she was able to express her feelings and let everyone no what she went through and publishing it so that parents and teenagers are able to learn from it = parents- you should take this situation and be able to learn from her parents’ mistake and be able to give your children the proper education they need: not to many rules not to harsh try not to have so much screaming around the house….. but at the same time caring and loving and being harsh in a good way meaning saying no… Read more »

hello
June 26, 2011 2:49 pm

reading this I AM SO HAPPY UR MARRIED!

to # 29
June 26, 2011 2:39 pm

that was when she was 9 years old, its 10 years later now

Love
June 26, 2011 2:11 pm

Most comments to this article keep mentioning about Strict or Rigid homes……That wasn’t her point.!…don’t you see she is crying out because she was never Kissed or Hugged or Shown Love by her Parents. How sad! Hashem should bentch her with Brochos for good health, mazal and the Koichos to get through this. PARENTS….it’s okay to set guidelines for your children…but please hug, kiss and love your children!

me too
June 26, 2011 1:57 pm

I identify with her completely, and it usually comes along with parents who have anger management issues too. (abuse too)

HELP
June 26, 2011 1:42 pm

I READ THIS POEM AND HAVE A QUESTION, I COME FROM A HOME WHERE MY PARENTS LOVE US AND EACH OTHER, AND SOMEHOW, I DON’T UNDERSTAND HOW, I HAVE A SISTER WHO IS TURNING OUR HOUSE AND FAMILY UPSIDE DOWN WITH DOING EVERYTHING WRONG YOU CAN IMAGINE. AND SHE HAS THE CHUTSPA TO COMPLAIN THAT SHE IS BEING RESTRICTED!!! MY PARENTS ARE LOVING AND KIND PEOPLE AND ARE THE SAME TO MY SISTER WHO REALLY AND TRULY DOESN’T DESERVE IT. I’M HOPING SHE SEE’S THIS AND READS IT, I JUST WANT HER TO KNOW THAT SHE IS HURTING ALL OF… Read more »

GOLDEN RULE
June 26, 2011 1:05 pm

go to therapy, so your kids wont need to

To Number 54!
June 26, 2011 1:03 pm

I don’t understand you! Can’t you see from this poem that this is your regular dicipline?
Do you think missing lunch is normal? Do you think having a silent table during meals is normal? Because I don’t! This is not a regular situation!

attn #2
June 26, 2011 1:03 pm

correct. But her parents sshould see someone too

Ppl, see what is written!
June 26, 2011 12:55 pm

I like the way some of you are suggesting that she marriage is not the true escape and she could have left home earlier. Can’t you see from the context that this girl was unable to do what she knew made sense? And also, imagine the name she would get in shidduchim if she left home at 19 to live in an appartment or something.
Maybe it wont hold true in the future but for now, this girl has every right to see marriage as an escape.

to #58..
June 26, 2011 12:55 pm

there is a VERY strong undertone that she is on her way off the path, e.g. no enthusiasm for modeh ani, not liking the tznius clothes she has to wear. open your eyes.

to No.8 & the author
June 26, 2011 12:33 pm

As a teacher of a child suffering through that.
What can we do?

context
June 26, 2011 11:17 am

If this girl really lived through gehenom, I feel sorry for her and her family, but to draw the conclusion that children must be ‘free’ is childish and absurd. Children must be taught values, and when they deviate, they must be nudged back into the straight and narrow. Unfortunately that requires a parent to do what they instinctively don’t want to do, which is discipline. The masses of parents know how to do it without making the children feel that their home is a boot camp, but rather create a place with rules in a loving environment. ‘Yemin mikareves usmol… Read more »

To #33
June 26, 2011 10:55 am

This poem does not say that she is leaving her Jewish heritage. She is leaving her strict, unloving, rigid home. This has nothing to do with chasidishkeit or frumkeit.

To #21
June 26, 2011 10:52 am

Children DO appreciate structure. I think you are obviously misinterpreting the poem. There is a difference between STRUCTURE and RIGIDITY. Also, if a child can not wait to leave their home- it doesn’t matter what stage it is– wrong was done. We’re not talking about a stubborn teenager who later tells her mom “I’m sorry for being so stubborn…CHayele is soooo stubborn..” this is not the situation.

get out before marriage
June 26, 2011 10:15 am

you’re right it’s not an australian
that was a way she attempted to disguise her true location because she is still living in fear of her parents’ wrath.
notice to all girls who feel as this girl did:
you do not have to get married to escape an unhappy home. you can graduate high school, get a job, find your own apartment, and even continue your education from there (scholarships). get out! don’t wait to be rescued by a chassan! not fair to him.

WOW!
June 26, 2011 9:20 am

Oh – the insidious presence of CONTROL – which people have no clue they are doing – from a parent who tells their child – “oh that is too hard for you” – called learned helplessness…. to parents who say “Oh, you don’t like pink icre cream, you like chocolate – take the chocolate” – and kids can have eating problems, chas v’shalom. So much of the way we are NOW – goes back to our parents’ “messing” us up – but that’s life – it goes from generation to generation – until someone along the line – learns communication… Read more »

Grow up
June 26, 2011 8:07 am

She will grow up and appreciate the parents who cared enough to set good boundaries, very evident that they the parents were involved and setting a healthy structure which hopefully she will do with her children too.
My father was strict and did not spare the rod, oh how I appreciate it now. Thank you dad.

author
June 26, 2011 6:07 am

Firstly, I’d like to thank you all for ur comments (good or bad!) I appreciate ur input on this alot! first things first, this poem mostly based on completely true facts. this family suffers daily under these crazy parents. there are many sadder things i was careful not to mention because i dont thing many ppl would have believed it and it would not have been fair for the family either. This girl is NOT messed up, the sad part is that she’s normal enough to realize that all this is wrong. she is definitely the LAST kind of girl… Read more »

really good poem
June 26, 2011 4:42 am

i completely understand the girl. i have friends that are scared to bring home bad marks because their parents will scream at them.
If any one suspects something like this is happening to a girl that they know, reach out to the girl and show them that you love and care for them
as a teenager i know that so many of my friends are secretly wishing for an older person to reach out to them and build a relationship with someone out of the family that they know that they will be able to trust.

Marriage is not a way out...
June 26, 2011 3:24 am

I feel terribly sorry for the guy who ends up with someone like this!
Marriage is a beautiful and powerful thing between two people who are ready to share their lives. This kind of girl has such a high expectation, she is setting herself up for failure! She needs to work on herself, be aware of her baggage and move forward, only then will she truly be free.
I think that many people can relate in some way…
We need to be happy and content with ourselves and not expect marriage to “fix” our lives!

Good Luck!
June 26, 2011 3:14 am

How did her parents even let her date a normal guy? They were not controlling then? It is VERY sad, but unfortunately MANY families are like this, and I pity them all. This poem reminds me of how grateful I must be to my wonderful parents. Judaism and Chassidut are not ment to be forced, for its about the relationship with God.

Australian teenager
June 26, 2011 2:59 am

I think she may have said she was from Australia, to make sure that no one will ever be able to track down who she really is, and where she really comes from, and that way no one could connect her to her poem, or trace her country of origin, which is why she wrote ‘anonymous’ at the very start

No.3.
June 26, 2011 2:53 am

Where did you see any where in this article that she has turned away from her ‘Jewish Heritage’ ?????
For G-ds sake, all this represents is a cry from the heart, and its people like yourself, who can react this way to such a poem, who need the help, not her, for writing it; You must be one of those who believe that everything should be just swept under the carpet. . . get a life!!!!!

omg!!!!!!!!!!!!
June 26, 2011 2:49 am

i agree with #27

maybe
June 26, 2011 2:49 am

maybe she did go to therapy, and its just not written there… we should surley see moshich now!

Open your eyes and see
June 26, 2011 2:49 am

THis child/teenager is not suffering due to the strict regime that her house is built on, like many of us know, structure and security build a home , when done with careful calculation and tenderness, they don’t destroy it; Whats lacking here r”l, is the total absence of love, affection, understansing, and above all, COMMUNICATION that every single parent must have with every one of their children; To be able to allow joy, fun and pure happines into the childs life is something that is a must in every child s existence today, and all that never cancels out structure… Read more »

emotional abuse
June 26, 2011 2:23 am

This can also describe emotional abuse from a husband toward a wife, and the wife can feel the same way as this girl, even worse. The husband can look very good to the public but in private treat his wife in a similarly unconnected, bossy, unfeeling and cold way that all she wants is to leave… and outsiders cannot understand why she is not happy and may blame her for rocking the boat when they see the marriage break up.

This Is For Everyone to Internalize; No Exceptions!
June 26, 2011 2:19 am

The sad thing is; the people that need to read this most, think that it’s directed at everyone but themselves!

Child Abuse
June 26, 2011 2:06 am

This woman was a victim of a very severe case of child abuse. Unfortunately many children of extremists become victims of abuse and continue to unintentionally put themselves into abusive situations and relationships for the rest of their lives. Please take care of yourself and seek therapy as soon as possible! It is extremely difficult to break away from abuse… even if you think you understand what it is. I wish you the best of luck and pray for you that this is truly the end of abuse in your life.

i love you
June 26, 2011 1:54 am

that poem is like i treat my kids

in my humble opinion...
June 26, 2011 1:52 am

i think the problem lies with her friends parents…

they allow their children to run around and do whatever they want.

so when any rules, however slight or harsh, are imposed on this girl she feels as though she is in a prison with nowhere to run.

Listen up!
June 26, 2011 1:36 am

hey, listen up to all you who are reading this comment! What this poem says, is clearly straight to the point of what some frum girls go through all over the world! I’ve gone through it and still am and I’m not the only one. Yet, I do disagree with the fact that she looks/ed at marriage for the answer. I did to and no, I’m not married yet. Marriage is definitely NOT the answer. We have to realize that although are parents view us in certain light and expect us to keep to the same stringencies they have, if… Read more »

To #20
June 26, 2011 1:05 am

I’m a male who grew up this way. Let me say that marriage has been the best thing that’s ever happened to me, thank G-d. Like the author, because I was aware of being raised inappropriately in a “toxic” environment, I’m actually much more sensitive to “signposts” of abuse. Therefore I’m much more diligent now to work with my spouse, with G-d’s help, to protect our children from experiencing the same neglect and minimizing/invalidation. “Tragic”? No. Life-giving and an opportunity to make teshuvah, as well as elevate my family to be a kiddush Hashem? Yes! What did our sages say?… Read more »

i dont think the title is good
June 26, 2011 1:02 am

these arent called strict parents, this is called emotionally and mentally challenged parents. and ultra controlling parents.

What about your siblings?
June 26, 2011 12:44 am

I’m sorry that Hashem put you through such a hard test of growing up with strict and not loving parents, now B”H you have moved on- what about your siblings? Is there any way you can get help them? Is there anything you can do, so that they don’t have to go through all the things you went through? Can you provide them with the love that they so desperately need? Maybe send them to an out of town Yeshiva, let them live in a dorm etc… you being older now- you have the power to help! Don’t let them… Read more »

GIVE YOUR KID LOVE!!!
June 26, 2011 12:35 am

Parents who are over-demanding, who expect too much from kids & who want their kids to be just like them will end up with rebellious, OTD children. Accept your children for who they are. Love them, nurture them, & give them space. Above all respect them. We can’t always get the the kids we want (I mean Chassidish enough, pretty enough, smart enough) but who cares?? These are our children & and a smart parent will know that you can’t force a square peg into a round hole. I know. I have a child who, despite the exact same upbringing… Read more »

I'm a teen from australia to!
June 25, 2011 11:56 pm

beutiful poem…

wonder who wrote it…

why??? oh why...??
June 25, 2011 11:49 pm

why do people feel the need to justify that they are turning away from their jewish heritage??

get help now and stop taking others with you.

Not oZzie
June 25, 2011 11:43 pm

No aus school has 8 weeks holidays they all gave 6

woa!!!!!!
June 25, 2011 11:40 pm

becareful!!! the emotions in this poem are expressed pretty normally based on the circumstances!!!!! but marriage is not the solution!!!!!! if anyone one reading this has similar family backgrounds, please do yourself a favor (yes get married and get away from the unhealthy situation) but first get help and therapy dont think getting married will save you. getting married is a huge step and you need to make sure that you can have a relationship and raise children and not be like the way you were raised. good luck

awareness
June 25, 2011 11:37 pm

It sounds as though this girl has gone through alot of pain may hashem help her and anyone who may be in similiar situation c”v to be able to heal themselves and their childhood so that it doesn’t carry over into the next generation. and i guess its an awareness for everyone to realize that everything we do has a direct affect on our children whether we see it or not. especially what we say………

australian girl
June 25, 2011 11:08 pm

i live in Australia and i don’t know anyone who wears navy skirts and pink blouses, i think it’s exaggerated and p[poetry more than raw facts

Wrong title
June 25, 2011 11:07 pm

I think your title is wrong – the issue is not that the parents were strict, it’s that the home is lacking in LOVE I grew up in a fairly strict home, and I believe that I am probably considered a strict parent by today’s standards. But there is love and understanding and COMMUNICATION in our home! Children do need rules and structure, not a free-for-all. You are misrepresenting the problem. I hope this girl sees the truth now as she grows with her husband and can rectify her relationship with her parents before she has to make decisions about… Read more »

To #1
June 25, 2011 11:07 pm

Just because they are very strict on her it doesn’t mean you should be EXTREMLY relaxed now, just not TOO strict

to #1
June 25, 2011 11:05 pm

You seem very unsure of your principles of parenting. It is therefore not surprising that you take guidance from a teenage girl who has “suffered” from her upbringing. Her case gives you no guidance as she suffered from harsh parenting which is not related to your concern. All that can be learned from this article is what not to do. What you need to do is find out how to bring up your precious children. A message to all readers: Each child is a diamond which has the potential to shine and sparkle. A parents job is to cut the… Read more »

well expressed
June 25, 2011 11:02 pm

i think someone who can express what she went through so clearly and realize it is not the norm , will make sure not to bring up her children the same way

Beautiful
June 25, 2011 10:56 pm

I must say I am very critical of the usually ridiculous articles posted, but I must say that this poem actually made me FEEL. I felt sad, upset, disappointed (in the parents), sympathetic and empathetic. And most of all relieved that the girl has finally left for good, and of course terribly sad that it had to be so.
Good luck if this was true and good luck to all of those who have to endure such lives

aha
June 25, 2011 10:55 pm

so my mother always calld me “stupid”…………………..what u say about that?

to #2
June 25, 2011 10:47 pm

Poetry does not necessarily prove what someone is feeling. i write gloomy poems all the time- but I am in fact a very happy person (ask my friends!) Don’t judge others from their writing.
Just appreciate this girl’s gift for writing,
and I know you wish you had it too.
beautiful poem!!!

A child's perspective
June 25, 2011 10:39 pm

I think that it has to be taken with a child’s mind. There must have been many good times in her life as well. Children don’t always perceive structure etc. as positive but later in life it makes them into mentshen and they look back and see it was for their best. I think she may find that but didn’t put the est of that in the poem. Actually maybe she isn’t at that stage yet, having her own kids, being under stress, and trying to do things the best way she can.

The conscious wrote
June 25, 2011 10:35 pm

Someone who sees marriage, seemingly, as a way of escaping a strict home?!?… What a sad and tragic ending!

......
June 25, 2011 10:30 pm

I grew up in a home like that….
Bh this girl was able to get married…
I am marriagable age and my parents r acting with me the same way they did till today with my decision in getting married……
I dont know when the day will come and i will be free……

from down unda
June 25, 2011 10:01 pm

we don’t have summer vacation for 8 weeks. that’s an american thing

wow!
June 25, 2011 9:57 pm

what an amazing poem!

So sad
June 25, 2011 9:47 pm

This just shows what is most important. Although as parents we try to set rules, structure, follow different parenting theories, in the end one thing really matters- showing our children that before ALL else we love them. So parents: take a deep breathe and give your children a hig and kiss, and do something fun with them, talk to them, play a game with them, enjoy them!

Peculiar
June 25, 2011 9:28 pm

Really interesting that you decided to post this, its mainly depressing.
What age is the author? Is this your life story?
But if there are children who are being brought up like this then maybe it was a good thing you posted it to bring more of an awareness to others, and to awaken those who are guilty.

Thought provoking article
June 25, 2011 7:58 pm

If only these parents had any idea of the long term effects their ”’so called” parenting principles have on their children, for LIFE, and the ripple effects it has for generations onwards, they would re think their ideas, totally; Abuse takes form in many different ways, unfortunately, and constant ongoing ‘silent ‘ abuse, is at times worse than abuse that is there for the world to see; These words written here pull at the very core of ones soul, and one can hear the obvious pain and helplessness of the child involved here; If any of us, normal functioning families… Read more »

sad
June 25, 2011 7:48 pm

Unfortunately this may rear itself again with her children….. this is the simple mechanics of neglected, stifled and unhappy children.

Whew!
June 25, 2011 7:17 pm

I actually never knew there were families like that! Very well put. Thank you for sharing this with us.

Wow!
June 25, 2011 7:08 pm

That is powerful…i’m sure some of it will hit home will a lot of people….

Wow !!
June 25, 2011 6:37 pm

Very powerful … i was a relbeluous teenager too i was brought up in a frum , lubavitch and loving home but as we got older we didnt have any rules and i did what i wanted ofcours my parents where very upset they didnt know what to do with me some times i wanted them to be stricked with me and tell me NO you cant do this or wear that i was a very stuborn child you can never win striked or to easy going

Wow
June 25, 2011 6:20 pm

Nice but don’t u think this is abit harsh?

sad.i am growing up in such a house.
June 25, 2011 5:55 pm
so sad,
June 25, 2011 4:48 pm

hope this girl goes for help so that her baggage doesnt effect her own marriage and family life, wish her all of the best.

i'm a teenager from australia
June 25, 2011 8:52 am

but i could assure you i didn’t write this poem

good, depressing and weird
June 25, 2011 6:57 am

AUSSIE
June 25, 2011 6:46 am

Thats a Beautiful poem. it made me cry

so what
June 25, 2011 4:45 am

firstly – why does it matter if shes australian, french, american, israeli or whatever?

Secondly – is this real? is she writing about herself or is it just poetry?

Thirdly – Just hope this poor girl will handle life married and with kids. That shes not emotionally damaged or scarred.

fourth – shame on the parents!!!!

therapy
June 25, 2011 4:44 am

I think this girl needs to see someone

Thank you for this poem.
June 25, 2011 4:32 am

As a mother, sometimes I think I am way too relaxed with my children. After reading this poem, I think I am doing ok! Thank you for your heartfelt words and hopefully your relationship with your parents will improve in the future.

X