By COLlive reporter
A suggested conduct policy for staff members of Jewish overnight summer camps was released in an effort to prevent and crack down on child abuse while children are away from home.
The “Child Safety Agreement” is meant to be signed by adults working in camps, reminding and committing them to the spiritual, mental and physical well-being of campers.
It was composed by Project E.M.E.S. (Educating Mosdos on Eradicating S. Abuse) in conjunction with the Crown Heights Jewish Community Council and the Jewish Community Watch in an effort to address the myriad of potential issues that a camp may encounter.
Typically, summer camps hire young adults and bochurim with the intention that they organize and direct many of the camp’s activities. And while an emphasis is put on their organizational skills and chassidishkeit, many are untrained and ill-prepared to handle issues relating to abuse.
And while the parents might get to know the counselors and learning teachers, their child will on every given day interact with the rest of the camp staff, ranging from life guards to kitchen staff and waiters, activity coordinators and more.
The new policy clearly spells out what is or isn’t appropriate and permissible physically and verbally, as research has shown the most abuse cases stem from the people regularly interacting with the child.
Brief hugs, ‘high fives’, a pat or putting a hand on a child’s shoulder are labeled “appropriate.” But lengthy embraces, kissing and obviously, any form of wanted affection or touching any otherwise covered body parts are forbidden.
Also labeled “inappropriate” is being alone with a child in isolated areas, pinching, hitting, spanking, and “touching of undergarments being worn by children (i.e. wedgies).”
It also puts on the ramifications of verbal interaction, warning against name-calling, cursing, vulgar language or insulting a child. The same is with comments or compliments that relate to “physical appearance or body development.”
The people behind the project say these guidelines have been endorsed by members of the Crown Heights Bais Din (they didn’t name which of the three), as well as Rabbis YY Jacobson, Levi Kaplan, Abba Paltiel, Yossi Paltiel, Avraham Zajac, Elchonon Tauber and Doctors Chaim Drizin (MA, LMFT), Norman Goldwasser (PhD), Asher Lipner (PhD) and Michael Salamon (PhD).
Project E.M.E.S. is hoping that camps adapt these guidelines and say they will be updating the public about which camps have agreed to implement them.
They call on parents to take action as well by teach children about the “No-Touch-Zone,” and not feel embarrassed to talk to when something suspicious happens.
They said that campers might feel embarrassed to spell out what is happening to them, especially on the phone with others around. They recommend agreeing on a code word that when said, can alert the parents.
Read the new agreement
HASHEM KNOWS THE INNOSCECE OF MENY OF THOSE HUNG IN THE “HALL (HELL) OF SHAME” AND HE WILL AVENGE THEIR BLOOD THAT WAS SPILLED THRUOUT THE STREETS OF THIS SHECHUNAH FROM THOSE CORRUPTED PEOPLE FROM WITHIN OWR MIDST, “Maharisayich umacharivayich mimaich yaitzaiu”.
Yasher Koach to Benny and Meir Seewald for all the great work you guys are doing keeping our children safe. Hopefully you’ll have a lot more rabbonim lend support to this effort. You guys are saving lives. Danny Fishman
That is something that happened to my friend this past summer, he went straight to Directors and told them about the situation… Not to sure what happened after that, but this is 100% true I know it happens all the time.
“WE” do nothing. You stand up for nothing and do nothing, rather you obfuscate about potentialy ridiculous issues. “Others” do something, only to have your uneducated criticism. Stop looking for things to bash and get behind programs dedicated to saving and protecting children.
What do we do about this?
The best thing the counselor can do is to IMMEDIATELY report the threat to the head staff and camp director and ask that the incident be on record that the child made this threat. The counselor should also take the precaution of switching himself or the child to a different bunk. But that is why we need guidelines: so counselors know never to put themselves into a situation where someone could even think to accuse them. And for people who think this is ridiculous: do you think hilchos tznius/yichud are ridiculous and spell things out in too much detail? Following… Read more »
So because you have some wild notion that had never been proven true, we should just do nothing and enact nothing? That’s absurd.
Sadly, the chazakah is on the predators not the alleged lying kids.
While yes, it is possible that the counsler is guilty, it is irelivent!!! The fact is the kids can use this as a serious Threat and they do!!!! Make no mistake; kids will catch on to this! And to 33, once a rumer is spread , it makes absolutly no difference what the investigation proves! The person is screwd for life! And whats next? The staff will Have to stand behind a fence when talking to campers?! In front of 24/7 web cams?? Where does this end?!?!
ALL camp directors have been notified and involved in this policy for the past 3 months. They have had opportunity for input, etc.
To address #25, etc. While there may be some kid that will claim that he will make a false claim, incidents are highly unlikely and unusual. Further, the claim will never stand up in the face of police and DA examination. It will fail and the accused will be vindicated. Ultimately, life is subject to human error, but we all must do what is necessary to ensure children are safe and to prevent harm from befalling them.
I see what your saying, by the same token their could be a person who ACTUALLY does touch a camper inappropriate and use that as an excuse….
This issue should not and can not be taken lightly. However this needs to be done in a more modest and professional way. With working together with the camp administration, agreeing that all staff are taught the protocol and sign a contract, sending an email out to parents notifying them of the precaution they are taking and to address the issue to their children- things are more likely to be taken seriously. This is such a strong issue which needs to be tackled effectively and by having this open to kids of all ages on an open forum website instead… Read more »
Oh my gosh that is aweful!!!!!!!!!
#25 brought up a very valid point!
Can someone please answer what the counselor should do in such a situation?
Because it can totally happen anywhere and ruin an innocent counselors life!
I was a counselor for toddlers a few years ago and gave my kids a ton of hugs, kisses, and rides too, because they were just sooo cute. Based on this though, is it inappropriate?
Spot on I too saw the same thing this past summer
– I agree with #22…why was Forer left off?
– Im amazed at the mentality in this chat. People are so opposed to saving kids lives? So opposed to preventing CSA? Are you people for real?
Here is real threat to staff, ams I will use a REAL and TRUE incident; I was in a cgi overnight camp this paat summer, when I saw the followoing take place. Counsler: “mendy, im sorry, but as I warned you, you distubed the (bedtime) story and therfore you must wait outside the bunkhouse unti it is over”. camper”oh yeah?!, well of you dont allow me into the bunkhouse I will TELL MY MOTHER YOU TOUCHED ME!!!” This is a REAL threat to staff all over and can ruin their life! Any advice to overcome this?
A hug is helpful for staff who are not so articulate since staff are only so old they can only do so much a hug could be really helpful
if you are someone who thinks this is not rediculis than the biggest “dont” is dont send your kids to camp!!!
Why did the article not include Benny Forer’s endorsement? He’s a respected DA who is also an expert in this field.
Congratulations, you’ve successfully attacked. You are officially a bully. Nice.
Speak like a mensch wontcha? Just like everyone else commenting here!!
I hear Safety Kid is having a camp training. Anyone have any information on that?
There seems to be a problem here. While this work is important. The organizations behind it must be vetted. These are not issues that one can simply say “better them then no one”. The issues here are serious. Serious people with serious capabilities and transparent modes of operation have to be the ones monitoring this. Not 2 organizations (chjcc and chw) notorious for their corruption. You sleep in the bed you make. Get the right people enforcing this with seriousness before you end up with a problem you wish you didn’t have. While chw can be applauded for shedding light… Read more »
CGI central did a camp training conference last year and trained staff on abuse and molestation awareness and prevention. (part of the training included guidelines of proper conduct in camp).
I highly recommend their training again, my daughter went and really enjoyed it.
it proven a hug goes further then words can, children need it,
Affection is not exclusively physical. Kind sensitive ears and words can provide more affection for a child than a hug.
For many years CGI running springs (a”h”sh) spent a day training counselors with a competent social worker. The course was extensive and professional, bochurim were given the social workers phone number for issues that came up in camp. An opportunity for candid questions was presented, and every issue under the sun discussed from pillow fights to tickling. With all due respect to the organizers, a professionally developed program tailored for frum camps and modified yearly as new issues arrive has been used by all frum camps inCalifornia for last 5 years. Why are resources being used to implement a program… Read more »
If a child is hurt or crying, I think a counselor can give a brief hug to comfort them
Why aren’t our schools & camps doing background checks? Including Chayolei Beis Dovid, Released Time & Friendship Circle volunteers (male AND female)??? We have to check, educate, inform & prevent.
I was fingerprinted & had a full background check a couple of years ago when I was working in a pre school. Even the cooks & janitors had to go through the same thing. If you are clean you have nothing to fear. Things like the Melbourne scandals could so easily be prevented with a little bit of investigation. DO IT!
This is similar to the Hecsher Tezedek. We don’t need the pepole behind this telling our moisdois how to assure proper care for our children.
I am suprised and dissapointed that this farce is geting any PR at all.
At least you gave yourself the title u deserve…actually, better call yourself OVERconcerned parent. You sound absolutely ridiculous!
Couldn’t agree more…
True, this is necessary, yet it is sad that a mentor CANNOT express the slightest bit of affection to a child. Sometimes this is what is NEEDED, and it will take the child to the next level he needs, maybe missing it from being away from home, etc. But in today’s crazy world, it must be prohibited, lest some hyper-sensitive person accuse a well meaning staff member, or scare a kid into thinking someone is molesting them
Dont gorget that kids in camp need hugs sometimes . not too much but when it’s needed. You don’t want ur child to ne sad the whole time and noone should be allowed to help him ….
The woods, wooded outdoor areas where people generally don’t go is also isolated even if it is outdoors.
Public outdoor places at night when everyone is asleep, like behind or side of bunkhouse is also considered isolated.
Please add to list
…That’s throwing the baby out with the bath water.
No, I think a brief hug is fine.
Remember: It’s healthy for a child to know what healthy affection is. Cutting out all forms of normal affection is unhealthy. It’s important for people to know that they are capable of being warm and appropriate at the same time.
BRIEF hugging fine…
I think this is wonderful because it’s very much needed but it’s sad that we’ve come to this point where appropriate and inappropriate need to be spelled out like this.
I feel like I need to tie that figurative string around my finger to remember that I’m normal in a world that’s going mad
This should be for the staff at both boys and girls camps.
Keep ALL hugs out! Period. No need for camp staff to be hugging kids.