Grant Rodgers reports in the Des Moines Register:
Prosecutors used disturbing tactics that secured a 27-year prison sentence for Iowa kosher slaughterhouse executive Sholom Rubashkin, according to a letter signed by more than 100 former U.S. attorneys general, judges and others.
The April 19 letter urges Kevin Techau, the U.S. attorney for the Northern District of Iowa, to “rectify the injustice” done to Rubashkin, who was convicted in 2009 of bank fraud and money laundering charges in the wake of a historic raid by immigration agents at his family’s Postville meatpacking plant, Agriprocessors.
The letter comes as defense attorneys detailed new evidence in a March filing suggesting that prosecutors knowingly allowed “false and misleading” testimony at a sentencing hearing that U.S. District Judge Linda Reade relied on in handing down the lengthy sentence.
Among the signers accusing the prosecutors of misconduct are four former attorneys general, the Cabinet official appointed by the president to oversee all prosecutions by the U.S. Department of Justice: John Ashcroft, Ramsey Clark, Edwin Meese III and Michael Mukasey.
Other signers include former U.S. senator and Democratic vice presidential candidate Joe Lieberman, Republican mafia prosecutor and New York City mayor Rudy Giuliani, and Kenneth Starr, a former appeals court judge who led ethics investigations into President Bill Clinton in the ’90s.
Former Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) directors Louis Freeh and William Sessions signed the letter as well.
But it’s hardly the first time Rubashkin supporters and notable figures, including former judges and members of Congress, have publicly weighed in with concerns about how prosecutors and Reade handled the controversial case, said Laurie Levenson, a professor at Loyola Law School and former federal prosecutor familiar with the case.
For instance, more than 80 former federal judges unsuccessfully asked the U.S. Supreme Court in 2012 to hear an appeal from Rubashkin, calling the sentence unjust.
Can renewed pressure convince Techau and others that the convicted executive was wronged and deserves a chance that could put him on a path toward freedom?
“There’s nothing to be lost by trying, but it hasn’t worked so far,” Levenson said. “Unless they come up with new facts. That’s really the important thing. Not that you have big names, but that you have facts and law on your side.”
Federal prosecutors have until May 20 to file a response to the allegations by Rubashkin’s attorneys. Assistant U.S. Attorney Steve Young said the office would not publicly discuss the claims outside of the filing.
How can America ever be ‘just’ and civilized when they use jail as a punishment for non-violent criminals? The Torah doesn’t believe in jail & jail is a very cruel system. People get tempted to steal. Non-violent crimes (& others) are not thwarted by fearsome punishments, so the criminal doesn’t feel great fear & they don’t believe they’ll get caught. They might also believe that, with a good lawyer, they’ll not be incarcerated. Many have escaped ‘justice’ and even escaped from jail. So the criminal is lured into committing a crime. Jail, for the non-violent, is certainly evil. Here are… Read more »
this really is so unjust and ugly, it should really be known all over. the media doesnt cover it, so its really just not known by enough people. it is really so unjust. People don’t know that this is an issue.
with brachos that SMR get released and can go back to his family, resume normal ilfe.
It is UNBELIEVABLE that with all the efforts to release Sholom Rubashkin, the situation remains so far unchanged. What can we do to assist? Would it help to have us all sign petitions? Let us all continue and redouble our efforts to become BETTER- recite tehillim with more kavannah, be kinder to one another, increase in Good Deeds. Hashem should help us all in bringing this event to a SUCCESSFUL conclusion.
Didan Notzach!!
I never met you in person but with hashem help I should dance with you and all Chasidim in front of 770 it will be such a dance of joy and then we can dance with Klal yisroel with moshiach now!
I’m fully trust that Sholom Rubashkin will be free soon!!
enough , let him go ….he paid enough …. Maybe Mr.President let him free ?! maybe the judges that put him there will dismiss the case ?
Didan Notzach!!!!!!!
Amen. May he be released now with?ALL OF AM YISROEL!!
What about a pardon from our esteemed outgoing president?
Release him and then talk .
I don’t quite understand. There have articles, news releases, op-eds on the inequity of Sholom Mordechai’s Gehennom. But it seems that what’s written above has been said several times, from almost the very beginning – the attoneys general and senators, and politicians all declaring the original trial illegal. Then what happens???
HaLevai, Sholom Mordechai, together with all of us, will finally be able make the brachah, מתיר אסורים