Tamar Rotem reports in Haaretz.com about how chumros (stringencies) on Pesach strike fear in the heart of the chassidic community.
Books with pages spread wide open, perched on balcony railings and shedding imaginary crumbs of not-kosher-for Passover food. Shelves covered in new paper, and masses of aluminum foil on kitchen counters and the stovetop. Signs on doors warning “Do not bring in hametz” – referring to leavened products – with several exclamation marks.
All of these were signs in my childhood that Passover was approaching. Above all I remember the near-hysteria that overtook the women and girls in the house, which mounted as the holiday grew nearer while they, dressed in rags, pursued to the death every stain and crumb.
In truly strict homes, I heard from girlfriends, they began the preparation for Passover on the day after Purim, which falls a month earlier. There they knelt on the floor and scrubbed every single tile with brushes and kerosene. In other households they took a toothpick dipped in rubbing alcohol and cleaned pot handles and faucet cracks with it. The contents of closets were laundered well in advance and the clothes were hung out on lines, with pockets turned inside out, for days on end. There were homes where they ate nothing but potatoes and eggs for some weeks.
Chabad Hasidim, Hasidim affiliated with the Eda Haredit, and especially the Toldot Aharon Hasidic sect are the most scrupulous of all.
While Hasidim avoid eating “soaked” matza – i.e., matza that has come into contact with water – among the Lithuanians (non-Hasidic ultra-Orthodox Jews) this stricture does not exist.
“You don’t want to insult anyone,” explains a Chabad Hasid, who prefers not to be identified by name. “It’s uncomfortable if the host offers you a cucumber, for example, and you don’t eat it because its seeds resemble grains of wheat.”
In Chabad circles, it is absolutely forbidden even to mention bread or bread products aloud during Passover.
Prof. Shaul Stampfer, a lecturer in the history of the Jewish people at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem, says that observance of customs related to preparing for and keeping Passover is an opportunity to express devotion and piousness in contemporary life, when observing religious commandments has otherwise become relatively easy.
“There was a time that it was impossible [in the Diaspora] to obtain kosher wine or kosher-slaughtered meat. Today everything is prepared, in packages at the supermarket. Proscriptions bring back something of the difficulty of observing commandments. It’s possible to ridicule them, but in principle it’s a human and emotional thing of the first degree,” says Stampfer.
Often the objective of following the Passover rules observed by Hasidim is not clear even to them. Sometimes they avoid various kinds of foods, only because in the past their community did so.
“In Russia [where Chabad Hasidism began], there were no eggplants,” says the man from Chabad, “and therefore at Passover, Chabadniks don’t eat eggplant.”
In Chabad they don’t eat radishes. The reason: The third Lubavitcher Rebbe, Menachem Mendel Schneerson [this was also the name of the seventh, and last, Rebbe], did not eat them during Passover.
As a rule, Hasidim do not eat fruit or vegetables on the holiday that have not been peeled, for fear that hametz has adhered to the peel, and customarily remove the peel even from tomatoes. For the same reason, they also will not eat berries, dates and the like. The very strict avoid eating any vegetables or fruit, apart from potatoes.
The disciples of the last Lubavitcher Rebbe noticed that he did not use a knife on Passover, and therefore a minority of them they have also stopped using knives, though they do not understand the reason.
On seder night it is customary to eat from glass dishes, but in Chabad they allow the use of porcelain with a gold rim. Why? Because at seders conducted by the Rebbe, the food was served on white china decorated in gold.
… For their part, Chabadniks also prefer to drink homemade wines.
…. Also in Chabad, they cook meat and fish dishes for the week-long holiday in advance.
… In Chabad, families rent a bakery for half a day and the members of the family come to work and to supervise the bakers. In other circles “matza groups” are organized, with a number of people coming to supervise the baking.
The risks that accompany the baking and eating of matza keep Hasidim awake nights. “The matza might crumble and the crumbs, heaven forbid, might land on a plate with soup or salad dressing,” says one man from Chabad. “Therefore, our custom is for everyone present [at every Pesach meal] to receive a bag with matza in it and he eats it from inside the bag. Only after the table is cleaned of crumbs do we go on to eat the rest of the food.”
Amazingly enough, many Hasidim refrain from eating matza on Passover in general, except for the olive-sized piece as mentioned in the Haggadah on the first night.
whoever wrote this article is verry talented in making something so holy so special something horrible
CHANGE THE WAY YOU LOOK AT LIFE!!!
life will be much better
where is that פסוק?
ur comments make sense!
handmade shmura matzah, no kitniyos, no gebrokts everything else…………i eat!
Yes u may, as much time as u need as close to shabbos as possiple.
Yes, we can do this on Friday, as it says in Otzar Minhogei Chabad and Hiskashrus this week.
this is some good comedy
What would they do with it there?
you should learn how to spell (two L)
HAHAHA
guys just laugh!
p.s. some of u guys got to learn to spel;
No, I was not assuming anything. I have said this all the time: There is no source — not in Halochoh, not in Minhag and not in Mesorah — not to eat things because they LOOK like Kitniyos. And since this is the case, whatever they did or didn’t have in those days should have no baring on what we do today. And to simply assume that since they did therefore their children should do it – is a Meshugaas. Again, if – like Yom Tov Sheini, for example – there was a very important and valid reason for doing… Read more »
can we make matza ball this friday and eat them on shabbes acharon shel pesach?
55, I meant whether to tighten the Kesher on the Shel Yad before or after the Brachah
59, All I can say is you are assuming they were doing this based on a lack of the required information and this assumption leads you to conclusions that might be adjusted based on today’s day and age.
You will never know what the original reason is, nor do you have to know. There is nothing wrong with blind faith.
You are misunderstanding what I am saying. I am not, Chas Vesholom, calling anyone’s grandparents fools. That is a terrible thing to say. I was calling those who follow blindly something that has no room in Halochoh and call it a “Minhag” foolish. In other words, what our grandparents did was based according to their circumstances and knowledge they had, but it cannot be considered a “Minhag”. To follow what they did blindly, without any kind of Mokor, simply because they did something – is foolish. It is, like I previously said, not using air conditioning because they didn’t have… Read more »
my chumra is to eat Gebrocks for 7 days and NOT eat Gebrocks on the 8th!!!!!!.
Then I don’t eat CHoometz till Shavoois !!
Plse don’t censor this have some humour !…..i have been to KINNUS SHLUCHIM last year 2011, as a VIP lay person!!
I heard Reb Moishe Feinstein held that peanuts are not kitniyos and that he personally ate them on pessach. Can someone confirm this??
Can you eat pumpkins and if so, what about the pumpkin seeds? I saw them kosher for pessach ONLY for those who eat kitniyos, but if you can eat the pumpkin, why not the seeds????
kesher is not a good example
is brought in shulchan aruch
// sefer minhagim
So everyone squeezes orange juice instead of purchasing “processed” juice. Which is more likely to be chometz? With produced orange juice, the oranges are picked off the trees and go to the factory on a truck with nothing but oranges. They are then processed on machines used for nothing other than oranges and handeled by technitians who are wearing scrubs in a lab type atmosphere. Now, your kosher lepesach mehadrin oranges go through many hands until they get to the retail or “wholesale” location where you picked them up. In the truck there could be other products and any number… Read more »
I just checked the Hiskashrus, your right about that. It says it’s OK. Garlic was a bad example. Radishes might have been a better example, or cinnamon or ginger. To say that my grandparents did not eat cucumbers because it was not common is wrong. They had a reason and I assume their reason is that it looks like Kitniyus. Today cucumbers and rice are both common so nobody would mistake the two but one day or in some places it might indeed be mistaken. There are things that just don’t make sense to us and should be kept anyway… Read more »
I will repeat – as an absolute definite: In Hiskashrus, for the past ten years at least, including this year – and including in the Hao’oros – it says there is NO Minhag Lubavitch not to eat garlic. It is said in the name of R’ Yaakov Landau, who was the Rov in the Rebbe Rashab’s house. Enough said.
And I will say, yet again: There is NO CHUMRAH or MINHAG not to eat cucumbers. It is a complete SHTUS. In Halacha and in Mesorah, there is no place for “Chashasah Dichshasha”. Kitniyos are NOT Chometz. It is only because they LOOK like Chometz did this thing become a problem for Ashkenazim. To say that because something LOOKS like Kitnoyos – which are not Ossur to begin with – is CRAZINESS. Again, there is nothing to be embarrassed about a Minhag that seem crazy. In Belz, for example, they don’t eat carrots, since they once found Chometz, or whatever.… Read more »
rabbo sb gansburg the personal meshamesh and cook of the rebbe says it is 100% UNTRUE
so what makes you a chabadnik?
you pick and choose what feels good?
The rebbe used milk on pesach, can anyone confirm?
i quote “In Chabad circles, it is absolutely forbidden even to mention bread or bread products aloud during Passover.” Someone tell me that isnt dumb. That’s only one example…
can you cook shruya (gebroktz) on friday to be eaten on shabbes acharon shel pesach?
ask Schermling before using the capital “NEVER”
I did not equate YomTov Sheini Shel she Galuyos to eating melons. I am merely pointing out that following a Minhag even when one does not understand it is not what you called “lunacy”. Many Lubavitchers also do not do ultrasounds or laser eye surgery based on the same logic. “There might be a reason”, is the logic. We don’t know everything and since Kitniyus or even matza Shruya have very little logic (as we see it) but the Chachomim and Rabeeim found it important ,we do the same and many great people do draw paralels from cucombers to rice,… Read more »
btw the knife has got nothing to do with pesach! yes it’s true that the Rebbe didn’t use one and I know some chasidim who follow ( there is a reason -but dont think you people posting would appreciate it anyway) this all year around. enough of this negative rebellious tone you all got. if you have issues or want to vent go elsewhere
The Rebbe NEVER ate ANY TYPE OF CHOCOLATE on Pesach. The Rebbe did not use sugar on Pesach, and besides, the Rebbe followed Minhag Lubavitch not to use processed foods. Even after making sugarless dark chocolate, the Rebbe never ate it on Pesach.
1) Cucumbers have SEEDS? Huh? So do apples, lemons, oranges an so forth. Edible seeds? How about melons, squash, and so forth. There is NO Mesorah about the pathtic not eating SEEDS!! It’s enough that we don’t eat Kitniyos – again just a simple concern. To make Kitniyos into Chometz, and therefore not to eat anything that LOOKS like them? How CRAZY do you need to be? That’s lunacy and follishness. I am sorry. I am ALL for Chumros and concerns. I am also all for Minhag Avoseinu, but there is a possiblity that “Avoseinu” were mislead, or whatever. There… Read more »
that the Rebbe ate dark chocolate
any body could confirm it?
also the article doesn’t mention about SUGAR!
It is clear from this thread alone that there really is no “mesora” of chumras, save for a few. A mesora is written and recorded, not one does this and the other does something else. In my books, a Lubavitcher is someone that follows shulcha aruch AND the horaos of the Rebbe – chitas Rambam, mivtzioim, learn chasidus. Whether you follow these chumras or not is by no means the limus test of who is and who is not a Lubavitcher. Rather, each family had their own and added or subtracted as they went along. To equate these chumras with… Read more »
Besides for the gold rim, knifes and wine. 🙂
I use a knife on pesach and i am a lubavitcher
as said earlier just because we may think some chumra a meshugas does not make the article untrue. besides for the dishes with the gold line
i did hear of all these chumras, so this article is mostly true but does have a derogatory tone to it.
I know many people who prefer home made wine because of the sulfites added. many people don;t use garlic. and most of us only eat what we can peel so we peel our tomatoes.
A koshern un freilichen Pesach!
“I am a Lubavitcher” not! To allthe fryouts of different levels in CH (and CH is not a neighborhood in Brooklyn. CH is a way of life!) you stopped being a Lubavitcher when you gave up the Mesoira of Chabad of 200 years! The article is wrong on many of its details and its making a mockery of Chabad tradition. However the nekuda of the Chabad approach to all Mitzvos and especially Pesach is that we are the most scupulos in our observance and on Pesach nothing is viewed as a Meshugas. You can’t rewrite history.
25, cucumbers have seeds. That’s the reason. If this was enough to make my grandparents not eat it then I wont eat it either. My grandmother says everything was available in the markets. Besides, “Minhag Avoiseinu Beyadeinu” is the reason for many of the things we do including celebrating 2 days Yomtov. Do you keep 2 days Yomtov in Chutz Laaretz or is that also just some old man’s foolishness? 26, i distinctly remember the Hisklashrus saying that we do not eat garlic even though we don’t know why. If you want to eat garlic go ahead but don’t insult… Read more »
Awsomist idea. For the future there is hope to drying lettuce after all!!!! I love cr!
Great idea!!!!!!!
Mao would be proud
it used to be cuerd in beer-chometz
To #26: Just because YOU didn’t hear of it, doesn’t mean it doesn’t exist.
the lettuce looks like charosesss!!!
i think i now found some more chumras to do!!!! i am “gej” and am looking to go overboard on pesach chumros. finally got myself a nice stash! thanks haaretz
There is NO CHUMRAH IN LUBAVITCH not to eat garlic. Period. Whoever says there is, does not know what he or she is talking about. See the Hiskahsrus, and ask any Rov you want. It is totaly false.
If I offend someone with this following point, I am sorry. There is no offense in mind, just trying to set the record straight. There is NO Chumrah OR Minhag, OR halachah, that basis itself on something not being available at any time. For people to continue a “Minhag” of their great-grandparents of not eating cucumbers, basing this on the mere fact that these were not available in old Eurpoe or Israel, or anywhere else in the world, is a misconception, misdirection, and outright Meshugaas. If you told me that. at some time or other, the family didn’t eat cheese… Read more »
Wowwwwwe that is the best idea.!!!!!!!
PUNK.! Punk punk
Bread, toast, bagels, paninis, wraps etc etc etc
Now go stone me. This article has more holes than a matza. Pure stupidity!
Thats is the funniest idea ever!!!!
Hahaha this is such a funny pic.!!
Rabbi gouraie i love you mach kidush..
love the dryer! 😉
BS”D
This is total nonsense! These are not all mainstream chumros, hey, everyone according to his own 🙂
Every set is beautiful though, many ways to the Makom!
Omg!!!!! I. In love with the kitchen who’s the designer?!?! BLANCO!!!!! He’s daaa man!!!!!!!! Very nice article too.
I am a chabanik and i have quit most chumros that are not in shulcha aruch or have a clear makor.
So i keep gebrokts but i buy most processed foods.
I simply do not enjoy yom tov with all the chumros and I have no interest in spending extra hours don things like squeezing oranges.
Awful!
What a stupid article
Never heard that one…please dont tell my husband this one!
Doesn’t mention garlic, always wondered why we don’t eat garlic…
and be proud of yourselves!
This is all just a mashal to removing the real chametz the gaava the ego in every one of us. So be intense.
I wish they would mention that we do it because we are crazy for Moshiach.!!
D.B.
I think she got all the wrong details here….. We dotn only use homemade wines.. its better to cop before but not all do. She made it sound like we are crazy… and we DO eat matzah other then an olive size deice at the seder.
Seems like this article interviewed the chabadniks with OCD… Gold rimmed china?
1)no eggplants,where do they get that from?????
2)”For their part, Chabadniks also prefer to drink homemade wines.” i know of one famaly in la that dose this(the rabbi dosent!!!) and two in crown heights(there are probobly more, but not that many)
“3) Also in Chabad, they cook meat and fish dishes for the week-long holiday in advance.” i only know of one famaly that dose that!!!! what makes it chabad?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?
a kosher un freilechen pesach!!!
Making fun of minhagim in a very deragotary way.
Are you not aware of the posuk: “minhag yisroel torah hee!” ?????
Great idea thanks!
lies
Thats such a nice kitchen.!!
omg.. i love the blowdryer!!!!! and the photographer!!!! lol… miss u..
i think she went a bit too extreme! not all chabad families do these things. and yes, i know she mentioned that, but she also made it seem like chabad as a whole have all these chumros.