ב"ה
Friday, 6 Sivan, 5780
  |  May 29, 2020

Live:

Tzadik Lamelech Gets Republished

Sought-after "Tzaddik LaMelech" journals were reprinted in a new book format with rare photos and documents of the Rebbe. Full Story

Chabad Moscow Opens Pharmacy

Next Story »

2000 Kids Join ‘Connection Point’

27
Opinions and Comments

To keep track of your comments, follow a conversation or flag a comment Login
avatar
  Subscribe  
newest oldest most voted
Notify of
Lazer z
Guest
Lazer z

There is also many things from 5753 that are changed in the new book

Thank you!
Guest
Thank you!

It’s an amazing set! Can’t wait to get my hands on it

Changes
Guest
Changes

There are unfortunately many things that were changed in this edition. Not the same as the original

Thanks for the reprint
Guest
Thanks for the reprint

Amazing book

Rewriting history
Guest
Rewriting history

If you dont want to mention something that happened- don’t mention it altogether.
But to change the facts that happened is just foolishness.
I’m not sure who could think of such an idea, and who they are trying to fool..
But this book contains MISINFORMATION!!

Shocking!
Guest
Shocking!

I was here in 5753 & I remember vividly (& this is recorded in hundreds of videos…) the Rebbe encouraging the “yechi” almost twice daily for a year straight! I am totally horrified that someone can print a book that outright denys this fact….

Totally horrifying !
Guest
Totally horrifying !

This book has one agenda: Rewriting history.

It’s a beautiful book and Zaklikovski did an amazing job!

But why take out a few words in a diary you don’t like?!

Who asked you???

To 2 & 4
Guest
To 2 & 4

If it would have been a reprint, not censured, it would of actually be an amazing set :,(

Yasher Koach
Guest
Yasher Koach

That is a beautiful idea. Thank you so much for all the effort put in. I’m sure it was a big job.
Please though reprint it with the changes back to the original. That’s not so emesdik. And not giving fully true information. I’d be happy to read it when I’m sure everything is 100% accurate.
Thank you again! Hatzlacha!

Wow!
Guest
Wow!

I must say i’m so touched by the comments here, which show us that there are still people whom the Rebbe’s kovoid is important.
Let us hope that we shouldn’t have to talk about such sad subject, and the main thing – we should reunite with our Rebbe by his hisgalus teikef umiyad mamosh!!

Reprints
Guest
Reprints

Any respectable publisher will fix errors in a second edition and is entitled to change anything he deems a mistake.

Regarding the changes
Guest
Regarding the changes

A book needs to be printed with Achrayus – B’ofen Hamiskabel.
Not everything that happened needs to be published publicly.
The author of a book has discretion what does or doesn’t need to printed.
It seems that the commentors above arn’t strong enough in their Hiskashrus, that they’re threatened by a line in a book.

And regarding #9, there is nothing untrue in the book, the claim is that is lacking certain information. So, you may read the book.
And not reading a book until you know everything is 100% accurate, is plain stupidly

To 6
Guest
To 6

You may want to look at what is actually printed in the book…

Are they making it in English?
Guest
Are they making it in English?

Why is everyone surprised by the small changes
Is it shocking that we don’t write about parts of history after we see what is going on today !
with the young generation being taught pure stupidity as a way of life

Confused
Guest
Confused

What is censored? The 1000 ‘Igros Kodesh’? The 300 facsimiles of Ksav-Yad-Kodesh? The100 selections from Sichos on the topic of Geulah and Moshiach? The 100 selections from Sichos on the topic of Hiskashrus? Excerpts of Sichos on the topic of the Rebbe’s birthday? Or The Memoirs of Rebbetzin Chana, the Rebbe’s mother, in its original Yiddish version? Or a few words here and there?

@Mendel Altein
Guest
@Mendel Altein

Thank you for all the work that went into the book. Very geshmake read.

Wondering
Guest
Wondering

I wonder if those commenting against the book are actually worried about the Yoman, or is it really the clear maainos and letters that clearly rebuffs their mishichist agenda, printed in this Sefer

נייתי ספר ונחזי
Guest
נייתי ספר ונחזי

Interestingly enough the book has many מענות /כתבי יד .. that will bring clarity to all those worried about the minor changes

To the critics
Guest
To the critics

I bought the book and I really enjoy it, I advise everyone to buy it.

it is a must in every Home.

To 11
Guest
To 11

If the fact that the Rebbe answered Amen on the complete nusach of yechi is deemed a mistake by the Respectable author than: כתבו לכם על קרן השור שאין לכם חלק באלקי ישראל!!!

To number 12
Guest
To number 12

Apparently you did not look at the book and you are unaware of the ‘mistakes’. Let me explain: You wrote “Not everything that happened needs to be published publicly.” – agreed. So than the author should just take out the entire diary, but don’t print the diary and *change* what happened.(especially that in this case the Rebbe clearly encouraged it for the public, on video and even the media). You wrote “there is nothing untrue in the book, the claim is that is lacking certain information”. That is incorrect. They changed things in the book to make it seem like… Read more »

Stop hacking
Guest
Stop hacking

K #12 pls stop digging to find the problem with everyone’s hiskashrus. Its very clear the author has an agenda and thats why he ommited some big stuff and that is takeh not acceptable for anyone to do. If u want to write ur own stuff fine but dont claim ur reprinting something and take out major stuff…thats called false advertising! And thats the point these guys are trying to bring out in their comments. U know that and we all know that and i think u made a fool out of urself by commenting on #9 and davke trying… Read more »

FAKE NEWS
Guest
FAKE NEWS

BH

The guy writes about what the Rebbe did in public, and warps the facts because he is embarrassed of what the Rebbe himself was not embarrassed to do.

If you are embarrassed of the Rebbe, go find yourself a new Rebbe.

Don’t start mixing your limited seichel into the desicisions of the Nasi Hador. (remember Korach? Meraglim? Miriam?)

And yes, I still love you.

To 12
Guest
To 12

I can fully understand those who do not want to print about Yechi etc, but to go & rewrite history is another story altogether!! The fact is (& this can be seen on hundreds of videos) that the Rebbe encouraged the singing of “יחי אדוננו מורנו ורבינו מלך המשיח לעולם ועד” & this was printed in the original Tzadik Lmelech. To come now & try to deny that is simply horrendous…

The Rebbe kovoid
Guest
The Rebbe kovoid

Let’s make stuff very simple. This is not a “meshichist”-“anti” subject, but rather something connected to anyone that besheim chabad yechuneh. If they feel a need not to be mefarsem mitzad atzmom that the Rebbe was meoided “yechi … melech hamoshiach leoilom voed”, they should of just taken out this whole yoman, un sholom al yisroel. The way it is now – that they did put the yoman, but are mezayef that the Rebbe wasn’t meoided what he was meoided, but something else – is the greatest chutzpah possible!! And again, this has nothing to do with any political party,… Read more »

Comment 12
Guest
Comment 12

I see a few comments responding to mine. So allow me to explain. To 21: obviously the author was uncomfortable printing parts of the Yoman, which you agree with. That does not mean he needs to remove the whole Yoman and be Monea Bar. He just took out a few words, that those that were there or watched videos etc. Are able to understand what he means, and together with that, maintain the rebbe’s kovod in a Dovor Shebidfus. It is clear to be that the Rebbe would not be me’asher to print it the way it was. Now, it… Read more »

To 25
Guest
To 25

Ask yourself this question: who did more for the rebbe’s kovoid, you or the author of this book, who dedicated his life to the rebbe and the rebbe’s inyonim. You – who are busy discussing and analyzing Lubavitch party politics, or him – a shliach that is busy spreading Yiddishkeit and the rebbe’s message to the world- actually working to bring moshiach- and his bit of free time is not dedicated to resting, rather to printing the rebbe’s inyonim.
Your going to teach him about Kovoid?

X