ב"ה
Saturday, 21 Elul, 5779
  |  September 21, 2019

Shul Found in Brooklyn Church

Real estate agents Judy Friedman and Chaya Zarchi made a surprising discovery in a Brooklyn church: a perfectly preserved Shul and Mikvah. Full Story, Photos

“We Can’t Give Up Now”

Next Story »

Wedding: Shollar – Shear

42
Opinions and Comments

To keep track of your comments, follow a conversation or flag a comment Login
avatar
  Subscribe  
newest oldest most voted
Notify of
WOW- Someone buy it!!
Guest
WOW- Someone buy it!!

How amazing.

Heartwarming to hear
Guest
Heartwarming to hear

I hope someone buys this property and revives it as a shul or yeshiva! May Moshiach come right away and restore all the old shuls that became houses of worship, etc. for others!

Amazing
Guest
Amazing

Wow that’s amazing

wow
Guest
wow

so cool! where is it located?

If not for the Rebbe..
Guest
If not for the Rebbe..

There would have been many more like this one when other communities left to boro park on those years, abandoning many shuls. The Rebbe made asked people to keep attending those shuls so they close down. Once a place is a shul cannot just close down.
The same goes for the latest trend recently seen of all these pop-ups shuls opening all over. If you open a shul you assume a responsibility and it is a commitment long term to maintain it and to make sure it doesn’t close. It’s not a social club, kedusha lo zazah mim’koma.

how much?
Guest
how much?
FEW QUESTIONS!!
Guest
FEW QUESTIONS!!

1) IF IT IS STILL A SHUL NOW/TODAY, HOW DID THEY USE IT AS A CHURCH ?
2) WHAT HAPPENED NOW THAT THE BUILDING IS UP FOR SALE ?
3) IS IT A SHUL OR LEHAVDIL A CHURCH ?

I SAY: IT IS DEFIANTLY MOSHIACH’S TIMES!!!

contact Trump
Guest
contact Trump

They are looking to score points. Freinds of Israel

To 7
Guest
To 7

Read the article.
It was a Shul. Years ago the church bought the building. They left the Shul intact. The Shul has not been used since. The building is up for sale.

Larry
Guest
Larry

Where is it located

Very interesting
Guest
Very interesting

There is another shul with a mikvah intact located on Eastern parkway corner Schenectady across the library.
The black lady who lives there, understands the kedysha of the place & never wanted to destry it.

Wow so amazing and sad,
Guest
Wow so amazing and sad,

Wish I could buy it. I have a strong feeling there are others like this one around as well.

Watch out who it's sold to. If a developer buys it
Guest
Watch out who it's sold to. If a developer buys it

they will probably turn it into condos which in this case is against Halacha.

woww
Guest
woww

incredible. someone will surely be reviving it, b’ezras HaShem

Baruch HaShem!!!!
Guest
Baruch HaShem!!!!

I thank and praise the G_D OF ISRAEL for this step in the correct direction. May He decree abundant steps in the correct direction, and very soon.

Why
Guest
Why

Why did they walk into a church? Its avoda zara. Its against halacha to walk into a church.

theres dozens of them
Guest
theres dozens of them

some in stunning building all over CH and BedSty :(:(:(
including EP

St johns place and utica/rochester /sterling place jews
Guest
St johns place and utica/rochester /sterling place jews

It would be super nice if someone bought this and revive it back into a shul for us hidden who live here 😉 shabbos its not so easy to shelp kids to shul so far, this would change our lives. I live 3 minutes from this property!

Resident
Guest
Resident

Maybe it’s s sign not to sell to developers who will bring yuppies

Joe
Guest
Joe

We may not have shul’s turning into churches but similar trends are happening in c.h. every day. Nobody cares anymore.

To 16
Guest
To 16

Halacha says that a goy can nullify Avoda Zara I would assume that selling is considered nullifying.

Wow wow wow!
Guest
Wow wow wow!

Wow! Chills!
This is amazing! The discovery, the Hashgacha protis, the respect, the preservation, after all these years! This is an investment opportunity of a lifetime.
I wish I had the means!
Lucky you, whoever does!

To #16
Guest
To #16

True, I’m sure in their line of work, they got a heter
Regardless, it’s not my place to judge

To #4 & #10
Guest
To #4 & #10

Read the article
At 209…. In northern crown heights

I hope they update who purchases the property

Landlords & Developers?
Guest
Landlords & Developers?

It would be very nice if Sperlin, Malamud, Fischer etc joined forces to buy the building and perhaps turn it into a Kolel or something. There aren’t many people in Crown Heights with the money or the vision to buy and restore this makom kedusha. Of course, it wouldn’t make a profit, so I suspect #13 is right. Yet another CH tragedy.

25 and 13
Guest
25 and 13

Brilliant

Let's not get excited. ...
Guest
Let's not get excited. ...

This pastor has been trying to sell this building for over 2 years now. He now found a new way to market it, bring the Jews and show them what you preserved and see how much mone you can get. He is a smart guy. I met him many times. This is all a play on the naive. Sadly some Jewish ‘real estate’agents are helping him promote his sale. There were 2 Jewish schools that wanted to buy it, but the appraisal fell short of what they were asking. Here he has a new audience with these ‘agents’ helping him… Read more »

Rohr?
Guest
Rohr?

I noticed that in the first 2 pictures the last name Rohr is in the center. Maybe it’s a relative of George Rohr & he’d be interested in buying it.

its a siman that CH needs to expand as it was in the olden days
Guest
its a siman that CH needs to expand as it was in the olden days

Hope someone still has heart and maybe good donor to invest and open it as a new shul for all who loves around , to attract Jews to this side of CH

Ellen Levitt, Lost Synagogues of NYC
Guest
Ellen Levitt, Lost Synagogues of NYC

I documented this building briefly in my book The Lost Synagogues of Brooklyn (2009, Avotaynu). It is a few blocks away from another, larger former synagogue.
I have news for some of you: there are a few hundred former shuls in NYC alone, and probably 2/3 of them became churches. Like it or not, this is widely known. At this point I am the foremost historian of them. My Facebook page “The Lost Synagogues of New York City & NJ” features these.

To 27
Guest
To 27

If what youre saying is accurate, perhaps the realtors can use their incredible savviness to keep the price DOWN if its indeed bought as a shul.

Not so overpriced
Guest
Not so overpriced

They are asking 975k. Is that really so bad for the size of property sane location.

Sad but true story of American Jewry and their synagogues.
Guest
Sad but true story of American Jewry and their synagogues.

In past centuries in Europe and the Middle East Jews didn’t abandon their Shuls because the neighborhood was changing and property values were going down. They were forced to leave their homes and synagogues! They had no choices. But here in the US its been more a matter of comfort. In Europe and elsewhere synagogues were destroyed, here they’ve been sold! I know there’s more to it than this, but it’s still not the same. Amazing that goyim have preserved the Shuls here so well.

Kumzitz Yitz
Guest
Kumzitz Yitz

The south Bronx has many of these as well, leftover from a byegone era when it was a vibrant frum community. So sad.

Moshe
Guest
Moshe

Lubavitch would never abandon property in Crown Heights.

Wow!
Guest
Wow!

under the flooring is the mikvah! such a smart way to save space!

Not the first
Guest
Not the first

Many Shuls were sold to churches when Criwn Heights changed into a predominately black neighborhood in the late 60’s. People fled to Boro Park and Williamsburg by the thousands.

What we CAN do
Guest
What we CAN do

We readers might have the funds to buy this building, but we CAN put our efforts into improving Crown Heights (or wherever we live) through our Torah and mitzvos, and our mentchlichkeit…by raising our children the best we can, by using our G-d-given talents to the maximum…by being our very best selves. Won’t it be thrilling when Moshiach comes and all the abandoned shuls worldwide will return to their former, true splendor!

If there are Yiddisheh brokers involved...
Guest
If there are Yiddisheh brokers involved...

It would be nice of them and great for their ruchniusdikeh standing if they could forfeit any profit connected to this sale, thus making the building more affordable for the families who live close by and would love to have a built shul of their own. Is that asking too much? They might even consult with a rav and find out if such a “donation” could be considered maaser!

Miriam P.
Guest
Miriam P.

Amazing!!!

nostalgia
Guest
nostalgia

I attended cheder in this building in 1956. It was rented by satmar whose principal was R Chaim Berkowits a”h. who was also shamas in the shul. By 1957 the cheder moved to a different location & twice more until it ended up on Kinston & park pl. The pics evoked many memories of a struggling orthodox jewish community(satmar) among others. these were the survivors of the nazi germany. They didn’t know much about america. The only thing they were driven by was to raise families in the original mesorah they inherited. G-d blessed their endeavers. No one dreamt or… Read more »

Thank you # 41 for a little background on this shul,
Guest
Thank you # 41 for a little background on this shul,

very beautiful and touching. Wish someone could buy it with the intentions of using it as a shul again soon. Though I understand this is one of many unfortunately. משיח כאו!

X