By Zalman M. Isaacs
Nivul Peh.
Formerly forbidden, frowned upon, and outright unforgivable, foul words have recently reared their ugly head. Too often, I encounter them in casual conversation, or perhaps at the wheel of a car after a shortstop. They are sometimes used to punctuate a sentence, to drive home a point, and even uttered out of pure instinct.
Years ago, this language was reserved for certain elements of society. It used to reflect a person’s state of being. One’s choice of wording spoke volumes, toxic language meant a toxic soul. But things have changed. New terminologies have infiltrated our vocabulary. What used to be thought is now being articulated, what was once whispered is now shouted.
After some cursory googling, it seems that a certain stigma has been lifted. Psychologists now recommend that people mouth off from time to time. Studies have shown that cursing relieves stress, dulls the sensation of pain, fosters camaraderie among peers and is linked with traits like verbal fluency, openness and honesty.
In addition, modern literature (including; books, articles, and all forms of social media) is replete with all types of creative invectives.
As we are so immersed in this culture, it is easy to ignore our rapid degeneration. Wake up. We are in a sorry state. Our eidelkeit is vanishing, our innocence lost, our sensitivities are being dulled. Hence the urgent need to call attention to this disease.
Yidden are baishanim (shy and modest by nature). It is against our inherent nature to allow ourselves to speak so crassly. The Torah goes to extra lengths to refer to things in the purest manner possible. The Rebbe’s lexicon taught us invaluable lessons; how to refer to a hospital, cemetery, disabled unit in the army (beis refuah, beis hachaim, metzutanei tzahal). He coined the term “special needs”, highlighting only the positive.
It’s not for nothing that seforim say that a pgam in dibbur leads to pgam habris. Vulgarity is a slippery slope. We don’t want it to traverse from speech to action.
This brings to mind a graphic story that’s recounted in the Hayom Yom of 29 Tishrei. A mild dispute soured and lost all semblance of civility when it spiraled into a shouting match culminating in the gruesome curse “I will tear you apart like a fish!” Disturbed, the Baal Shem Tov instructed his disciples to stand together and hold each other’s hands with their eyes closed. Suddenly, they started to shriek in terror – the curse had begun to unfold before their eyes. They had all witnessed a traumatic vision of the dismemberment of that individual.
Although it was only a threat, there had been somewhat of a manifestation in reality. Words have power. We must not underestimate their impact.
Ponder this for a moment, and try to erase certain words from your dictionary, in an effort to sanitize your speech. Make sure to control yourself and curb your tongue, especially in those heated moments.
If chas veshalom, you do indeed die in a car accident, what are the last words you want to have muttered under your breath? Do you pass away with Shema Yisroel on your lips or…
Those in role model positions, must take extra heed. As with everything else, the greater the position of influence, the greater the responsibility. When you sully your tongue, it causes untold damage to those around you. Either they’ll adopt the lingo too, or they’ll be shattered and traumatized. It’s a lose-lose.
Where am I going with all this? Isn’t this a tangential issue, merely indicative of a larger problem? Let’s focus on the big picture, our integration in modern culture, our susceptibility to secular influences. Then we can point fingers at the institutions, and blame all who were negligent and allowed us to sink to such depths.
Perhaps.
But unlike the above, this doesn’t require much effort. We don’t need to assemble teams and crisis plans, the mosdos don’t need to hire new people, we don’t need to schedule events and take away people’s nights. It’s one simple thing to be mindful of – that’s it. Read this article, think about it, and forward it to a friend.
Some will argue that it is better not to discuss such topics.
Perhaps.
But I sincerely believe this will do more good than harm. Yes, it may seem childish to complain about such trivial things, but I feel that it can go a long way in furthering our eidelkeit as a community.
Again, it shouldn’t be too hard to amend this issue. We don’t need curriculums or panels, it’s something we can figure out together. We all agree it needs work, and simply raising awareness is enough to curb its spread.
Let us all come together, to reclaim the sanctity of speech.
To be honest the chasidim in Russia weren’t known to have the cleanest mouths…
we call it “nevel peh”!
I was thinking this the entire time, Chassidim always said things how they are, but my friend Nevel beat me to it. It seems like you have recently taken your head out of the sand and might be slightly insulted. It’s okay and natural; we’re going to be chassidim anyway.
Please clarify: how is saying things as they are equivalent to saying things using expletives?
Even their nivul peh was eidel! They said things like “putz” vikadoimeh. Not the foul filth that even teenagers are saying these days
Not using the F word simply because you don’t speak English has nothing to do with Eidelkeit. Sorry bud.
You know that, right? Now, can you find an example of one of those eltere chassidim using them?
Please ask your mashpia what putz means. And if he doesn’t know, ask your bubby.
Reb yoel once explained the difference between nivul Peh from a chossid back then like Zalman Moshe who had a message to bring out, and today’s garbage.
While I agree that words are powerful and it is important to use clean/refined/ Tznius language, I would just like to mention that the power of words continues even beyond clean speech. I can’t even begin to tell you just how many teachers in high schools and seminaries talk in a derogatory tone about other Yidden, not Lubavitchers. It’s embarrassing to remember Rabbis making demeaning jokes about people who go to therapy or believe in psychology. It’s heartbreaking that when the educators of our community want to get a point across, they choose the least sensitive path instead of using… Read more »
It seems the real problem that has “recently reared it’s ugly head” is the new “trend” of every slightly disgruntled community member feeling the need to write long op-eds decrying the “falling standards” or “shocking developments” in the community.
If you really cared to engage with the younger segments of the community whom you are so scared of falling to lower standards, you certainly wouldn’t have nivul peh at the top of your list for problems that need solving.
These type of criticisms indicate a latent holier-than-thou mentality, a desire to”keep up appearances”, not a genuine desire to solve anything.
It’s mind numbing to read such an ugly response to such a well meaning and truthful op-Ed. in fact it’s exactly this type of attitude and mentality that the author is referring too in what state of insensitivity some of the general oilam have descended into as a result of losing the inherent eidelkeit in their speech. As chasidim we are so well in touch with and aware that what mainly differentiates human beings from animals is the power of speech and therefore it is perfectly reasonable that the fundamental difference between us as yidden to the rest of humanity… Read more »
And why not take the time to to understand where the commenter is coming instead of ridiculing then and perpetuating the same cycle you say you want to avoid
though its definitely a start, as it can reflect/impact lots of other issues
I think what we have is a very caring community member who is trying to help us with one of the easier things we can do to improve ourselves. There is no question psychologically speaking that the language we use affects us. So even though it is common in everyone does it it is certainly something to try to work against. As a matter of fact, I can only admit because this is anonymous that yesterday I was so distraught over something that when speaking to one of the rabbonim in the shchuna I did drop a few foul words… Read more »
As someone who is no longer frum, I find that being particularly careful about language is very important. Yes there are other community issues, however, fixing one does not negate the other. Using poor language lends to an angry, lackadaisical personality shift which in turn leads to poor lifestyle choices and difficulty making changes in other aspects of life or sometimes even getting the help that is needed. This has been my observation with many people in both higher and lower class society. Those who use expletives more frequently are less grateful, less happy and more angry. It is a… Read more »
The issue is people or I’m sorry to have to write: yidden are becoming more and more heartless due to chinuch from a parent and thus the need for frustration to be released comes out due to so much negativity stocked up within a person instead of fixing their faults. Lately I’ve been hearing so much “gehanom” word that its totally uncalled for, for even parents to express it and children/teens/adults hear it, go through life experiences with it and begin to express it. It all started with: 1 parent!
Masks matter
The (political) science has determined that masks aren’t necessary, and indeed never were.
Thank you for bringing up this important issue! I am shocked to hear the language of some my 12 year olds friends! Something need to change
Your comment can be interpreted differently according to your age
If you think anash of yesteryear were not prone to drop some less than flattering terms at a Farbrengen boy have I got news for you
We are supposed to learn from them. Both follow in the positive things they did and also to learn that some things are just not becoming of a chossid and we should not do them.
I’m a shliach too!
We trained our children from an early age that not all the words they hear at home should be repeated outside the house.
i can use some of the words referred to in this article on you, but i will hold myself back… its because of people like yourself that our children are being “educated” in things ADULTS don’t speak about! why are they hearing these words at home exactly? being “chabad lite” (more like, chabad dark, or חב”ד ליידט פון זיי!), is not an excuse to corrupt your kids, let alone other’s, maybe its about time to move out of crown heights to a place where clean language, beards, tznius, and all our other chassidic (more like basic frum) values are optional,… Read more »
So you publicly disparage other Yidden let alone Chabad Chasidim and that’s OK?
When did the judgement committee get its marching orders to categorize people as Chabad light or Chabad dark or whatever?
Are you the one who issues Chabad membership cards?
You are correct, however, that this starts at home.
The comment you responded to is CLEARLY a joke
You don’t use them at home to begin with
I agree 100%
Lol funniest comment
Clean up your language and your children wont hear it to begin with. Thats a really messed up mindset.
Beautiful prose and very convincing.
The rebbe didn’t coin the term special needs. The Rebbe introduced the term “special”.
i was in a bad crash recently, and mouthed a expletive in front of a bunch of kids. I kind of pushed it out of my mind, i was to embarrassed to think about it. This was the reminder i needed to work on it, thank you!
Also be mindful of your safety, especially if you’re driving with kids.
Even secular well educated people refrain. Kal v chomer so should we. Lubavitcher Chassidim. It really lowers a person.
The secular well educated people I’ve encountered tend to be liberal and have some of the most filthy language one can imagine.
It’s almost like being addicted to a drug. For some it’s become a habit that very difficult to break. Also environmental influences can make it hard to stop & change. Alas it might have gone on already far too long. Hashem Y’rachem.
Did we become the mussar movement.
Enough with all the tochacho.
Since when did mussar become a bad word?
It’s really not mutually exclusive with Chabad.
And I’d suggest you listen to some farbrengens of olde, that’ll give you a nice dosage of well needed mussar.
You’re both wrong
Nobody needs a good dose of Mussar
Be kind
And this isn’t mussar it’s just written in a language that’s not making you feel good about yourself
True rebbeim didn’t always write rosy and nice things that you live hearing but that doesn’t compare to mussar
You’re overflowing with it
Another exciting op-ed on COL! Bochurim, do your thing
we need to fix this!
Liquid soap is the tried and true way to ensure clean mouths in my house
Also an effective way to traumatise your children, gifting them terrible memories of you and leaving lasting resentment.
I’m sure the Rebbe would have encouraged forcing a foul substance into the mouth a child.
Enjoy the soup, I hope your kids turn out frum with that method!
I can attest that this method works
You should soap your mouth after writing this
Liquid soap is the reason that the current generation uses foul language to begin with. They were never educated why not to use foul they just had their mouths washed with soap, given fines, and punished for using foul language instead of being educated on why it’s harmful.
You are absolutely right, it is such a shande and a chillul hashem. I can’t even
Oh cr** my supper is about to burn, bye
By far the best comment
So true! We NEED Moshiach!!
P.s. I was shocked and dismayed to learn that there were people parading around under my name…ואני מוחה ברבים כי נבלה עשה בישראל וכן לא יעשה!!
Signing off,
C.C.H.M.
Lollll…good comment to lighten the mood.
We might experience a nuclear Holocaust and you’re freaking out about people SWEARING?! Get your priorities straight dude. And science has shown that people who swear efficiently in the correct scenarios are more likely to have higher IQ’s, especially in language-based areas.
you should be aware that ruchniyus affects gashmiyus. You’re worried about a nuclear holocaust? Then work on that in the way that a Yid does, by increasing in Torah and mitzvos.
Purposely swearing doesn’t make you smarter, I hope you know that.
Smart people tend to swear more. Just helping out
This is the kind of real education we need
If speaking Holy has the below affect, just imagine what speaking toxic can affect. HaYom Yom Tevet 11 5703 Man’s life is dependent on the air around him. Without air he cannot live and the quality of life is dependent on the quality of air. In an atmosphere of Torah and mitzvot there is healthy life. In a G‑dless environment life is diseased, and one is constantly threatened with the possibility of being stricken with contagious maladies. The first general step in healing is to purify the atmosphere. Purification of the air is the task of every person familiar with… Read more »
Hashem is not going to destroy the world again. Maybe remember to say the bracha next time you see a rainbow.
Hashem will not destroy his creations again by a flood. That still leaves a very horrific option of which the world has become only very much more too capable of. Don’t be so complacent the situation is extremely serious.
You say that smarter people curse, I want a study or statistics of how many people curse. From what I see most people curse meaning that this study is not done correctly
The gemara in shabbos says that destruction comes to the world because of people that are מנוול פה and those who stand by silently
This beautiful world was created with holy words,let’s continue building…no time for distractions
Ein Oid Milvadoi
Instead of being mechazek the community with words of encouragement, you chose a backwards path. While the world burns, you’re worried about nivul peh. Don’t forget, most buchrim who are using such expletives heard it first in yeshiva. Oftentimes by mechanchim, menahalim, rabonim and mashpi’im (who think it’s cool to curse among buchrim to obtain social worth and create a sense of friendship). So before you preach about our degradation, take a look at our broken system. Bsurois Toivos!
Listen to yourself. “Instead of being mechazek the community”… you’re putting down its educators.
Facts
You think the world started burning last week ?
It’s been burning for years y’all are just blinded by your “American chocolatniker” life style’s so you’ve never seen it
I agree with you 100%. However, part of the problem is the world we live in. I was recently talking to an autistic teenager who used some foul language and when I told him I was surprised to hear that from him he told me what the dictionary said about it. The definition was “used to emphasize or express annoyance with someone or something” (although it did say vulgar expression). This means we have to work at least double as hard on the problem because we even have decent society to fight against. Yes, like you said, we are yidden… Read more »
What’s wrong if these words get used out and lose their power and meaning?
In camp thats where all the vulgar language starts immature bochurim and fried kids later become yungerlite and the rest is history…
Air fried or deep fried
Who starts it?
Well I usually keep my language clean, occasionally something will slip.
Last week I was sending an email and using voice to text to type it up. I used one of the less serious foul words and the voice to text put in the first letter of the word and then a bunch of asterisks. If even voice to text has the brains not to be vulgar, we probably should too.
It’s a setting on your phone lol it can be turned off
Beautifully written article. The author clearly mentions it’s not an earth shattering flaw – simply something to keep in mind and work on upping our standards of speech. While we’re on the topic, it’s high time with all the many fatherless r’l children in our community to STOP CALLING an evening of learning אבות ובנים – Father/Son. Yes, the little boy who can’t bring his father can bring an uncle/grandfather/older brother. Why rub his issue in his face? It’s meant to be a pleasant learning evening for ALL boys and adult males – be sensitive and call it that!! Remember… Read more »
A parent comes into the school for parent-teacher conferences. First item they plan to mention is how is the school subjecting their dear child to such language; after all, they must have learned that in school–couldn’t be at home.
Yet the teacher has the same concerns–how is that household allowing the child to use such language? After all, they couldn’t possibly have learned such words in the classroom!
The parent denies allowing such language at home; the teacher denies allowing such language at school.
The conclusion: “They must have heard it on the bus…”
This is my rule. I’ve made it very clear every to immediate family members and followed through on it. When children see its acceptable they copy. Protect your children as best you can to grow up with clean minds and mouths. There are ways to voice your frustration in a polite and clean way. Learn social emotional awareness and how to get rid if your mad in a non vulgar way. Hatzlacha to everyone who struggles with this. Thank you for the reminder! Something every human ca be reminded especially in difficult times!
Every yid has something to learn from them and your children should be aware of that just saying
“If you can’t say anything nice, say it in Yiddish”
So true
what do u expect us to do when all the people we’re supposed to look up to talk like that?
The adults cant hear you, please repeat that comment to them again! most realistic comment how this negativity gets passed down to the next generation and then they complain, “why?????”!👍for expressing it!👏👏👏
Exactly blame the source fix the problem there
what do u expect us to do when all the people we’re supposed to look up to talk like that?
I feel your pain but your obviously looking up to the wrong ppl. someone who speaks nivel pe should not be a role model or looked up to in any way shape or form.
-a great role model and mashpia
Yes! We all use this language because we hear it from adults. But when we use it, it’s extremely bad. Doesn’t make sense why.
I can tell you. Everytime my spouse says nivel peh I respect him less.
I hope you and your husband can have a conversation about this. Either spouse losing respect needs to be addressed!
There may be more issues present here then bad language
Seems like your looking for reasons to lose respect
Are you suggesting that years of emphasizing the way you look over whats on the inside in our education systems resulted in people not feeling the need to be careful with their words? Shocking. We definitely need curriculum and policy changes in yeshivas to accomplish what you’re speaking about.
Just reread the last few paragraphs, I beg you!
At least it’s bad words and not a Alcoholic or drug addiction! It’s from the better things. Wow! Really some narrow minded people here!
They can both be worked on. If someone suffers from alcohol or drug addiction, they should seek therapy. That is not to say that because one doesn’t suffer an addiction to either of the aforementioned substances, they need not work to be a better person.
The Frierdiker Rebbe asks three things from a Talmid 1) Shkeedah 2) Ahavas Reim and 3) Peh Noki
ספר השיחות תש”ג 120
What about loshon hara? What about being critical of others?
There are other forms of nivel peh that must be addressed.
Arguably these are worse.
Bilaam couldn’t even curse us. But today goyim and even BETWEEN US, its being done! For shame! (Btw who even knows what shame is today?! Oh but low, they know) yidden became THAT LOW?!
Different kind of curse
If you’re involved in learning nigle & chasidus. Regularly. You won’t swear. You’ll feel close to Hashem. Kovea itim. Basics of Judaism. Even if 15 mins. Need to learn without interruption. Try it. You’ll see. Your brain starts working differently.
Amar Abaye…. Let’s go.
This is long overdue
Why the racist title of excuse my French am I the only confused one here. It’s clickbait on the expense of subconsciously permeating the never ending stigma of French. It’s also a polite language like EVERY other language
Thank you
If we would emulate The Rebbe in pnimius as well as chitzoniyusdike things we would never have to have a “discussion” like this.
French is a beautiful language, how dare you slander it. The audacity!
They say a story of a guy who bought a new couch but he could not bring it through the front door, it was too big so he smashed a window to get it in. chassidim used to say this story to explain someone using nivul peh to get a point across, but to go around smashing windows is totally different.
Yet another blow-hard trying to control people.
What we actually need more of is, less judgement, more leadership by example, and reaching out to the needs of people.
The rest will certainly follow.
Today’s Tanya “לב” portion, is very apropos.
ph
What did it say plz ?
They say of your bored that can lead to bad things.
I guess there always a bright side in everything in life then, between the war in Ukraine and these op ed’s, we have never been more occupied.
So thank thank you to the brave men and women that keep having interesting things to write about. Y’all are heroes
BSD
As is stated in liqutei eitzot: “obscene speech gives wings to the primordial serpent. It flies through the world wreaking havoc.”
The only way I see to combat this is to increase in the verbal learning of the holy torah and the wondrous mysticism of our great sages. For speech is derived from the divine aspect of GeVURaH so it takes a great deal of sublime articulation to sweeten the severities via the divine aspect of CHeSeD.
With blessings and guidance from our great sages
NNNNM
i was a staff member for two years in a mainstream overnight camp, once a camper of mine cursed so i called him over and asked him “why would you even say such a word if you yourself know that it is a bad word?” his response? “well my dad says it all the time” i personally as a camper learned all the bad words in camp… in this camp i was a staff in, kids as little as 8 year old are cursing freely. besides for cursing they also know a lot of jokes and line related to inyanim… Read more »
Asking for a friend
It’s all because the fathers stay late in shul and come home late on shabbos afternoon
Only after overhearing conversations on Kingston Ave.
To the young commenter whose immediate defense of foul language was ‘We have bigger problems that need to be taken care of.’ Yes, we have bigger problems, but why is that an excuse to contribute to the “smaller” problems? And who says uncouth and vulgar language is such a “small” problem anyway? It’s one “small” step closer to yucky, uncouth behavior; deny the fact who can.
Meg men zein uber redden tur men nisht? While I appreciate the concern of the author, I’d rather focus on changing the behavior of all of us. Action speaks louder than words. And yes, there are times when we need to speak the truth without sugar coating it. Yakeh Yose es Yose. The harsh words and nivul peh can penetrate into people who act like menuvalim and the message resignates better. There is a reason why the psychologists encourage it. Because it allows us to express ourselves. Please don’t silence our voices and feelings, in the name of Judiasm. I’ve… Read more »
The other day I was walking down Kingston Ave, and got stuck behind 2 girls and couldn’t overtake. It was on that annoying block between Crown and Carroll with no space to pass. B’kitzur I was privy to their conversation. I was shocked to hear the way they were talking about husbands that stay in 770 until 2PM on shabbos to farbreng. The vulgar language and nivul peh they used to describe them, was utterly horrific. I’m calling on our entire community, teachers and principals to teach the girls that their husbands need to farbreng on shabbos day, and ITS… Read more »
But if you look in the sicha of Parshas Noach, the Rebbementions that the Torah speaks in a refined way, with a story, when stating what halacha is, the Torah, uses the word Tameh so nobody gets confused. Also there are many expressions of frustration in the Torah, for example Rivka Imenu said ” I am disgusted with my life ( if yakov intermarries) the modern “slang” being fml. Also Shaul hamelech told called his son “son of a rebellious women” and the gemara does mention a bad person is called a dog by people, so there is some source… Read more »
If you’d like to say something foul (no matter how bad) while still keeping your “aidelkeit”, stick to the old rule they used in the “alter yoren” which said ” say it in Yiddish and it’ll sound chassidish”
a staff member in one of the main chabad camps was saying bad words in yiddish to kids- later we gave him mouthwash but thats besides the point
I was once walking up Kingston and some guy that looked like a Russian Chassid nearly ran over a kid and his father. The father started cursing him out in front of his kid, and the kid was smiling. He had no idea what those words meant. He was only 6 years old! But yet he saw the power in those words; he nearly got hurt c”v, and now he sees that if his father, a role model, says these words to somebody and it invokes control and power, he will likely do the same… (I’m not one to judge… Read more »