ב"ה
Saturday, 20 Tishri, 5780
  |  October 19, 2019

Rabbi Heller Criticizes Homework

Speaking to Crown Heights teachers, senior Rabbi Yosef Heller called homework "an excessive burden" and tests "intimidating." Full Story

‘770’ Mansion Up for Sale in Illinois

Next Story »

When My Father Opposed Yeshiva

115
Opinions and Comments

To keep track of your comments, follow a conversation or flag a comment Login
avatar
  Subscribe  
newest oldest most voted
Notify of
Melamdim Kolel Erev
Guest
Melamdim Kolel Erev

I want to express my gratitude to this kolel,What a great way for Teachers to unite- through learning Torah! It definitely has a positive impact on their students. Thank you to Igud Hamelamdim for all that you do for us Chabad Teachers!

 rabbi heller!
Guest
rabbi heller!

i totally agree!

Learning never ends
Guest
Learning never ends

proof is in the pudding, Seeing Teachers come in their own time to sit and learn,shows what the’re up to,KOL HAKAVOD!

Homework = Negtlectful educational practice
Guest
Homework = Negtlectful educational practice

Homework has non jewish origins for children in public school with minimal hours and irresponsible teachers that leave half the work and all the review to be done at home wothout their supervision. Homework doesn’t belong in a Jewish school with longer hours and teachers that should be careful to teach everything under their aupervision. If there isn’t enough time to squeeze in the curriculum, then plan the curriculum better next time. In our community, the children are left with little time to play and unwind. A teacher has no business unburdening part of the curriculum to the child’s hometime… Read more »

crem de la crem
Guest
crem de la crem

Keep rocking Rabbi Raskin and Rabbi Cousin. You do great work!

kids need to be taught in a language they understand
Guest
kids need to be taught in a language they understand

they learn taitsh in yiddish, and will often know the taitsh but not know what it means in English, so essentially they are not properly understanding what they are learning

what about kriah skills, comprehension skills
Guest
what about kriah skills, comprehension skills

many kids have not mastered these

homework
Guest
homework

It can be made optional. That’s what Lamplighter’s Yeshiva already does…look into how they do it!

Important note
Guest
Important note

Rabbi heller also strongly opposes having internet in the house, let alone granting children access to the web.
It’s quite obvious that without homework kids will spend more time on computers and the like, this hed probably support homework.

We need more
Guest
We need more

We need more like Rabbi Heller. He seems to understand the importance of being sensitive to the complexity of teaching and learning. More is not better, necessarily. Meaningful lessons are more educational than thoughtless rote. Keeping an evaluative eye and ear on a student’s learning is important, and assuming that a lesson presented is a lesson learned is ineffective teaching.

 wen saying that for years !
Guest
wen saying that for years !

i Never encouraged my kids to do homework and they never did it until they were old enough to do it themselves and even then i made them stop when i thought they have done enough ,made them to crafts , read , cook and bake go on family trips and walks and didn’t care when the teachers complained , i just stopped going to PTA. they all very balanced , good students , polite and caring individuals , very smart , they passed all their exams well , went to sem and yeshiva , did well and got married… Read more »

Thank You
Guest
Thank You

that is really encouraging as a student.
also no gemer

Agree
Guest
Agree

100 percent

Ch’er
Guest
Ch’er

Well well. Finally a voice of reason. Thank you Rabbi Heller.

Oh is he right
Guest
Oh is he right

Years ago there was no homework in limudei kodesh. The funny thing is that all these new fancy learning methods didn’t exist yet nor did homework and the kids grew up knowing how to learn. But as the years go on new complicated methods are introduced and loads of homework get added and the average boy or bochur can’t learn a bit of Gemoro on his own without Artscroll or the like nor can many learn Chumash with Rashi. Maybe it’s time to wake up from all this nonsense and go back to the old methods which were straight and… Read more »

Great thinking
Guest
Great thinking

In many places in the world where homework is not allowed its been proven children perform better. The brain is stressed with homework and tests and it doesn’t allow the right drugs to the brain, which come in for clear thinking and good performance

a better option
Guest
a better option

For todays times , a forward thinking director of a school, implemented a no homework policy, but instead, parents need to spend 20 min quality time with their child, without phones or interruptions
children bring a note to say what they did with their parents.

100%
Guest
100%

A teacher who can leave a fire in you when young it will last a lifetime
Yasher koach HaRav Heller

Children failing tests
Guest
Children failing tests

Great point. Perhaps it’s not the student that failed the test.
It’s the teacher that failed to reach the student.

MRS PERL ARBOR
Guest
MRS PERL ARBOR

BORUCH HASHEM RABBI HELLER HAS SPOKEN OUT ON THIS. KOL HAKOVOID. THIS SHOULD BE PUBLICISED THE WORLD OVER NOT JUST IN CROWN HEIGHTS. THE MISTAKEN AGENDA OF THOSE WHO PROFESS TO KNOW HOW TO TEACH AND INSPIRE AND WORSE GIVE SPECIAL ATTENTION TO THE CLEVERER ONES AT THE EXPENSE OF THOSE KIDS WHO STRUGGLE IN THE MISTAKEN BELIEF THEY WILL SUCCEED SO WHY NOT PUT ALL OUR ENERGIES INTO THOSE “SMARTER MORE DILIGENT KIDS. HELLO? HOW WRONG THEY ARE. THOUSANDS OF KIDS WHO “SUCCEEDED” IN THEIR CHADORIM AND MECHINAS MESIFTAS AND EVEN INITIALLY AT YESHIVAS HAVE EITHER DROPPED OUT OF… Read more »

CHINUCH VHADROCHO
Guest
CHINUCH VHADROCHO

THE MOST IMPORTANT STATEMENT ON CHINUCH EVER PUBLICISED ON COL

Alfred E Newman
Guest
Alfred E Newman

Make the teaching of TORAH an enjoyable experience for kids
GREAT AGAIN.

Cancel homework today!!!
Guest
Cancel homework today!!!
Montrealer
Guest
Montrealer

I know kids who have actually dropped out of school b/c of the humiliation they faced when teacher reacted to undone homework, day after day. Kids had no one at home who knew French or Hebrew well enough to help, and no $ to hire tutor.

Chinuch expert
Guest
Chinuch expert

Rabbi Heller really understands kids! He should become our schools advisers instead of all the modern secular ones that are failing!

Right on!
Guest
Right on!

I applaud Rabbi Heller’s position!! Excessive burdens on child and parents!

So special
Guest
So special

Anyway to share a recording?

Mother of six kh
Guest
Mother of six kh

Finally finally a voice of reason Homework has become a PARENT׳S nightmare and little children come home from 8 hours a day of work and the first thing they have to do is more schoolwork! All Montessori type schools believe homework means a teachers failure to cover the subject in school Please educators let’s all review this contentious practice in all schools and all subjects If you MUST give homework place a limit If your child is six years old he gets six minutes LETS STOP STRESSING OUR CHILDREN AND PARENTS UNNECESSARILY It’s hard for a mother of multiple school… Read more »

Finland stopped homework
Guest
Finland stopped homework

Finland stopped homework for same reasons and saw a major increase in grades

The Rebbe's opinion
Guest
The Rebbe's opinion

It’s very known that the Rebbe was very pro tests. Reports and monitoring progress. Etc.

Gd Bless Rabbi Heller
Guest
Gd Bless Rabbi Heller

The ONLY time a child should have homework is either if they are having difficulty in a subject and need extra help to keep up with class, or if they were horsing around in class and didn’t do their school work (to make up the work)
It is crazy that some of my kids spend over 3 hours of homework a night!

To number 29
Guest
To number 29

“grades”? Means they do testing…..

Strongly disagree
Guest
Strongly disagree

I’ve been a limudei kodesh teacher for 15+ years. I don’t give HW every night, prob 3x a week. That said, it is all about what type of HW is being given. Reviewing Pessukim in Chumash will only help the student the next day, or preparing a Rashi helps a student become more proficient. The Gemara (quoted in Tanya too) says ideal is to review 101 times!! If the HW given is just “busy work” then there is no value to that. But I have seen on a consistent basis that those who do their HW (short assignments that are… Read more »

To #32 re: Finland
Guest
To #32 re: Finland
So On Point
Guest
So On Point

About time someone speaks the truth

Boruch hashem
Guest
Boruch hashem

Finally people are starting to realize. There’s 1 thing more important . And when the people “in charge of CINUCH” will recognize and implement that 1 thing, then our kids will want to continue to behave with yiras shomayim. (and not have the desire to abandon everything) That 1 thing is. The kids need to feel and recognize that theis educators REALLY CARE FOR THEM. And be a role model of yiras shomayim and true AHAVAS YISROEL. this super ingredient is the cement that holds the whole building together. When this ingredient is MISSING, then the whole building will ח”ו… Read more »

This headline is misleading
Guest
This headline is misleading

He spoke about the importance of getting students to love yiddishkeit. I was there…HW was not the main issue and he said it can be a burden and children need to unwind. A far cry from the way this headline makes it sound like it was all about HW.

To 15
Guest
To 15

I remind you that “in the old days”, not every boy and girl went to school. Most young people went to work. Only the smart one’s went to Yeshivas, today everyone goes.

HELLO BAIS RIVKAH?
Guest
HELLO BAIS RIVKAH?

100 teachers giving 5 hours of homework each day.
I’ve seen it up close.

Bais Rivkah gives 10 hours of homework each day! Kids have no life!
Guest
Bais Rivkah gives 10 hours of homework each day! Kids have no life!

Hmmmm… why do they hate learning?

Larry
Guest
Larry

Forget about coming home to do homework The homework that these teachers give to the kids to do at home that’s completely not normal for instance this past week my daughter had a test and had to study of what you say And where to say certain things in the עמידה The high holidays What the heck is that relevant to 4 weeks after the high holidays It isn’t there more important things to give a kid to study that will be relevant to their daily lives of being a better person and a better Jew?

To 15
Guest
To 15

I agree with #38, the good old days are a myth. Most Jews did not have the opportunity to learn. The great talmidei chachamim you speak of represent so few of our numbers. We also beat kids senseless. Ahh, the good old days…

#9 & #17
Guest
#9 & #17

Don’t have the school give HW because of poor parenting skills.

It’s also not the teachers place on dictating and deciding how the family’s bonding time works.

I heard a teacher say ” I give HW so i know the parent will have at least 15 minutes with their son” how insane is that?!?!?!

The chinuch system these days
Guest
The chinuch system these days

most of the people working in the chinuch system these days don’t belong there

Principal
Guest
Principal

You will not like what I am about to say but it is the truth, but please hear me out in full. We purposly give homework because it is a burden on the family! With all the distractions that we have nowadays, there are many homes where the parents are not involved in their children’s Chinuch, the families lives are focused around sports and vacations instead of Torah and education. By us jamming you with homework we force the children and parents to have a school focused home, a home where the children are busy with their learning, a home… Read more »

the genius from #29
Guest
the genius from #29

of course grades went up, because the curriculum became less demanding. It’s not that the kids started learning better or became smarter. (Well, maybe yes, but the way you are writing it is logically fallacious.)

Dear  honorable  Principal comment 45
Guest
Dear honorable Principal comment 45

Dear Principal
Then maybe part of the curriculum should be focused on teaching kids how to fill their extra time with quality choices such as using their creative talents with learning to play an instrument or art by bringing creative arts into the Yeshiva which is also a major relaxer which will help kids feel better about themselves and help them learn the taught material better so that they will love school and be happy with themselves

10000% Agree
Guest
10000% Agree

From the second we get home from an already long day the only time my kids have at home is doing homework, dinner and bath. There is absolutely no free time, this is a very stressful time. When my kids were younger, after school time was spent going to the park or surprising them by taking them out for ice cream. Some parents love homework, because from what I’ve been told, how are they supposed to entertain their kids for the evening. I hate that mentality. I agree to homework for some extent, like working on fun on going projects… Read more »

#45
Guest
#45

leave your job!!! you belong in a different occupation. i have a school focused home and we learn Torah as well but i would like my kids to have time to be kids as well. The homework pressure is destroying jewish homes and marriages.

Chabad schools: Are you listening?
Guest
Chabad schools: Are you listening?

Heartfelt pleas from moms and dads how YOUR homework policy is ruining lives
Have a heart

#45
Guest
#45

Your school should be closed down! Don’t you know about large families! Kids gain much more from cutting a salad and interacting with family members! I hated school because all of it was about homework and tests! We couldn’t enjoy any learning. When I see my teachers today all I feel is hate- there was an atmosphere of trying to get you! I was a good student, got good grades and hated every minute! Now I go to a shiur, learn and enjoy! Thank you Rabbi Heller for seeing things clearly once again!

Yesssssss #12!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Guest
Yesssssss #12!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Gemer is a waste of time,energy, patience, and EVERYTHING!!!!!!
Pls put an end to it NOW!!!!

Wake up teachers!!!
Guest
Wake up teachers!!!

14 teachers are “only” giving 10 minute of homework ….plussssss… gemer and tests…and all the ridiculous out of school learning…

Well do the math.

There's worse:
Guest
There's worse:

In my child’s school even if you get a 100% on a test but you didn’t get it signed by your parent you are penalized! Now, how crazy is that?

Bais Rivkah girls have homework 24/7
Guest
Bais Rivkah girls have homework 24/7

Their 39 teachers (and the Tuldos) each give three hours of homework each day.
Add that up.

Selfish teachers give loads of homework so they feel good about themselves
Guest
Selfish teachers give loads of homework so they feel good about themselves

Bais Rivkah, just make sure you drive your students even more crazy by increasing their insane homework load from five hours a day to ten. That will definitely make them love learning more.

High School Overdoes the Homework
Guest
High School Overdoes the Homework

Whether you agree with homework or not, there needs to at least be a limit. The amount of homework high school girls get now is absurd!! The principals claim it’s to keep the girls occuppied so they shouldn’t have time for other things. But 5 hrs a night is way over board. The girls who are doing the “other” things will do it anyways. And the other girls who are majority are being bogged down with unnecessary homework, assignments, projects, tests and daily quizzes to study for…HIGH SCHOOL GIRLS DON’T EVEN HAVE TIME ANYMORE TO HELP OUT AT HOME BECAUSE… Read more »

Keep dreaming ppl
Guest
Keep dreaming ppl

It ain’t gonna change

Keep dreaming

Rav Dovid Klein
Guest
Rav Dovid Klein

BSD One of the major foundations of our Chassidic movement, Lubavitch, founded by Rebbe Yisroel Bal Shem Tov is SIMCHA !!!! I am greatly inspired by Rav Heller’s comments about teaching enthusiasm to the young people. It is much more important to teach a young Lubavitcher Chossid to be b’Simcha (to be happy with his Yiddishkeit) and to be very enthused about it than to focus so so much on the technical skills of learning. However, on the other hand, all of Rabbosenu Nasieinu (Our Rebbes, Our Leaders) have always taught us to not be amei ho’aretz, ignorant of the… Read more »

Purpose of real homework is just a short review
Guest
Purpose of real homework is just a short review

“Homework” is abused by Bais Rivkah and other schools where “teachers” pile load upon loads of work on the students to snuff out any life left in them.

To 45
Guest
To 45

Learning needs to be a lifestyle and not a forced upon burden.
Doing it the way you describe will guarantee that when the child finishes the system, they will use their newfound freedom to turn to all these outlets you describe.

To 33
Guest
To 33

If the children need the review from home to succeed in your class, you should strongly consider fitting in that extra review into your class schedule during your classtime so that even the student that don’t know how or do not do their review at home can also do well in your class.

@ 24
Guest
@ 24

Yes! That’s so true! I’m a high school student and I am really suffering from all this homework!! After a long exhausting day in school with 10 periods and multiple teachers, I finally get home at six pm. I eat a quick supper and it homework time, till anout 12 am. The next day I’m tired, frustrated and pressured, because I still didn’t manage to finish it all so I wake up at 5 am to finish. The schedule is really killing me. It’s a reall issue! My life is overtaken by homework, I have NO time to myself to… Read more »

והגית בו יומם ולילה
Guest
והגית בו יומם ולילה

שו”ע יו”ד סי’ רמ”ה סעי’ י”א: יושב ומלמדם כל היום וקצת מהלילה כדי לחנכם ללמוד ביום ובלילה.
If the child is home before evening, then the father seems have the mitzvah to teach his son a bit in the evening.

There is a boss
Guest
There is a boss

I think the Rabbi’s main point is not so clear here.

I was at the talk he said the main think for all of chinuch is to give the kids and boachrim a cahyus to want to learn they should have a love for torah and miztvos all the rest was just to exsplain and clarify the love for learning torah.

Therefore anything that takes away from that be it homework, tests, missions, finishing a perek, parsha or sefer if it takes away from the above is not helping…

missed the point
Guest
missed the point

why did this thread become a teacher punching bag?
this surely wasn’t Rabbi Heller’s intention. Plenty of students visit this website, how in the world are they supposed to respect their teachers if everywhere they turn they see their teachers being bashed?
Remember you can have complaints against the teachers, but to make it a public discussion only harms OUR children’s education.

15  responding to 38 and 42
Guest
15 responding to 38 and 42

What are you guys talking about. I was talking about when I was a kid and those who grew up then know how to learn on their own. There was not homework and no fancy methods. Today’s generation most cant learn on their own.

what a powerful quote
Guest
what a powerful quote

“It’s not about how much material you cover, but how much you inspire them to learn. If you fire them up with a love for Torah, you’ve in essence taught them the entire Torah,”
How true how true how true!!!

Check out Ami magazine this week
Guest
Check out Ami magazine this week

There’s an article about how HW teaches kids responsibility and those who do it are more successful in life and more self-disciplined. Just saying there’s another side here too…

Last I checked school was for learning, not to dump on the home life
Guest
Last I checked school was for learning, not to dump on the home life

Guess it’s easier for a “teacher” to make the student learn everything at home instead of teaching it at school which you’d think is their job. I guess not.

to #69
Guest
to #69

Yes, responsible and reasonable homework that’s used as a modest supplement to the school studies.
Not when they have to sit for hours every night learning what should have been taught to them at school. Kids need a life and time to unwind to avoid burn out.

Following the lead
Guest
Following the lead

It’s beautiful to see Rabbi Heller following the example set by Menachem Education Foundation and speaking about such important issues concerning our children’s chinuch. Beautiful job!

Mother & Teacher
Guest
Mother & Teacher

I once got A+ on a Gemorrah test when I had to study with my son when my husband was out of town. I’m very proud of that (my son was happy, too.)

Homework should be review – brief, 10 mins max. Or perhaps looking over tomorrow’s lesson in advance. As for testing… I detest it. Tests only prove how well kids can memorize ; they don’t show if the students can apply the concept in other cases. I gave as few as possible to my students, but boy, did they work hard IN class!

9th grade girl
Guest
9th grade girl

I just entered high school, and I had to stay home from lack of sleep. when I came back, lo and behold! I had to stay up till 3 catching up! please lower the mount of homework! last time I had a normal conversation with my family was sukkos!

I agree
Guest
I agree

I was reading these comments and crying. I’m a good student, with mostly good grades. I but way much hmwk and tests. Girls study for hours the night before, and then still on skl try to finish was wasn’t yet done during their breaks. It’s riddiculous, and sad. Girls do drop out from the stress. It’s a fact. We have lives too, we can’t spend so much of our time on hmwk. Everyone agrees that your teenage years are the hardest. Why make it harder???? We just want to LIVE!!

To 69
Guest
To 69

There’s homework the way it’s supposed to be, and there’s homework as it’s abused by teachers.
Get the difference?

He should give a lecture to Bais Rivkah
Guest
He should give a lecture to Bais Rivkah

They could definitely learn a thing or two from him.

I all HS teachers see this!!!!!!!!!!!!
Guest
I all HS teachers see this!!!!!!!!!!!!

!

From 8th/9th grade Bais Rivkah turns the girls into slaves
Guest
From 8th/9th grade Bais Rivkah turns the girls into slaves

They’re STUDENTS meant to be TAUGHT in school, not SLAVES doing mind/back breaking labor for egotistical teachers/overlords.

To principal 45
Guest
To principal 45

I will never send my child to your school. I an figure out what my child will do after school hours. There are many, many activities available. And they will be good Jess who love Torah and have a well balanced happier experience.

Please.
Guest
Please.

Effective teachers and principal’s know that toouch homework takes a toll on students. That much homework is most often such a burden that a student doesn’t benefit much, if at all. Do we not want our children to love learning? And Bais Rivkah, it sounds like your thinking about homework could use some serious review. My child will not be attending your school, because I want my child to feel not burdened, but rather enthused about learning.

Dear #45
Guest
Dear #45

Why are you a principal? Perhaps you might want to take a step back and do your own 5 hours of homework nightly, studying experts in the field. Times have changed. We adapt. We adapt to technology, vehicles, any number of evolving things. Education evolves as well. Could you at least consider an open conversation about it?

To 66
Guest
To 66

You have a good point but unfortunately too many teachers don’t get it (ego is tough to overcome you know), effectively making themselves a punching bag.

to 57
Guest
to 57

The girls high schools (BRHS especially) don’t care if kids help out at home.
As long as they do 10 hours of homework each day.

WE AREN'T BASHING TEACHERS PER SE
Guest
WE AREN'T BASHING TEACHERS PER SE

But rather school policy (that too many teachers sadly follow).

NOT ALL TEACHERS ARE BAD!
Guest
NOT ALL TEACHERS ARE BAD!

But teacher who abuse and harass students with homework are.

Thank You #51
Guest
Thank You #51

You expressed exactly how me and my friends and our kids feel.

You hit it right on target

Thank you

I love homework
Guest
I love homework

I agree that excessive homework is not appropriate.
However, homework invites a parent to be part of their child’s chinuch. A parent can also bring a new perspective to what a child is learning.
My child’s chinuch is my responsibility and I appreciate the opportunity that homework gives me to help create a positive attitude to learning.

Agree #9
Guest
Agree #9

You have to take that into consideration. The more they use the web the more they loose their fire for any learning. No matter how good the teacher! Less homework-yes. But also More playing ball with your family in the back yard!!!

Homework in my opinion
Guest
Homework in my opinion

is not fair. There are some families where there is parental guidance and help and in some families less or none. Why should the children with less help lose out. A good memory doesn’t necessarily mean you have other types of intelligence. Why should children suffer bec. they have a weak memory. Tests are often all about memory.

homework only makes sense when
Guest
homework only makes sense when

you have to read something on your own time and write a paper about it. Should be allowed several days or even weeks depending on the project. But tons of homework that’s due every single day whether or not it makes sense for the student will only overwhelm her and she’ll end up forgetting everything anyway after the year is over.

Full speech
Guest
Full speech

Please post ful speech

IT ISNT ROCKET SCIENCE
Guest
IT ISNT ROCKET SCIENCE

#45
If you believe that you are in the wrong profession or a total idiot.
I pity the kids in your school.
You sit for 5 hours a night terrified about failing a test the next day. We need to instill a pleasant enjoyable learning experience not an oppressive miserable one so the kids grow to love learning torah naturally.

Many teachers are good!
Guest
Many teachers are good!

And they don’t abuse homework or the students.

HOMEWORK NOT LONGER THAN 20 MINUTES A DAY
Guest
HOMEWORK NOT LONGER THAN 20 MINUTES A DAY

Any objections?

Homework = brief review at home
Guest
Homework = brief review at home

Longer than that is a teacher’s dereliction of duty to teach adequately at school.

To 66
Guest
To 66

We’re not making all teachers punching bags.
Just those who (figuratively) punch their students.

There are many good teachers that this doesn’t pertain to.

The good teachers use homework properly
Guest
The good teachers use homework properly

Since they teach well at school all the students need is a short review at home.
Longer homework indicates a problem with the teacher’s teaching and/or personality.

Bais Rivkah please pay heed
Guest
Bais Rivkah please pay heed

Many parents and former students (and definitely current ones) are furious with your abusive homework policy that allows teacher to harass students with as much as homework they wish.

If you’re responsible, you’d change it now. Not because of what parents and students want, but because it’s the right thing for many reasons.

Not just HW, Tests are also part of the insanity
Guest
Not just HW, Tests are also part of the insanity

Here is how I did tests for very many years as a teacher. Teach all the answers to the upcoming test. The test is merely a mirror of what we plan to learn. After the test, had children do SELF-CORRECTION. I told them the answers, how to grade, and THEY did it themselves. THEY then wrote their grade. Publicity is not necessary. They gave me their test for my review, and I then returned it to them. Result: – What was important to know was known at the outset, by all. – Multiple review of what had to be learned… Read more »

whasapp msg
Guest
whasapp msg

are there whatsapp groups for the classes at beis rivka? If so, someone can make a petition and parents can sign it and send to the principal demanding minimum amount of hmwk.

# 100
Guest
# 100

Where do you teach ?
Lucky mosad to have you

Homework to generate parental involvement.
Guest
Homework to generate parental involvement.

Suppose someone has between 7 and 15 children bla”h, and all of the children who bring home homework, bring “officially only four subjects” each child, “officially only 20 minutes” each subject per each child, Plus “just one ‘project'” each child that is due in 2 weeks. Assuming these conservative estimates reflect the reality, which we all know they do not–in the very real world these estimates are far too conservative–can you please tell me which sain person considers such imposed parental involvement as reasonable? Besides there are some subjects that I don’t know how to help with. The primary one… Read more »

When I was young
Guest
When I was young

Many decades ago in the public school system I went to homework was not given until 2nd grade so we looked forward to it as something special. Parents weren’t allowed to help with reading , spelling, math tables, or other subjects. What we were learning was made interesting because we discussed it or “showed off’ our learning proudly. If we were having difficulties teachers communicated with our parents in a spirit of teamwork. As we got in higher grades, homework increased but never so much that we didn’t have time to do it and also enjoy dinner with the family,… Read more »

First curriculum written in this weeks parsha, road on
Guest
First curriculum written in this weeks parsha, road on

All had to fit to one measure and standard. If not you were either cut short or stretched longer. A quote from one of the leading educators in our generation. In as much as teachers are expected to tailor their lessons and subsequent expectations based on a particular child’s ability to learn. Homework need not be different. Expections of homework should not be one size fits all, for it really can’t fit all. As principal of many years, homework often becomes a teachers means of communicating to his parent audience, “look at my class, see how hard, how much we… Read more »

ALFRED E NEWMAN
Guest
ALFRED E NEWMAN

If every MECHANECH or Menahel was subjected to the scrunity for competence by the Sefer Chinuch Vhadrocho, they would fail miserably.
You need to be born to teach, not teach to live

There are many good teachers
Guest
There are many good teachers

And they know how to use the homework system properly and as intended.

I totally agree
Guest
I totally agree

most kids in younger grades don’t fully finish their homework, and if they do, its not always not properly. I think teachers would have it easier if they ,say, practiced kriah more in school then send it home where its barely done.
Also, if the teachers know that the cant send homework, they’ll make sure to make use class time better.
I think that, at most, they should have 10-15 min. a day, if the teacher is in a school that they have to give homework.

Most Prominent Non-Chasidic Chinuch Expert on Homework
Guest
Most Prominent Non-Chasidic Chinuch Expert on Homework

Rabbi Yaakov Bender Slams Homework In Op-Ed To Mishpacha Magazine The letter I received from out of town contained a plea for help and guidance from a frum father navigating a particularly onerous challenge in chinuch habanim — and a relatively new one. My son spends close to eight hours in school. When he arrives back at home we want to be able to kick back and relax together. We would also love to be able to spend the time with him and our other children pressure-free, playing a game, having a catch, reading or just stam schmoozing — which,… Read more »

When you cram and push too much, it doesn't sink in
Guest
When you cram and push too much, it doesn't sink in

I used to do tons of homework when i was in school and I did get all A’s. But I forgot almost everything the next year. So I worked so hard and had no life, no time for friends, for nothing.

To 104
Guest
To 104

The piblic school day ends somewhere around 2:30 pm
Lets compare apples with apples.

Testing within reason
Guest
Testing within reason

Memorization, applied reasoning and critical thinking are skills that need to be built from a very young age. The way memory games and puzzles ‘test’ and thus train these skills for preschoolers, memory and thinking questions test and train these skills for older children and adults. However, it needs to be done within reason of the memorization and thinking skills appropriate for that age group. It’s true that learning and processing come naturally, which is why I agree with with open styled school and class environments as well as plenty of free time, which means less homework, however, memorization, applied… Read more »

agree with comment #60
Guest
agree with comment #60

there is a place for homework in a child’s life. it is a way to revisit and briefly review what was taught/learned in class. it is NOT a way to shift incompleted lessons to the child or to his/her parents and family to teach. a quick h.w. review serves a dual purpose. 1) it solidifies the material in the student’s mind while it the material is still fresh and easily recalled. 2) it clarifies what, if any, part of the lesson the student hasn’t really grasped well and needs to have re-explained to them. often a student thinks they understood… Read more »

To 112
Guest
To 112

Among other things you wrote “To everyone here complaining about the memorization required for tests, it’s a crucial skill for life and the maintenance of healthy neurons” Crucial beyond this life skill is LOVING YIDDISHKEIT, LOVING TORAH, LOVING LEARNING. Its time we kept the main thing the main thing. And I have news for you. Pressure motivates some, compelles many, but repells most from LOVING Hasem, Torah & learning. SINCE WHEN IS THE MAIN GOAL OF TEACHING MEMORIZATION SKILLS? If you cover less, remember less BUT YOU DO love Hashem & love learning His Torah, how important as ANYTHING ELSE… Read more »

To 114
Guest
To 114

I hear you and agree. Abosultely loving yiddishkeit Torah and learning is tops. However, I wouldn’t call that a skill. In terms of skill, memory is the the corner skill upon which all other skills are built. Memory isn’t taught, but rather trained. The training begins with speaking to your newborns and playing memory styled games with your toddler and preschooler. At that point the child is usually motivated by an attitude of can-do and a love of learning to explore and remember more on their own, and tests are supplements, though necessary ones. However, that doesn’t mean that it… Read more »

X