It all started with a phone call I shouldn’t have picked up. I am great at ignoring phone calls, but today, for some reason, I am hearing my father while I am in bed.
“Zaidy passed away last night can you take me to the airport and take over my business for a week?”
All the punctuation there is correct. There were no commas, no ellipsis and no exclamation marks. The flood of marks I saw was from me, not from the phone. All the phone gave was that little question mark at the end which asked for one thing: a mundane yes. Which it got, and two of them.
The ride and the business faded away and Zaidy came into my screen. He was there from then until now—and hour before the livayah–and he’s only getting stronger and stronger.
As I head to my father house, I was greeted with a good morning by an old friend. Today he tells me good morning? It’s not a good morning! Who says it’s a morning altogether. If Zaidy is not here, then maybe morning is also not here. Zaidy was always here. Zaidy never changed in my short 25 years. How can one phone call change it all?
As I continued with my day, I realized that it was not just the phone call that was off, the whole day is; everything is different today. Everything is the same, but everything is different. Today zaidy is not here. And he will never be here again.
I come to my father’s house and see a man praying. Perhaps it’s good he’s praying, I have nothing to say to him anyway. But why is he praying? I never knew you have to pray when Zaidy is not here. It’s not a regular day, and on a not-regular day, regular things should not happen.
I didn’t even know that zaidy was sick—my father did not tell me. My father is a man who does not seek attention through pain, even—and especially—his own. For this reason he did not tell my siblings what happened today either, so I picked up my phone and spammed them this text:
BARUCH DAYAN EMES!!!
ZAIDY PASSED AWAY LAST NIGHT!
TATTY IS FLYING FROM
NEWARK AT 1:15
I am bombarded with details. How did it happen? When did it happen? Where did it happen? But in all of these questions, I see one painful thought: how is it possible for zaidy to leave us.
Yes it’s painful, and that’s my point today.
Zaidy was 93, but to me he was Zaidy. To me he was Zaidy from Eretz Yisroel. To me he was my Tatty’s Tatty. He was the one who made sure I was not on the bus that blew up. He was the one who made sure I did not die, and today he died himself?
I am not saying that he was the best Zaidy, he probably wasn’t. I am just saying that he was Zaidy. He was Zaidy and he is Zaidy, and he will always be Zaidy, even if he was 93.
But all my feelings shattered when my father asked me to wait while answering a phone call. “Nigmar histaryah,” he said while his stomach breathed deeper then I have ever seen. All his limbs fell out of place; the muscles holding them together were gone. Gone together with Zaidy.
It was then that I realized that what to me was Zaidy was to him Tatty. Tatty for sure can not go away! But that’s what happened today. That’s what happened in that phone call. It happened, though everything I see says otherwise.
While driving to my father’s business, I saw many cars on the road. That too, I did not understand. What are cars doing here when Zaidy is gone?
On the news sites, Zaidy’s passing is almost good news. Besides being words to fill up an intimidating white paper, the editors go on to say his age! It says it almost before his name. It starts with his age, continues with his accomplishments, and finishes with his many children. No where does it say what I know. No where does it say that Zaidy passed away. No where does it say that he will never come back. Of course Moshaich is coming, of course Zaidy will be back, but Zaidy was not supposed to leave in the first place. Not my Zaidy.
When I tell my father’s friends that Zaidy passed away, they sigh; but are relieved when they hear that he was 93. Who cares about 93? Zaidy was not 93! Zaidy was Zaidy. Who cares if he accomplished, and who cares if he did not accomplish; who cares if he had children, and who cares if he didn’t have children; today, one thing matters, and one thing only: My Zaidy.
At the levayah of Reb Yudel Chitrik obm, I remember my principal was proud of his sharpness and subsequently repeated this many times: “This is a good levayah.” He said, everyone else thought it. Everyone except the children. And today I am the children.
Though that principal is not here today, though that levayah was not Zaidy’s, I hear him saying it about my Zaidy. I hear everyone saying it about my zaidy. And to you, everyone, let me say one thing: you have it wrong and I have it right. I promise. For as my father will wish goodbye to his father, he will not be thinking that it is a good levayah. He will be thinking what I am thinking: this is the worst levayah on earth.
He will be thinking about Tatty. Tatty who kissed him and Tatty who slapped him; tatty who laughed for him and tatty who cried for him. And then, when he will finish thinking of all the things tatty did and did not do, he will return to think what he already thought: Tatty…Tatty…Oh Tatty!
“Its Okay he was 116” “It will be alright” “oy vey Moshiach Now!”
Tell it to the children and einiklach and brothers and sisters
Tell it to the one..vchu Emunah and bitachon are great but not to be used as clichés to comfort people, they’re meant for you to use on yourself.
The Bilsofsky video explains it.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ci-8Z3H4KVY
In no way is this a criticism of any sort-I’m just interested why when people suffer a loss others say only simchas??I notice people write about Moshiach and I understand that he is very much wanted but while others are grieving and only thinking of that particular emotion, why are simchas and other such statements made? I truly want to understand the meaning behind this.I notice it is always on these comments when tragedies occur- someone help me get this so I dont think anything negative such as “why these cliches” and who does this help?Thank you.
very well written. Only simchos!
thsi brought me to tears. truly amazing.
can you please identify the shliach. I curious for several reasons.
I can relate with every inch of my body my zeidy didnt die as an old man he wasnt even sixty! Two of my uncles passed away and people are always telling me how special they are but it doesnt take away the fact that they are gone, no longer with me! its been over four years since my zeidy has passed away and there is still that void in my heart but that void will never go away! My heart is crushed but i have to glue it back together and try to move on. I wish you much… Read more »
Wow.
As a newly-wed young man,I had the zechus to drive Reb Shmuel around when he came to Melbourne to collect for Tomchei Tmimim in Kfar Chabad. we developed a warm freindship, especially since he also knew my father ob”m and the other emmisaries who came to Australia to establish the Chabad comminity here. What was evident by the way people received Reb Shmuel into their homes, that they immediately recognized a Jew with exceptional chassidishe middois toivois , humility and sincerety. I envisaged that he would have been a clone of Reb Itche der massmid. What a giant of a… Read more »
In yechidus for a bar-mitzvah of the son of a shliach back in the late 60’s, the Rebbe questioned the shliach on all aspects of the upcoming bar-mitzvah. There were close to 400 balle baatim,as well as the Reform Rabbi,conservative,misnagdishe etc all expected. The Rebbe then asked which chassidim would be coming from NY. I remember my father listing Rabbi Jacobson,Feter Hendel, Shimon Goldman,Mendel Shemtov ,Shmuel Aizik,and others. The Rebbbe then said that Reb Shmuel Gurevitch is here now from EY and he should be asked to also attend and he came then as a shliach to my bar mitzvah… Read more »
very true but i think you should be grateful for his long life/health etc. my grandmother passed away at 90, peacefully in her sleep, and when looking around at this brutal world, there is no greater blessing than that.
The point is, that you have to thank for those 25 years you did have him, when I was 6 I had no more grandparents alive, I barely remember my grandmother! So of course it is your zaidy you lost and it is really hard, but please look back at those years you were able to spend with him and thank the aibershter for what you had! May his neshama have an aliyah!
Your words are painfully moving and deeply touching.
Hamakom Yinacheim Eschem Besoich Sha’ar Aveilei Tzion VeYerushalayim.
I agree with you. My father passed away young, but the age does not matter. We just need Moshiach already!
to be honest i never heard of your grfa. but in your piece i saw raw, heartfelt pain of the loss and it hit me in the gut.i feel like crying for someone who meant so much to a family,Since when does age ever define a loss or degree of grief,This was a beautiful tribute to the love of a grandson for his dear grandfather and it meant a lot to me personally.
i do not usually comment, but you compelled me to.
thank you for putting it into words. truly true
powerful and incredibly well written. A little editing and this would be amazing.
Thanks for sharing your perspective. It is so important for people to realize.
I think many grandchildren who have experienced the death of a beloved grandparent feel the exact same way. Very beautifully written!!! Heart wrenching!! May you be comforted among the mourners of Zion and Yerushalayim.
I don’t mean that just in general. You are the grandson of R. Shmuel and great-grandson of Reb Itche der Masmid, who was renowned for accepting nothing but the whole emes in every situation in life. Your article is real and very deep and inspiring. I’m sure it makes both of them proud. May your zeide’s neshama have an aliya in the zechus of what you wrote, and may you be reunited with him immediately in Yerushalayim with Moshiach.
I feel for you.
Your pain is obvious, and real. Very real.
There is a reason why an onen is patur from mitzvos. Your writing clearly portrays why.
When in pain, there are no explanations, no reassurances. Nothing. Except to know that others are with you, and here for you.
So what I want to say to you is this – I don’t know you personally, I don’t even know your name, but R’ Yid, I know you, and care for you. And I feel for you.
What a poignant article…I totally relate. When my zeide, R’ Meir Itkin, passed away at the age of 96, I felt the exact same way…the age was [almost] completely irrelevant.
BS”D
This was the truest article i have seen in my life. Thank you for opening my eyes from a personal perspective.