How to Make Music During Sefirah
Students of Bais Menachem Yeshiva in Wilkes-Barre, PA, used the most unlikely tools to create 'music' during the Sefirah period. Video
Students of Bais Menachem Yeshiva in Wilkes-Barre, PA, used the most unlikely tools to create 'music' during the Sefirah period. Video
this is amazing and talented, keep up he good work.
Fantastic job. Looks too complex for the average Joe! Keep up the good work. Hope to see more of your work soon!
Weather or not its halachikly approved for sfira is for a rav not col comments, but definitely qualifies as talent and creativity! Use it for good things and serving Hashem!
Oh my gooooosh wow
And funny!
Who says electronic music isn’t music?
Wow talented! That’s all I can say!
Wilkes produces the best music ever!!!
Talented place!
Wilkes produces the best music ever!!!
Talented place!
All year round people say Electronic Music isn’t music, but all of a sudden during Sefirah they say it’s an instrument and halachikly forbidden! Just confused..
if you are listening to this “akapella” music during sefirah, you may as well just listen to real music with instruments, and you are doing the same thing.
Super original, and creative idea!
sefira tunes? maybe not… but def. the making of a viral music video… Keep at it!
You guys have real talent… I am not sure of the halachic status of listening to it, but I am sure that there is no problem producing it! Really creative.
If a regular listener cannot tell the difference, then it is music
Good on you guys. You are lucky to be in wilkes where neshamos burn bright. I feel sorry for the negative commentators they will never get a chance to see mamash miracles in that unassuming town. These kids music will usher in mashiach
A machine playing recorded music of ANY kind is basically instrumental music. Why does it matter if the original was vocal but now it is reproduced by a machine or if the original was an instrument now reproduced by a machine? Why does it matter if the original was made by someone drumming a drum or someone drumming on a table? Ultimately, there is no such thing as music that is allowed during sefira unless it is live people singing. See matzav.com that Rav Yisrael Belsky (see also Shulchan Halevi 13:6 of Rav Belsky) and Rav Shlomo Miller differentiate between… Read more »
whether halachic or not. this is amazing. keep up the good work, creativity, and studies. -The Shul- Member, Cincinnati Ohio, Elbrook Ave!!!
Did anyone ask a rav if it’s permitted? Sure sounds like music to me. Why do they have to try to find a way around the halacha? It doesn’t seem right. In yerushalayim I remember a drum being used alone at a wedding to avoid musical instruments. This reminds me of it. But it wasn’t during sefira then.
I must say,that is very creative!
Wow! Is it permissible because what produces the sounds are not considered instruments? Wondering
What talent! Way to go!
(I can’t wait for all the machmirim and shoite-chassidim to crawl out of the woodwork and start decrying.)
Way to go LEVYTICUS and BMAD!! This is very talented, you guys have amazing potential, keep it up!!
R U kidding me? …If it walks like a duck… Quacks like a duck… Swims like a duck… then it must be a duck. Sounds like music to me.
Perhaps all this points to one direction: Better just listen to plain ole’ music and direct your time to studying Torah and Ahavat Yisroel, vs. all the time wasted in coming up with “alternatives” to real music.
That’s awesome!!
Way to go boys!
Wild stuff. This kind of thing can go viral
Amazing!!!
I must say that he’s very talented and creative but hate to break it to you that using “sampling” to make sounds and feeding it through studio software is essentially exactly what synthesizer or keyboard music is so I wouldn’t call it “sfira” music.
Who are we trying to fool? If it sounds like music it is music