ב"ה
Sunday, 20 Tammuz, 5780
  |  July 12, 2020

Live:

Crown Heights Has Shown That Lives Matter

From the COLlive inbox: "You want to know what it means that lives matter? Let me explain to you what that looked like in our Crown Heights community for the past few months." Full Story

Live: Unique Frum High School Holds Open House

Next Story »

Gimmel Tammuz: Observances, Resources

21
Opinions and Comments

To keep track of your comments, follow a conversation or flag a comment Login
avatar
  Subscribe  
newest oldest most voted
Notify of
A Chidush!
Guest
A Chidush!

A gevaldike chides

Focus on what you could be doing better...
Guest
Focus on what you could be doing better...

Condescending, and you missed the point of the BLM conversation taking place. Of course there is much to be learned from our community, but the BLM plea is simply that their lives should be valued in the eyes of the police, and other parties of our society. Some (too many) rotten apples in the police force, or American society at large, don’t feel like black lives matter equally, and are therefore quicker to “throw one away”. That’s all they’re saying. Noone is denying that the black communities have shortcomings, or issues within themselves, but that isn’t our concern. Let’s not… Read more »

You’re lecturing
Guest
You’re lecturing

ALL lives matter and Jews shouldn’t be scared to walk down the street even more so in the hood! My son was almost attacked today by an angry black man so scary

Yes all lives matter
Guest
Yes all lives matter

No Jews shouldn’t have to be scared.
But we can point out the merits of the lubavitch community, without implying that it is the way the blacks treat themselves, that is responsible for their lives “mattering less” in the eyes of some racist Americans.

He didn't apply that!
Guest
He didn't apply that!

How ridiculous “yes all lives matter”. You obviously missed his point. Ethics guides a community, steadies a community, uplifts a community. Not race baiting, grandstanding or violence on those who had NOTHING TO DO WITH ANY OF THIS. Stop defending horrible behavior.

Who missed the point?
Guest
Who missed the point?

By ‘BLM conversation’ do you mean the rioting, looting and nightly fireworks that disregard everyone else’s safety and security? Or do you mean the ‘conversation’ taking place between those that illegally and forcefully occupied a public area and are negotiating to only give it back if their demands are met? The original op-ed writer was not pointing out shortcomings in the black community nor denying that there could be bad apples who treat others unfairly. The writer was pointing out which actions demonstrate that other’s lives matter and that many in the CH community have been doing so, naturally and… Read more »

How terribly deaf you are to the suffering
Guest
How terribly deaf you are to the suffering

Of those who aren’t ‘your’ community!
Yes, our community showed that every single life matters. But that should mean we are all the more sensitive to everybody’s life! OUr stores weren’t looted, and that’s your ‘moral equivalence’??? The message of the nationwide protests is t hat some people are treated worse than others ONLY because of their skin color. This is true of black lubavitchers also! So if you care about every life, even if you care about only Lubavitcher lives, then you should care that skin color NEVER s hould matter!!

The BLM Plea is not so "Simple"
Guest
The BLM Plea is not so "Simple"

For starters, BLM officially endorses BDS. That means they would like to see Eretz Yisrael brought down economically. That alone is a deal-breaker for me: Why should anyone who loves Israel then respect the organization called BLM, regardless of whatever else they may espouse? (But of course all lives DO matter, organization or not!) Second: Nearly every penny given to BLM goes directly to candidates from the Democrat party running for office. I, for one, prefer to judge candidates by the content of their platform and character, not by whether there is a “D” next to their name. And we… Read more »

Dear author of above comment
Guest
Dear author of above comment

As you so well said, you should “cut your own nails” before your tell others to cut them, and get a real-actual-what-is really-going-on reality check.

The BLM conversation
Guest
The BLM conversation

BLM conversation has absolutely nothing to do with protecting and supporting black lives. If it did, it would concern itself with the many mamy good black people that are unprotected and hurting from the looting, defund the police movement, and inner city problems…BLM does absolutely zero to help them. If it was about the black people they would be doing things such as those described in this article.Please call a spade, a spade.

Do all black lives matter
Guest
Do all black lives matter

In your comment you make a case for the BLM movement by stating that certain members of the police and society do not value black lives. What you do not include is the staggering amount of black lives who are lost to inter-gang black on black violence. Just this past weekend over 130 people were shot in Chicago, NY, and MN INCLUDING 5 CHILDREN and not a peep from the BLM movement or allies such as yourself. Your hypocrisy is astounding as you have clearly demonstrated that you only care about blacks loosing their life when it makes you look… Read more »

Well said
Guest
Well said

Eloquently explained

Beaitiful
Guest
Beaitiful

You will have naysayers like post above
Please ignore

Nice message!
Guest
Nice message!

But not sure why it has to be put in context of “lives mattering” when it’s a sensitive topic right now. Seems to be passively belittling the movement about lives mattering…

We'll said
Guest
We'll said

We’ll said

True!
Guest
True!

A shining example – for those that care to take note and follow.

Pittsburgh Shooting
Guest
Pittsburgh Shooting

Right after the Tree of Life shooting took place in Pittsburgh, there was an immediate action to pass a resolution in the senate condemning antisemitism. The resolution addressed antisemitism initially, but then, other groups, including one led by the disgusting Ilhan Omar screamed “what about us? Don’t we matter too?!” and the language of the resolution was ultimately watered down to include anti-muslim sentiment and condemned overall hate and bigotry – ultimately a waste against antisemitism being particularly recognized even though it clearly should be. This isn’t our fight, folks. Crying out “all lives matter” is watering down the cries… Read more »

Beautifully done
Guest
Beautifully done

Well said

Not the time to speak of ourselves as ants..
Guest
Not the time to speak of ourselves as ants..

Ashreinu. Good on you for having pride in our blessed community. We have much to teach the world about how to take care of each other and there’s no time like the present to start. The issues being battled out in the streets would be practically irrelevant if people invested more in their communities and less on government programs that have all but decimated the inner city communities. BLM cares as much about black lives as frum Jews care about how many shrimp there are in the sea. Read more, dear people of the Book. There are plenty of black… Read more »

BLM is bad!!
Guest
BLM is bad!!

They don’t care about black lives.
Antifa is behind the BLM.
Educate yourself ppl!
They don’t protest when any black man is killed. Only if done by a white cop. There’s an agenda here.

Beautiful article!
Guest
Beautiful article!

The message is 100% true and put beautifully. Ashreinu!

X