ב"ה
Monday, 15 Shevat, 5786
  |  February 2, 2026

Cigarettes Not a Frum Habit

Op-Ed: On Motzoei Shabbos, a pack of cigarettes is shared amongst the desperate people "dying" after 25 hours. And the message to teens and young adults is very clear. Full Story

The Rebbe Picked Up the Phone

Next Story »

Chabad Raffles Off 101 Bottles

61 Comments
oldest
newest most voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
My brother smokes.
April 8, 2011 2:14 am

And I’m really scared, he’s so young! sometimes I wonder where he even gets them from, but then I remember, it’s not hard. No offense, this is like the most basic of basic introduction to smoking, and does not give me any advice on how to even approach it with him, with him being open to receiving. I see it as one of two ways: 1. You can try the scare tactic. that is “you will contact so and so disease'”(G-d forbid) personally I don’t think this works. 2. Another approach is the “it’s not G-dly approach. Good luck. You… Read more »

All you guys who think you're cool!
March 3, 2011 11:46 am

As a mother, I wouldn’t want my daughter dating someone who smokes either. And to all you Bochurim who say you will stop for your wife, why don’t you stop now? Why wait for your wife to stop you? You are missing out on an opportunity to meet some good girls… A good girl does not want someone who smokes, Not just for the potential dangers involved. It also shows a lot on the charachter of the bochur. He is obviously not a happy, stable boy if he felt the need to start smoking L’chatchila. It’s not so cool after… Read more »

you should know... all u guys...
March 3, 2011 10:56 am

in seminairies they tell girls do not go out with somone who smoks.

to all the people who say: the Rebbes smoke
March 2, 2011 8:56 pm

in those days, they didnt know that smoking wasnt heathy!

To all the people that say "the Rabbeim smoked"
March 2, 2011 5:17 pm

They smoked simple pipes, which contained not much more than plain tobacco. None of the nicotine, chemicals, or other things meant to addict the user.

To # 55:
March 2, 2011 12:26 am

Great comment! Every word is so true!

Thank you for this important article
March 1, 2011 10:01 pm

We live in a scary world today. It seems every time you turn around, there is another study coming out which shows how something else that we enjoy is not healthy for us. Don’t eat salt… it will raise your blood pressure. Don’t drink alcohol… it will lead to traffic accidents, domestic violence, vitamin deficiency, and liver failure. Don’t smoke marijuana… it will lead to amotivational syndrome. Aren’t there any vices that we can enjoy in all good conscience anymore? In truth, for just about everything we enjoy in life, there is some study which tells us why it is… Read more »

They are Anti-Torah
March 1, 2011 3:04 pm

Don’t make an excuse to smoke, its dumb. Its your Yetzer hara talking, do what hashem wants… Be his Chussid not the Cig’s.

To #37
March 1, 2011 1:59 am

A great guy who smokes occasionally ?? Are you kidding?
Those who start smoking in this day & age when we know how dangerous smoking is have issues. These could be ADHD, low self esteem , very low intelligence…
What exactly is great about that?
Everyone talks of cancer but it’s not only that. How about:
Lung disease
Artery blockages
Infertility
Liver cancer
There’s more…
I’ll pass on the occasional “great guy” smoker any time, thanks.

To #3:
February 28, 2011 4:17 pm

Someone finally has the audacity to speak up against smoking in the frum community and you are whining about it???! So very sad.

I Quit
February 28, 2011 2:48 pm

i quit (5 years ago) when my wife got pregnant which was after 9 years of smoking two packs per day. I wish I had role models who concentrated their efforts in my generation to educate us to quit smoking–or to not start at all.
P.S. I used Zyban and it worked perfectly. Good luck to all those “Quitters”.

Self medication
February 28, 2011 8:14 am

#3 – people who smoke are using cigarette as self medication, try Ritalin it’s safer & more effective.
Yeshivas should not employ anyone who smokes.
I would never consider a smoker as a shidduch for my kids either, no one wants their daughter to become a widow.
I have seen this first hand.
I will not let anyone smoke near me either, second hand smoke is just as dangerous.

Rebbeim and poskim
February 28, 2011 12:14 am

The notion that “the Rebbeim smoked” makes it ok. The facts of smoking were simply not well known. If you look in early poskim they talk about the benefits being “shovoh lechol efesh” which is why it’s allowed on Yom tov.

Obviously we now know that there are no health benefits.

It is a shame that chareidi rabbis don;t come out and say it’s ossur. If they can forbid internet why can’t they forbid smoking????

cigarettes are discusting
February 27, 2011 10:50 pm

i am a lubavich girl and all i can say is that i have no respect for any rabbi or person that cannot hold themselves back from this cravings because what about the mitzvah to watch ur health??? THIS KILLS THE HUMAN BODY. and it kills other along with you. it shows that your craving comes before hashems comandment to watch ur body, cuz if u cared enough u wudnt be doing something that KILLS your body- its just a matter of time

....
February 27, 2011 6:33 pm

the reason people smoked than and it was fine was because they didnt know how bad it was.

did not know
February 27, 2011 4:29 pm

40 years ago people did not know that smoking harms one’s health. But now a days there is NO EXCUSE. Teachers, Rebbis, parents any one who smokes take heed there are people out there willing to help you quit. For the sake of the next generation get help.
Schools should get involved, speak to the students while they are young and explain the dangers why one should not smoke.
Hatzlochoh

Turn off Jews by smoking
February 27, 2011 4:05 pm

I’d like to reiterate what a previous poster wrote. The sentiment you are about to read IS FACTUALLY repeated in every Chabad House the world over. Frum smokers turn off people from Yiddishkeit. Here is what was written: people have to be careful because i have a friend who is becoming frum and when she saw a bachur smoking on Kingston she was shocked and said” when my dad sees people like this, it makes him not want to keep Shabbos, because he says that the Torah says to take care of your health and here they are smoking!!!!” so… Read more »

Create A Stigma
February 27, 2011 4:01 pm

– If, we get more and more smoking-bashing articles like this (thank COL for this important article), – If we had Rabbonim (from multiple segments of the frum world) at the very least state that it is wrong to start smoking, – If we convinced shuls, stores and every other public place to ban smoking in their buildings, we might then create the appropriate sense of derision towards smoking. Of all segments of the modern world, it is the frum world is one of the (if not the) most behind on this subject. Create a environment in which PEOPLE FEEL… Read more »

Another Happy Non Smoker Thanks to Allen Carr's Method
February 27, 2011 10:54 am

I second the other Allen Carr user. An amazing book. Highly recommend it to anyone who is thinking about quiting or knows anyone who is considering quiting. Will change the way you think about smoking forever.

to comment #13
February 27, 2011 10:53 am

the minute they heard that cigarettes are not healthy that instant they(the rebbe and the frierdike rebbe) stopet smoking and 2. torah “chasa al mamon israel ” IT COUST ALOT OF MONEY

Did you know
February 27, 2011 10:31 am

“Tobacco is the only legally available consumer product which kills people when used entirely as intended.”
-The Oxford Medical Companion, 1994

Just saying
February 27, 2011 7:53 am

It’s so annoying when people use the ” this is frum/not frum” argument to prove their personal issues. “smoking is against the Torah” or ” smoking is not not Kosher”. This is a human issue- to have a better quality of live (cheaper and less ilness) and to live longer don’t smoke. Smoking is not immoral- other things are!

To #3 all joking aside, obesity is a huge problem in our community
February 27, 2011 6:03 am

The Rambam writes quite disparagingly of those “whose belly extends…”. He considers it a trait for boors and ignoramuses. We know that it will kill you. For the sake of your children, if you have any or plan to have in the future: don’t smoke, eat healthy and exercise.

The Rebbe and Lark
February 27, 2011 5:03 am

What of the story that the Rebbe smoked Lark cigarettes at one time? Also nonsense – or was it before the nesius?

to #24
February 27, 2011 2:33 am

whoa whoa! take it easy mrs.! don`t think you`re gonna manipulate your children in every way you would like to. it`s kind of extreme to say what your saying. I mean, maybe there CAN ACTUALLY be a great guy who smokes occasionaly! does that make every other part of him “disgusting” and “smelly”?!? what if your own child is a smoker and you don`t even know about it?? (which is actually the case with most young smokers)!! maybe you should start being a little more sensitive to people who smoke, and not just exclude them from the category of human-beings… Read more »

smoke everywhere!!!!
February 27, 2011 1:09 am

there are smokers everywhere!!!! whether they are jewish, non jewish, frum, chassidish or chilled. it is very common now and if you smoke or not, it does not determine whether you are chassidush or not (its addicting) However, people have to becareful because i have a friend who is becoming frum and when she saw a bachur smoking on kingston she was shocked and said” when my dad sees people like this, it makes him not want to keep shabbos, because he says that the torah says to take care of your health and here they are smoking!!!!” so we… Read more »

SECOND HAND SMOKE!!!!!
February 27, 2011 1:03 am

second hand smoke kills as well!!!!! so if you smoke and you dont care about the effects on yourself, have concern for your family and friends and dont KILL them!!!!!!!!!! Its not fair to those who want to live, to have to suffer everyday when they walk down the street or leave their house, because every person they walk by is smoking. (how long can we hold our breath for already. )

to #13 (and #32)
February 27, 2011 12:46 am

Stop spreading a lie I have not heard from one reliable source about the Rebbe smoking. What we heard was a rumor that in the early years there was smoke seen in Rebbe’s room. Non of the Rebbe’s mazkirim (secretaries) verified this rumor or other people who were around those days. Stop spreading this foolish rumor. And to #29: In previous generation many things were done because of a lack of awareness or scientific findings. In these days when we all know the undisputed fact that smoking is dangerous for out health, there is no reason whatsoever to touch a… Read more »

well what about our roshei yeshivos?
February 27, 2011 12:29 am

excellent, informative article! its about time, this is brought open to our open community! I wonder what you expect our bochurim to say when they see their own magid shiur walk in the street and smoking????? very mixed message. please parents talk to your children about how bad it is to smoke. you be surprised, our children hear what we are saying and in the end they will thank you for this important message.

to 13
February 27, 2011 12:23 am

OMG some1 plz tell me that’s not true?!!?!

Mixed Review
February 27, 2011 12:22 am

First of all I applaud you for speaking out against a terrible habit, and especially loved the anecdote about the founder of AA dying from cigarettes. I am concerned about your lack of details when you say the salesmen of cigarettes are in the Shul or Yeshiva and you dont explain. You also make it sound like this is epidemic of these places by your omission of detail. I do agree however the religious world seems to lack education in the area of healthy living. Yeshivahs should have curriculums that include the dangers of alcohol, drugs and cigarettes from a… Read more »

Mendy
February 27, 2011 12:07 am

Stop the Machlokes in Crown heights, that is a bigger problem.

kosher????
February 26, 2011 11:38 pm

don’t use the word Kosher or not kosher when it comes to cigarettes because you are misinforming people of the use of kosher as far as food and other things are concerned, Great Rebbe’s smoked in the last generation so don’t say that they used some thing not kosher.

to #3
February 26, 2011 11:33 pm

You are absolutely correct. The next article should be about the problem of obesity in the community. Smoking and obesity are two of the largest contributors to the decline of the standard of health in our communities and society as a whole. Maybe with some education (or at least awareness) we can help overcome these dangerous hurdles.
🙂

#3 helloo
February 26, 2011 11:32 pm

are you kidding? smoking is an avaira, you are knowingly harming your body!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Wrongo
February 26, 2011 11:31 pm

Smoking cigs is actually a very “frum thing to do”. I’m a bt and when I was in public high school, all the guys thought smoking cigarettes was disgusting and now, I see teenaged boys all over CH smoking thinking it’s “normal”. Of course not only frum people smoke but the heading of this article isn’t quite true.

Reb Y
February 26, 2011 10:57 pm

I agree with this article totaly!

not smoking shidduch
February 26, 2011 10:51 pm

I have made it clear to my own children that smoking is a filthy disgusting smelly habit, and that I will not accept anyone as potential shidduch material who smokes for my children, and would likely seek to find out of others, including their parents smoke, and that would definatley impact on any and all shidduch considerations

years ago a frum doctor talked of this and....
February 26, 2011 10:45 pm

BS”D

suggested to take a Vit B injection to support the breaking of the habit. it worked. Vit B – it was a mega B if i remember.
Have to say i was sooo relaxed for about 2 weeks. awesome.
p.s. cigarettes are a seriously disgusting habit. when you give it up, you cant stand to be anywhere near them.

#9 - agree
February 26, 2011 10:33 pm

…if only there were tzniusdik gyms… Related, much of the diet (in addition to us being sedentary most of the time) is cause for concern – high fat, high sugar, high carb… high everything (including large portion sizes) and minimal physical activity/exertion. We’re not burning off all the energy we’re taking in.

Also, all the snacks/noshes/desserts we buy premade… full of processed and artificial chemicals (check out the ingredients in most parve “treats”) …Altogether, a recipe for diabetes and further tzuris. LaBriut!

to number 3
February 26, 2011 10:23 pm

denile ain’t just a river in egypt and from many of the responses to articles on this site re addiction one can see that there’s an awful lot of denile by us.

We have enough personal character habits to refine already
February 26, 2011 10:15 pm

…why create a new burden against your life by taking up smoking? Don’t even put your kavanah on cigarettes, and just tell yourself “It’s not for me”… like treif. Don’t we already have enough bad habits to work on?! Don’t become a slave to cigarette addiction – don’t give into satan. Focus your energies and time on mitzvot, ahavos Yisroel, and Hashem, instead of on an object that takes your money (that could be used for tzedakah), your time, your energy and health, and robs your focus away from life, mitzvot, and Hashem. Thank you for discussing this issue among… Read more »

to #8
February 26, 2011 10:13 pm

That was the Freidiker Rebbe.
And since when is smoking “chassidishe” #3?

thanks
February 26, 2011 10:07 pm

i think the article answers its own question, people dont realize the effects immediately and therefore dont think it harms them…
well… its time to wake up and smell the coffee… SMOKING KILLS!!!!!!

benzene.
February 26, 2011 10:05 pm

Benzene is also a ingredient you forgot

great article
February 26, 2011 10:02 pm

smoking is suicide.

Yasher Koach
February 26, 2011 9:32 pm

A much needed and well written article, may these efforts to stop smoking bring much success and good health to all
(you didn’t mention effects on people from second hand smoke, which could also cause health problems) and a most disturbing sight iis to see a father pushing his child in a stroller and smoking at the same time

happy former smoker!
February 26, 2011 9:27 pm

AlanCarr’s Easyway method is the best way to stop smoking.They have a seminar with a money-back guarantee if it doesn’t work.(They are the only tobacco cessation orginazation to offer such a guarantee!) He has also written a book called The easy way to stop smoking which has sold over a million copies. http://www.theeasywaytostopsmoking.com/

question
February 26, 2011 9:20 pm

Didn’t the Rebbe and all other Rebbeim smoke too?

frum???
February 26, 2011 9:03 pm

tel that to the generations of chassidim whom smoked over the years
what a stupid way of trying to get an anti-smoking message out there

this is from a 12 year old who knows better than those adults who smoke
February 26, 2011 8:49 pm

to # 3 drinking coke is a unhealthy habit and it shouldnt be used so often but it DOSENT kill
SMOKING DOES

unfortunely some people dont take it serious till its to late
and dont say at least ill enjoy life because in the end im going to enjoy life more than you for not smoking those disgracefull paper rolls filled with

CARBON
MONOXIDE
NICOTINE
AMMONA
ARSENIC
HYDROGEN CYANIDE
METHANOL
FORMALDEHYDE
NITRIC ACID
NAPHTHALENE
TAR

Watched my father die from them.
February 26, 2011 8:13 pm

Even after he quit for 15 years.
How about the expense?

Finally!
February 26, 2011 8:05 pm

Yasher Koach for finally writing something that is so necessary and important. It is utterly ridiculous that anyone would smoke in the frum community. And to #3, I hope the next article is about the issues of health such as obesity and sodas and all the other problems in the frum community. Perhaps you have heard the phrase “guard your health?” well take it to heart. What a complete chilul Hashem that we have rabbis walking around speaking about the importance of G-dliness as they are significantly overweight and not doing the first thing to take care of their G-dly… Read more »

Who said this?
February 26, 2011 7:38 pm

“Forbidden under 20 years old, over 20 Bakasheh Nafshis (a soulful request)” .

kol hakavod
February 26, 2011 7:33 pm

thanks

Cancer Sticks
February 26, 2011 7:24 pm

Cigarettes Kill Thanks you for bringing this important issue to the masses. Unfortunately, there is a new wave of young teens that are beginning to smoke because of the “cool” factor. Then they are hooked! The cigarette companies add these additives precisely to addict people to smoking. The young people think that they are invincible and they can stop at any time. Easier said than done. I think all preteens should visit a cancer ward in a local hospital to see the results of smoking. Newsflash! Smoking IS NOT cool. Smoking = Cancer = Death. Living a long healthy life… Read more »

Love
February 26, 2011 7:11 pm

This is amazing

this may help...
February 26, 2011 5:29 pm

theres something called an e-ciggarette its run on batteries and its not full of chemicals its ‘healthier’ and has cartridges with all diff types of tastes and has nicotine free ones aswell its helped many people attack this terrible addiction in a healthier way google it!

"Drinking coke - not a jewish habit"
February 26, 2011 3:28 pm

That’s the headline of the next op-ed coming to town. I mean come on! I can bring you the dangers of doing just about anything enjoyed by many and conclude that oh, its so unhealthy it cant be a jewish habit! Why do you have to come out against smoking which in addition to being a Chasidishe thing to do is also something enjoyed by so many frum jews !? Upset and perplexed.

Yasher Koach
February 26, 2011 2:15 pm

Finally someone dares say something about that plague that is killing hundred and maybe thousand of people around the world every single day..

Nicotine—Pesticide
February 26, 2011 12:52 pm

Actually nicotine was BANNED years ago as a pesticide because it was too dangerous. I had a bottle – the word POISON took up half the label!

X