Create Account
ב"ה
Thursday, 17 Sivan, 5779
  |  June 20, 2019

    Rival Speaks as a Friend

    Guess who is singing the praises of Lubavitch? Chief Rabbi of Moscow Pinchas Goldschmidt, a rival of Chabad Rabbi Berel Lazar. Full Story

    Mesivta to hold Open House

    Next Story »

    Russia: Library Staying Here

    19
    Opinions and Comments

    To keep track of your comments, follow a conversation or flag a comment Login
    avatar
      Subscribe  
    newest oldest most voted
    Notify of
    no choice
    Guest
    no choice

    riskin is openly pro chabad
    goldshmit would stand no chance to say anything but in front of such an audience

    ELUL
    Guest
    ELUL

    There is a tone to this article which is not quite right. Since this is a public forum, the Torah way would be to either give praise that is really praise or to omit the article altogether.

    You obviously do not know R. Goldshmidt
    Guest
    You obviously do not know R. Goldshmidt

    He is not a soina Chabad, he just does not get along with R. Lazar

    chief rabbi?
    Guest
    chief rabbi?

    H’s NOT the chief Rabbi of Russia! he just THINKS he is!
    There is a HUGE difference people! i would like to know which idiot told collive that he was the chief rabbi? Berel Lazar has been Russia’s chief rabbi for nearly twenty years!

    Only this? How about ....
    Guest
    Only this? How about ....

    BTW he has like 5 Chabadniks working for him. No where is he on record ever speaking against Chabad. Lazar did to him a lot more avlos than he ever did to Lazar and/or Chabad. He also took this same group in St Petersburg to the prison that the Baal Hatanya sat in.

    to # 4
    Guest
    to # 4

    He has been in Russia just as long as Rabbi Lazar. As a bochur I was stuck in Moscow in 1991 and stayed by him.

    As for the Chief Rabbi thing, Russia actually recognizes both of them as Chief Rabbis (for the last 20 years), so halt zach ayn in di ramen.

    to #4
    Guest
    to #4

    Mr. it does not say that he’s the chief rabbi of russia.
    What it does say is that he’s the chief rabbi of Moscow. big difference.

    Corrections from an ex Moskvich
    Guest
    Corrections from an ex Moskvich

    a) Goldschmidt claims only to be chief rabbi of Moscow. the phoney chief rabbi is Shayevich, who is a leftover from the USSR and is not qualified. b) He and his daughter have written inflammatory articles about Chabad and he IS on record as having made statements against Chabad. He is also an official of the very anti Chabad Conference of European Rabbis which now has been surpassed by Rabbi Garelik’s organization and does little for anyone. His shul used to sell unzerer cholov Yisroel with the Chabad stickers removed. c)Goldschmidt purposely hires Lubavitchers who do not get along with… Read more »

    to 4 an 5
    Guest
    to 4 an 5

    firstly, he’s the chief rabbi of moscow, which rabbi lazar isn’t. secondly, there was an article from his daughter printed in yeshiva university student paper calling for rabbis to vet all chabad rabbis to make sure they arent apiorsim ch”v. thats something she probably heard at home

    The nasy article by Estee Goldschmidt
    Guest
    The nasy article by Estee Goldschmidt
    for your info-for the record, history
    Guest
    for your info-for the record, history

    the issue Pinchas Goldschmidt hade is NOT with Lubavitch, fyi his wifes family were early supporters of Bris Avrohom. Berel Lazar used Pinchas Goldschmidt as a skapegoat to advance his political agenda and created a fight with Pinchas Goldschmidt, if not for Berel Lazar starting a fight with Pinchas Goldschmidt he would have been a great friend of Lubavitch.
    for #6 Berel Lazar was elected chief rabbi of Russia in June 2000 and Pinchas Goldschmidt hade the title of Chief Rabbi of MOSCOW in the early 1990’s

    Rabbi Goldschmid is a Ehrliche Yid and a Big Talmid Chochom
    Guest
    Rabbi Goldschmid is a Ehrliche Yid and a Big Talmid Chochom

    I know Rabbi Goldschmid personally, he is a Big Talmid Chochom, a Ehrliche Yid, a person who helps everyone, and AFAIK he has never said a bad word about Chabad, but Chabad has said plenty against him. He wrote a book called “Zikaron BaSeifer” which has Teshuvos about how to do specific Halachic procedures in Russia and Lubavitchers use it. There are quite a few Chabad Mosdos which are officially aligned with him and not with Or Avner (such as Chabad in Kazakhstan).

    ....
    Guest
    ....

    to number 5 rabbi lazar did not do anything to him….
    to number 6 makes sence but lazar is doing much more and is more active!

    As a  young man he was never a soina of Chabad
    Guest
    As a young man he was never a soina of Chabad

    He used to occasionally daaven in a Beth Chabad as bochur

    I love you Rabbi Kot
    Guest
    I love you Rabbi Kot

    The Rebbes Shluchim are amazing

    Let us not forget!!!
    Guest
    Let us not forget!!!

    Don’t forget how Rabbi Avrohom Berkowitz, (now former) Executive Director of the Federation of Jewish Communities of the CIS, was attacked inside Goldschmidt’s mikvah and was almost killed:
    http://bit.ly/cED8lt

    raivule???!?....?1/.
    Guest
    raivule???!?....?1/.

    forumer rievull

    well liked
    Guest
    well liked

    I was in the room when these pictures were taken and spent two weeks on a cruise where Rabbi Goldshmidt was invited as the guest Rabbi. He actually spoke highly about Chabad. I found him to be very informed on all issues that he discussed, a very pleasant individual
    Sincerely
    Mrs. H. Hayward

    HOW CAN MOSHIACH COME WITH SO MUCH MACHLOKES WITHIN THE FRUM COMMUNITY
    Guest
    HOW CAN MOSHIACH COME WITH SO MUCH MACHLOKES WITHIN THE FRUM COMMUNITY

    Rabbi Berel Lazars father was an amazing Pirchei Agudah leader and head councellor of Camp Agudah, High Mount NY.
    Rabbi Lazar ad his father have worked for the Klal all their lives and only want to help bring Moshiach in our generation by being Mekarev thousands upon thousands of Yeeden. So put the nonsense and rivalry in the trash can. Whatever we can do to have the Russian Hiarchy help us to achieve this ultimate goal and merit the coming of Moshiach IY’H.

    X