ב"ה
Saturday, 10 Nisan, 5780
  |  April 4, 2020

Picture of the Day

Eli Blachman of Crown Heights holds granddaughter Luba Zarchi and what he claims to be the world's tallest lulav, at the Kotel. Photo

Melbourne Young Yeshiva Join BBQ

Next Story »

Thousands at Birchas Kohanim

9
Opinions and Comments

To keep track of your comments, follow a conversation or flag a comment Login
avatar
  Subscribe  
newest oldest most voted
Notify of
Don't understand
Guest
Don't understand

There is absolutely no point in a tall lulav

Nice!!
Guest
Nice!!

This is really cool!

This might not be any Hidur, but it is definitely really cool!

There’s books and museums on the biggest / smallest / fastest etc. things in the world, there’s no real point except that lots of people are interested in these types of things.

One thing is for sure, there is a point, and a BIG point in not being negative for no reason!!!

Brocha in a sukah
Guest
Brocha in a sukah

How can you bentch on such a lulov in a sukah – the top of lulov will poke thru schach?

To #1
Guest
To #1

Tall lulavs are really cool.
Your right , there is no point but its cool so why not post!

To #3
Guest
To #3

If most of lulov is in sukah it is considered as if you bentched lulov in the sukah (just as if most of person’s body is in sukah it is considered that he is in sukah). So if the top 49% sticks out through the schach it is ok to bentch on it in the sukah.

You need head in sukah!
Guest
You need head in sukah!

If most of person INCLUDING his HEAD is inside sukah – THEN it is considered as if he is in the sukah, but NOT if head is outside of sukah! If head of lulov is outside, you aren’t bentching lulov in the sukah!!!

Ask a Rav
Guest
Ask a Rav

But personally, I think it’s ridiculous.

2 QUESTIONS!!
Guest
2 QUESTIONS!!

1) IS SUCH A TALL LULOV EVEN KOSHER ??
2) WHAT ABOUT THE STORY OF THE TALL LULOV FROM WASHINGTON DC ? IS THAT NOT THE TALLEST LULOV IN THE WORLD ?

this is not the tallest lulav in the world
Guest
this is not the tallest lulav in the world

2 QUESTIONS your right it said that he only claimed it was the tallest lulav.The one in Washington is much taller.

P.S did anyone notice this person esrog?????

X