ב"ה
Tuesday, 30 Shevat, 5780
  |  February 25, 2020

Jews Stabbed in Monsey Shul in Bloody Attack

Anti-Jewish horror: A black male wielding a machete stabbed 5 people at Rabbi Rottenburg’s Shul in Monsey on Motzoei Shabbos Chanukah. Update at 6:00 am: Ramapo Police report a suspect is in custody. Full Story, Video

Chanukah Boats Light S. Antonio River

Next Story »

Threatening Man in 770 Arrested by NYPD

102
Opinions and Comments

To keep track of your comments, follow a conversation or flag a comment Login
avatar
  Subscribe  
newest oldest most voted
Notify of
Hashem yishmar
Guest
Hashem yishmar

What’s happening already??? enough is enough MOSHIACH NOW!!

tehillim
Guest
tehillim

please post names for refuah shleima

Names to say tehillim for.
Guest
Names to say tehillim for.

Yosef ben Perel
Chaim ben Vittel
Naftali Tzvi ben Gila

Names to say tehillim for.
Guest
Names to say tehillim for.

Also
Shlomo ben Vittel
Meir Yosef ben Vittel

Jews protect yourself.
Guest
Jews protect yourself.

People start carrying guns . It’s your right. Don’t be victims. Armed guard for every shul and school. Demand it from federal government.

...except it's not.
Guest
...except it's not.

I also say we must advocate for jews or at least some in every shul and Yeshiva to carry, but in new York it is NOT our right.

It is our right, even in NY
Guest
It is our right, even in NY

The constitution guarantees it. The government is breaking the law by infringing this right.

Constitution
Guest
Constitution

You are absolutely correct. Sadly though Jewish liberals are the most interested in taking away those rights

Time to stand up ...
Guest
Time to stand up ...

It most certainly IS your right. The Second Amendment to the Constitution guarantees it. Stop electing Democrats!

Dumb 2nd Amenders
Guest
Dumb 2nd Amenders

If this guy was a true idiot Republican (gun lover), there would have been 15 dead, not wounded

false!!!!!!
Guest
false!!!!!!

these criminals clearly don’t care about the law, how ironic.. he tried to kill people which shows that nothing will stay in his way, so the reason why he had a machete was NOT because the law doesn’t allow guns, We have to protect ourselves with guns so we could stop the guy immediately! Did you ever hear of people stopping terrorist in Israel trough throwing chair and tables at them? No, we just stop terrorist faster shooting at them before their stab our brothers! Criminals don’t care about any law! They can get guns if they Want! All gun… Read more »

More guns!
Guest
More guns!

Give rifles to everybody, yeeeeaah. If this guy had a gun there would have been 15 dead, my maniac 2nd amendment lover.

Greater caution
Guest
Greater caution

Or maybe the guy would think twice before firing, if he sees a number of people who also have guns.

Ms. Elana Nazari
Guest
Ms. Elana Nazari

X

The 2nd Amendment
Guest
The 2nd Amendment

Yes it is

Wrong.
Guest
Wrong.

Look it up. New York state has permitles carry for long arms. If you are over 18 you can walk into a store and buy a rifle (after a federal background check). Now in regards to small arms, (pistols) in new York state, you can buy one at 21. Carrying may be a little more difficult.

Every shul should buy one and keep it in a safe and easily accessible place. It’s a matter of walking in to any gun store. Learn your Rights

Wrong
Guest
Wrong

Not in the 5 boros. Here even long guns need a permit

Lock it up
Guest
Lock it up

Yea that makes total sense, buy a gun and keep it locked up, because you will have ample time to sneak over and unlock the safe in the middle of an attack. Every shul needs shomrim with guns, period.

Not gonna happen buddy not in blue NYS
Guest
Not gonna happen buddy not in blue NYS

The harshest anti-gun laws in the nation.

Some many other ways
Guest
Some many other ways

WHEN WILL THE JEWS LEARN TO TAKE SOMETHING TO DEFEND THEMSELVES? for years I’ve been yelling… take a class, take a fork, a steak knife, a concealed gun, mace, hair spray, wasp spray… Something… Jews must carry WHATEVER! Learn to fight, take Krav Maga and defend themselves… no more excuses for a world that hates us. We must change our mental ways of thinking… we have been through this from time and memorial… Enough is enough! Wake up JEWS! In Minneapolis or in New York, in the Orthodox Jewish community, people must take back the streets as Americans, against the… Read more »

Trained dogs
Guest
Trained dogs

Security dogs will protect you.

Wasp spray
Guest
Wasp spray

It works great

So what good would it do in NY
Guest
So what good would it do in NY

When the incident was in NJ!

MONSEY????
Guest
MONSEY????

Is in new York. Very close to NJ, but in NY.

Firearms training and carry permits now!
Guest
Firearms training and carry permits now!

Never again.

Agree
Guest
Agree

This contagion is spreading rapidly. It starts with the Jews but doesn’t end there. This mania spreads and in the end it is genocide. The LGBT community has a self defense organization called the Pink Pistols. The NRA assists this group. The right of self defense is a fundamental, God given human right. I urge all who as disturbed as I am about this to get trained, obtain a Concealed Weapons Permit and carry to defend yourself, your family, your friends and your community. These terrorist are cowards. They only attack soft targets. The Jewish community should never be a… Read more »

Shliach
Guest
Shliach

I have been asking members of the boards of local crown heights girls and boys schools why they don’t have armed guards, the excuse they gave was that “they don’t have funding for it”! Can you imagine? Really? They have funding to serve the kids chicken, and go on year end trips and paint the walls, but no funding for what is important???? Where are the priorities???? Do we need another school building with another gym? Another brochure or another international campaign? What is wrong with these people? Why do we allow these self appointed board members make decisions for… Read more »

Yes
Guest
Yes

Agreed.

Forget the armed guards
Guest
Forget the armed guards

Just make the shuls more like fortresses with a tower and spotlights at the top. Arm the guards there with machine guns and simply kill anyone within a 5 meter radius from the building.

Only long term solution
Guest
Only long term solution

Guns and security are the short term solution. The long term solution is increasing the awareness and observance of the 7 Universal Laws and a Moment of Silence in the public schools.

Heaven
Guest
Heaven

Ha ha we banned guns here via the Dems.

They Won't
Guest
They Won't

I grew up in Monsey, as a Reformed/Conservative Jew, many years ago. The Hassidic will not carry weapons on Shabbat, or probably not ever, Our religion teaches non-violence. The best they could do, but will face religious argument, is to post armed, pre-paid, Shabbos Goy around every neighborhood. It’s a large area. I’m not even sure if it’s possible.

Terrorist attack inMonsey
Guest
Terrorist attack inMonsey

What is wrong with ALL the Jewish communities…You need armed guards. We are living in difficult times..Sephardi Shuls have had armed guards for a few years now…Wake up our Ashkenazi Brother and sisters..

Care to sponsor that?
Guest
Care to sponsor that?

Gotta be practical my friend.

No armed guards
Guest
No armed guards

No! We need G-d’s protection and until we do teshuva and stop the lashon hara snd increase the ahavas israel big time, we aren’t going to merit His protection!

Fake news
Guest
Fake news

Yes!

Not Really
Guest
Not Really

Sounds beautiful and we should do as you say but until that happens we need to take matters In our own hands and protect ourselves just like the Jewish Resistance in nazi German occupied Europe. Thats what G-D would want from us. Tons of episodes in the Torah where we protected ourselves.

Responsibility for attacks
Guest
Responsibility for attacks

The Lubavitcher Rebbe asserted that All Jews are innately good and do not deserve to be attacked!!
He is correct!!
The attackers are Evil rashas (rodefs)
Rav Mier Kahane organized the JDL to patrol dangerous areas.

Do our part
Guest
Do our part

Ever heard of histadlus? You are in a dream world, how many more attacks do you need to see on Jews before you realize that WE have to do our part.

you need to do your part
Guest
you need to do your part

in order to receive g-ds help, you must do your part first.

I used to daven there, they have people who carry
Guest
I used to daven there, they have people who carry

I used to daven at that Shul and lived next to a guy who carried a pistol to every minyan. Likely the assault happened too fast.

Names
Guest
Names

Yosef ben Perel
Chaim ben vittel
Naftula tzvi ben gila

Names to say tehillim for.
Guest
Names to say tehillim for.

Yosef ben Perel
Chaim ben Vittel
Naftali tzvi ben Gila

MOSHIACH NOW
Guest
MOSHIACH NOW

oh my goodness. hashem we need moshiach

Duh
Guest
Duh

and in the interim, anything to be done?

We shouldn't have to take this anymore
Guest
We shouldn't have to take this anymore

only one that will protect us (with Hashem) is ourselves – no lipservice by an incompetant mayor will help.

Spiritual War
Guest
Spiritual War

This is a spiritual war. HaShem allowed this to happen because we are divided as a nation. We need to do teshuva, stop speaking lashon hara about each other, and increase the ahavas israel big tome and quick if we want Him to protect us!

Don't worry
Guest
Don't worry

Don’t worry ny is very safe because you can’t carry a gun.
And the police will increase patrols so we are fine.

a sincere question
Guest
a sincere question

Wait, is this *another* stabbing in Monsey, NY? One Jewish man was stabbed in Monsey on November 20, 2019. I don’t know if people are getting mixed up, or if there really were two separate incidents.

Are you a confused person?
Guest
Are you a confused person?

Or just trying to spread fake news. Yes there were more than 2 incidents since November.

Start following the Torah
Guest
Start following the Torah

We have seen proof after proof of our blood spilled in the streets, shuls, schools, and homes. The Torah says if law violates the Torah don’t follow it. NY State violates the Constitutional right to use guns the Torah says if someone comes to kill you or do harm end their life first use no restraint. It’s not done for joy or want it’s done for survival. I don’t care about color or creed they come to kill or hurt us stop being passive sheep in a field being open season with a lazy shepherd

Protect ourselves
Guest
Protect ourselves

Every Jew needs to wear a gun like they wear Tzizis!
We must protect ourselves before the next …..
Wake up and smell the coffee ! anti-Semitism is growing and growing faster and faster .

Come to Israel
Guest
Come to Israel

It is a sign to come to Israel.

Firearms training and carry permits now!
Guest
Firearms training and carry permits now!

Never again!

Firearms training and carry permits now!
Guest
Firearms training and carry permits now!

Never again!
We all need to train in firearms and Sue for carry permits. Now.

Gotta add martual arts to.....
Guest
Gotta add martual arts to.....

All cheder yeshiva kollel and seminary class’s. Gotta get every adult a gun permit, gotta hold monthly meetings at the range. When faced with the prospect of war Avrahm Avinu first prayed to G-d readied himself for war, and stood at the gate of beersheva to pursue peace. Its the way of our fathers it should be our way too.

Thank "D Black CEO" for all this.
Guest
Thank "D Black CEO" for all this.

Thank D Black CEO for all this.

They should never have let that dog into 770 the other day, he has blood on his hands and would do the same as dickins did, get our knives and guns ready and fight back hard, we have plenty of bochurim who know just what to do, we just need “D black CEO” and all the liberal judges in NY to treat us with the same slap on the wrist as they do when the dog’s bite us.

we need to get gun permites for shuls!!
Guest
we need to get gun permites for shuls!!

what are we waiting for? a worse attack c”v? we need to wake up our leaders to demand guns and armed securety for our shuls! it’s pikuach nefesh! more then saying tehilim – the hungeryan jews in the holocaust should have relized

Oy Vey
Guest
Oy Vey

I’m also going to assume the perpetrator is a Christian.

I would assume it's a crazy man
Guest
I would assume it's a crazy man

Of no particular religion

Time to get ready
Guest
Time to get ready

The perpetrator is an antissemit and it does not matter if he is Christian, Budist, Atheist, Islamic.
It is also not important black.or white, tall or short.
He has to be caught and punished. And we must be able to defend ourselves.
It is about time to become string and fight.
The Macabim did it. Bar Cochba did it. Dvorá did it.
Let us follow their example.

No Christian would do this
Guest
No Christian would do this

No Christian who truly loves HaShem would ever do this horror. True Christian Believers, like evangelicals are Israel’s and Jewish peoples’ greatest friends. I love HaShem and His children and Israel. Sha’alu Shalom Yerushalayim.

Emet4us
Guest
Emet4us

But why did he use a machete? That is telling isn’t it?

religion?
Guest
religion?

hate is hate i don’t care if he’s a Christian he attacked innocent Jews in a home/synagogue he should be tortured and thrown away for life

Bc religious contempt
Guest
Bc religious contempt

is totally different when you do it.

we need to get gun permites for shuls!!
Guest
we need to get gun permites for shuls!!

we must get armed! -more then saying tehilim!

we need to get gun permites for shuls!!
Guest
we need to get gun permites for shuls!!

!

We'll...
Guest
We'll...

You don’t need one! Look it up. You don’t need a permit to buy a rifle or shotgun in new York state. And a non carrying permit for a pistol is easy to get.
Yes. It’s true. Your 18 year son or daughter can walk into a gun dealer in nys and buy an ar15 (modified to nys standards). These are the facts.

You're right
Guest
You're right

In counties outside of NYC. In the city it is basically impossible, but upstate and long island it is doable.

Enough Already😡
Guest
Enough Already😡

JDL….it is time resurrect yourself!

It's time
Guest
It's time

We need a race war to settle our differences. This tension must erupt once and for all

Berel
Guest
Berel

this is not okay
a majority of black goyim are as okay as any other goy
if they weren’t, then we couldn’t live in CH for a second like we can’t live in gaza
there is no need for a ‘race’ war
our job is to point out evil and of course not to be naive to evil that does exist within the black culture, but you are dangerously off of your rocker

The US is imploding from political correctness
Guest
The US is imploding from political correctness

It’s not only the Jews that are suffering, if you keep up with the news, just that they are seen as easier victims. Until this country can look truth in the eye and notice who commits 90% of the crimes, there will be no change.

Every Jew a 22
Guest
Every Jew a 22

Every Jew a 22

Pepper spray and krav maga
Guest
Pepper spray and krav maga

Al tismoch al hanes

Pepper spray and krav maga
Guest
Pepper spray and krav maga

At the very least.

Next time you see a Mike Bloomberg ad...
Guest
Next time you see a Mike Bloomberg ad...

demanding the disarmament of law-abiding citizens, while Black Israelite or Muslim butchers can get whatever they need to attack Jews — think of this.

Ma Rabbi
Guest
Ma Rabbi

When these perps are caught by our bochurim or shomrim instead of just handing them over to the police they should first beat them senseless then call the police to take them away.

Exactly
Guest
Exactly

I don’t understand how the guy who came into 770 the other day was able to get out. They should have taken him into a corner with no security cameras and rearranged his face.

Bring "CHAPTZEM" back!!!
Guest
Bring "CHAPTZEM" back!!!

Bring “CHAPTZEM” back!!!

We need spiritual and physical weapons
Guest
We need spiritual and physical weapons

We must arm ourselves immediately with love and respect for each other , lots of judgments are brought for baseless hatred , lashon haro and condescension. Also we need to get basic training and purchase of firearms to defend ourselves and we need to VOTE and make our voice to be heard .

Rav Mier Kahane and the JDL
Guest
Rav Mier Kahane and the JDL

Reestablish the JDL of Rav Kahane to patrol!
We Jews must take responsibility for our own safety !!!

Heshy
Guest
Heshy

Does days are over. Today with all the security cameras u can’t defend yourself or u also get arrested. One solution Dump all democrats.

Rav Mier Kahane and the JDL
Guest
Rav Mier Kahane and the JDL

We need the JDL to patrol!!

Think about it.
Guest
Think about it.

Just like it happened in butiful poway… Pittsburgh… it will happen in monsey, and it did! So where next? Chas vesholom in some beautiful shul somewhere? Or who knows where. Act now and let’s protect ourselves and not wait until…. (I’m not going to mention..).

Tayere Brider Ketz Sam lachoshech

Monsey
Guest
Monsey

I live in Monsey. Absolutely loved loved loved living here.
Am now seriously considering moving away. Just a matter of time. I’m out.

Heshy
Guest
Heshy

Where you moving to Brooklyn.

You're quite dumb
Guest
You're quite dumb

Where you gonna move to????
CROWN HIGHTS??? POWAY??? PITTSBURGH????You get what I mean right?
I’d still consider Monsey safer than most others places.

Menachem
Guest
Menachem

https://www.jdn.co.il/j_world/1251881/

jdn. Hebrew article.
Dov Hikend saying as it should be said. Please watch. Stop the BS already.

Heshy
Guest
Heshy

Upstate which is out of nyc limits it is a drop easier to get a gun license. What you wed is at least two people with guns in a big shul. What’s most amazing is that this is the second vicious attack in monsey where you don’t expect an attacker to drive to I doing their crime. They could easily find a closer shul near their area. This is a message from Above. It’s not a natural attack. It’s difficult to get a pistol license these days but a rifle should be far easier. Even mace could of stopped this… Read more »

Part of Upstate you got KKK
Guest
Part of Upstate you got KKK

There’s a lot of white anti-Semitism in certain areas of upstate New York.
I have been to places where people hide they are Jews they are that scared.

Such sad times
Guest
Such sad times

So sad that these crazy people are out there prayers fir the victim’s and their family’s, Just goes to show you these politicians that wanna take our guns are off their rockers, if someone in this get together had a concealed weapon they mite could have ended this idiots life before he hurts others.

Time to take action!
Guest
Time to take action!

Sheva mitzvot cards need to be given out by every one of us!

Meanwhile, in the spiritual realm....
Guest
Meanwhile, in the spiritual realm....

The eternal fight between GOOD and EVIL rages on….EVIL seems to be winning these days because he has successfully adopted the age old technique of “Divide and Conquer”. He has managed to pit the Muslims against Jews and Christians and vice versa. The Whites against Blacks and Browns and vice versa. The Democrats against Republicans and vice versa. The Orthodox Religious against the Non Believers and vice versa….. EVIL, like the magician that he is, has tricked us into focusing on the insignificant differences between us, like race, religion, economic social class, geographic location….and now he has us fighting HIS… Read more »

Heshy
Guest
Heshy

I wonder if this stabbed was the same guy who did the stabbing a month ago in monsey. Police should look into that where he was that morning and also check his Facebook or online rantings. Maybe he used to work in monsey and got radicalized by the black Israelite gang. Anyway he will be out of jail January first as they are releasing all the prisoners other than murderers,rapists and men who had a domestic dispute with their wives. This is liberal democracy at its best.

Black Anti-Semitism
Guest
Black Anti-Semitism

Why do we liberal media sources only report the race of the perp in a suspected bias attack when the perp is white and not black ? I have seen the headlines “White cop shoots black male, white man shoots unarmed black male” but I have not seen “Black male attacks another Jew” After the Jersey city attacks on the Jewish deli by two black “Hebrew Israelites”, video on another website showed African-Americans blaming the Jewish victims for the problems they brought to the Jersey city neighborhood. Farrakhan and the black Hebrew Israelite “temples” preach the hate that manifests itself… Read more »

scared
Guest
scared

a “homeless” man drove a car? where did he get the money from?????if hes mentally ill he should be in a hospital, not on the streets.

WOW
Guest
WOW

scary….

White Supremacy
Guest
White Supremacy

Obviously the attacker was a white supremacist Trump voter! Keep voting Dem, Jews! They will protect you!

Obviously you didn’t read
Guest
Obviously you didn’t read

Article says it was a BLACK man.

CBS HAD story for one night.....
Guest
CBS HAD story for one night.....

CBS New York’s Tony Aiello reports at least five people been taken to area hospitals with injuries….

They dropped the story much faster than it took the black chaya raoh to enter the shull…

Please get, on you own volition, to spread this story out to any ask all connections, don’t hold back anything or anyone, you never know who can forward it to the right nerve….

X