ב"ה
Tuesday, 23 Tishri, 5780
  |  October 22, 2019

Jewish Man Violently Assaulted

Just in: a group of teenage black males violently assaulted a 19-year-old Jewish man on Motzoei Shabbos in Crown Heights. Full Story

Mr. Efraim Steinmetz, OBM

Next Story »

Live Shiur on Mezuzah Controversy

47
Opinions and Comments

To keep track of your comments, follow a conversation or flag a comment Login
avatar
  Subscribe  
newest oldest most voted
Notify of
Enough!
Guest
Enough!

Have we not learned from our brother In Eretz yisroel,that silence is not the appropriate response? How many more attacks do we c” v need ,until there is real action taken . The word gets around really fast ” you can r”l beat up Jews,and no one does anything.

Could you imagine if it were the other way around?
Guest
Could you imagine if it were the other way around?

Could you imagine if groups of Jews were violently attacking blacks in Crown Heights for no reason other than to commit a hate crime?! The filthy anti-Semitic rag newspapers NY Daily News & NY Post would have it on the front cover each time!! And BBC & fake news CNN would be running the story nonstop. And the race baiter Al Sharpton would be out having a news conference on the corner near 770, inciting people to act against the Jews. But when Jews are attacked Rachmana Litzlan nobody cares. Someone should compile a list of all the violent hate… Read more »

Drc
Guest
Drc

The city shohld make subsidised surveillance cameras available . How is the victim?

Increíble
Guest
Increíble

Happens again and again and our representatives do nothing , they keep quiet not to upset their friends, the politicians, and our Jewish community pays the price.Its about time for us to realize that they don’t care about us and they only care about themselves and their friends.WE NEED ELECTIONS URGENT and elect decent members of our community

To #2
Guest
To #2

You are right! I think for every such attack we should respond in kind. Throngs of Jew’s should start randomly attacking blacks until those rats learn it works both ways!!! We just need to sometimes use the ידים ידי עשו!!!

Moshe
Guest
Moshe

If you see something say something call shmira 718-221-0303

another night another asault
Guest
another night another asault

when will we learn every jew a 22. I prefer a 44 it leaves a better commemoration.

NYC
Guest
NYC

Crazy NY who don’t care about their people.

Yossel Fried
Guest
Yossel Fried

Kan TZEEVA HASHEM ES HABRACHA

You Democrats will get no where
Guest
You Democrats will get no where

You need guns to defend your self the police are useless they didnt help you in pitsburg and they didnt help you tonight you need to protect yourselves from such evil hate crimes this is just like in russia and germany we were led to the slaughter because we let the government take our rights frim us guns dont just get up snd kill the same way cars dont just kill thousands of people a year you cant blame it on the gun it is your right to own one so go protect yourself. I dont want to be the… Read more »

Shocking
Guest
Shocking

But….you can have elections all you want… EVERY YID HAS TO GO & VOTE
Enough excuses …
otherwise nothing changes…

Outsider.
Guest
Outsider.

Needs:
CCTV
Frum, caring politicians in the area
Bikur Cholim for victims
A list of all attacks to be hand given to the head CNN or BBC office by a chossid.
Moshiach now!

What you won't hear in the news
Guest
What you won't hear in the news

The secret reality is that blacks are about 3 times more likely to be anti semitic than the general population. Unfortunately the news decides what’s relevant, what’s news, and what’s reality.

Like someone above said “if it was the other way around…” then they would decide that this happened and how terrible it was, despite it being a rare incident. But when it’s this way, it never happened and it’s not so relevant despite it unfortunately being pretty common.

JDL. N3ver Again
Guest
JDL. N3ver Again

Perhapss it is time for a rejuvenated JDL

Mrs
Guest
Mrs

Wihat is good for the goose is good for the gander. Why no surveillance cameras about?
There should be some kind of surveillance about.

To number 4
Guest
To number 4

I agree, but first we need better discussion and motivation in the neighborhood that when we have elections, people are actually registered and go out to vote. If we voted as a block and had EVERYONE eligible vote, we’d be in a much better political situation IMO.

We need Berel sugar
Guest
We need Berel sugar

We need another protest like we had back in the day organized by berel sugar, that’s the only language the cops understand and are scared of. The last thing they need is the media involved doesnt look good for them

Our community needs to gather together and do invite TV and all
Guest
Our community needs to gather together and do invite TV and all

Politicians and police and etc … enough is enough…
we are good to go to L”G baOmer parade so we are good to go and do meeting … it’s impossible and scary to raise kids and let them go around , crime and hate are in each corner …

ENOUGH IS ENOUGH!!!!
Guest
ENOUGH IS ENOUGH!!!!

WHERE ARE OUR COMMUNITY LEADERS WE VOTED FOR??!!

Chabad CH member
Guest
Chabad CH member

Crown heights Shmira is not what it used to be. They have a bunch of young guys running around who don’t know what’s going on. And they also have very few people in Shmira. It’s sad. A while back they had plenty of big healthy people involved.

I agree with #16
Guest
I agree with #16

But until SOMEONE here organizes a serious voter registration drive – including absentee ballots for the hundreds of buchurim & girls that study / live out of Crown Heights nothing will change We still have not learned from Willy, Boro Park, Monroe etc that numbers of votes = real power. Until we finally figure that out and actually register everyone and vote as a community we are going in circles .

to #5
Guest
to #5

The Rebbe said that is not the Jewish reaction.

what's needed
Guest
what's needed

Time to do teshuva. There needs to be more achdus. There needs to be less machlokes. There also needs to be more police present and better justice system – the would-be perpetrators should have fear of the government , innocent people should not have fear of criminal behavior.

Mike
Guest
Mike

you are so right I’ve been saying that so many times that someone should put together all these type of crimes and make an issue exactly what you’re saying And not is just The crimes they should go around Sundays by all the churches where the cars are triple parked parked on sidewalks and asked why do they get different treatment the problem is who do you think is going to do it the people who like to have photo ops.

How does the bocher feel
Guest
How does the bocher feel

I hope he has a easy recovery.

moshe
Guest
moshe

To # 19 Eating in restaurants or taking pictures

Velvel
Guest
Velvel

To # 14 A couple of guys who have black belt know how to fight should walk the streets in when you have the subs asking you want to fight they should show them a thing or two

To #7
Guest
To #7

You do realize that the tyrannical powers that be don’t allow individuals the inalienable right to keep and BEAR arms for self defense.

Sad as this is, are you saying Jews should become felons?

absolutely correct
Guest
absolutely correct

dont tell us what what WE should do..i.e. cameras etc..lets get police to put the fear of G-d into these chayos..We must make a geshrei and surround the police station with protests! its their job to protect us..we cant even walk; our streets again..C”V like the ’70’s??

to #5
Guest
to #5

With a kind one, You show Yourself kind, with a sincere man, You show Yourself sincere.
With a pure one, You show Yourself pure, but with a crooked one, You deal crookedly. Israel is respected and feared not because it takes its Complaints to the UN but because it FIGHTS BACK.

More cameras
Guest
More cameras

There needs to be cameras everywhere. It’s a deterrent.

Menachem mendel
Guest
Menachem mendel

First off Moshiach Now, Everyone report to Jury duty and make sure to convict every criminal , pack heat like the saying goes every Jew a 22 .

Hello
Guest
Hello

The only reliable long term approach is implementing the Rebbe’s call for a moment of silence in the public schools, and increasing the awareness and observance of the Sheva mitzvos.

We don't need more PHOTO OPTS
Guest
We don't need more PHOTO OPTS

We need real action from our community leaders NOT MORE PHOTO OPTS !

#22 haters will always be haters
Guest
#22 haters will always be haters

Haters will always be haters
Shmira gets things done

Shmira
Guest
Shmira

Shmira does amazing work I see almost every night in there marked vehicles patrolling sometimes I even saw 3-4 am
It’s good to go home at night knowing there are guys members that are married who have families leaving wife and kids to go do good for our our community 22 you should be ashamed of your self

Alert!
Guest
Alert!

Loshen Hora is in itself harmful to all parties involved.

There are all sorts of readers, of all ages, and not everyone reacts the same way or with the same ease or the same strength.

Be considerate of others and their differences, including those who practice Halachic standards.

Demonstrate you know why Loshen Hora is wrong in the first place, please.

Brooklyn yid
Guest
Brooklyn yid

There are things that need to be done to make crown heights safer. My question to all of you is are the yuppies getting attacked. I would assume they do. What you need to do with shmuel is get dogs. Dogs are a good deterrent to crime. Talking about guns is not realistic because to get a gun license in nyc is very difficult. I know because I have licensed guns for over 20 years. Crown heights is improving. Not so long ago you did not see a white face on the black side of the park. Now when you… Read more »

To # 10
Guest
To # 10

You are wrong- the police did help in Pittsburgh and stopped the evil perpetrator from going to the next shul on his list, BH

To 21 and Anyone Else
Guest
To 21 and Anyone Else

Serious crowdsourcing here—who in the neighborhood has the conacts and reach to start organizing voter drives? No need to post names publicly, but seriously give it some thought. Discuss this at shul during kiddush and over shabbos. I will be doing the same. Once we have movement on this, we can worry about The Who/what/and when of voting cohesively.

for everytime the word should has been used
Guest
for everytime the word should has been used

looking through the comments the word should has been used a lot. Someone should …. they should …..
its easy to be an armchair warrior, stop whining and go do something. If this is not your thing go do some chessed.

Api TEVAH...
Guest
Api TEVAH...

Achdus, yes! Tefilla & Chesed, yes! Increasing Voter Registration, yes! But I am buying PEPPER SPRAY for my family members IMMEDIATELY! Better SAFE than sorry, Hashem y’racheim!!!😕 (P.S. they sell it in Sunshine Pharmacy)

#1 is correct
Guest
#1 is correct

Silence equals acquiescence. We need local volunteer groups to patrol, catch and capture and put the fear in these animals. That is, and has always been, the only way.

to #31
Guest
to #31

theres only 1 deterrent. next time catch these criminals and hang em. it wont happen again

How is the bochur
Guest
How is the bochur

How is the Bochur now? Refua shelaima.

to #44
Guest
to #44

the kind of reckless behavior you are advocating only exacerbates problems, leaving cooler heads to figure out how to get hotheads out of the trouble they get themselves in to. having said that i do agree that local politicians are quickly realizing that not only do we have no “bite”, we don’t even do enough “barking.” shame on every one of anash who is legally able to vote and doesn’t bother, or doesn’t even bother to register to vote because they’re afraid it might activate a call to jury duty or something. you can’t have it both ways. you want… Read more »

Out of State Jew
Guest
Out of State Jew

This pains me to see my brethren being mistreated. I am a Black Jew. That’s why this pains me. My ancestors dealt with this during the Civil Rights movement. Yes you are right what if the shoe was on ther other foot? You would have who’s who in the political zoo there. I can’t tell you what to do but if you will allow me to make a suggestion It’s okay to defend yourself. That’s what the Maccabaees did. That’s what we did in Israel during the six days war. We defended ourselves and HaShem was with us. Yes do… Read more »

X