ב"ה
Sunday, 21 Tishri, 5780
  |  October 20, 2019

Full List of Poland’s Donors

Cunin, Gurarie, Jacobson, Kramer, Plotkin, Rivkin, Schmerling, Shmotkin and Zalmanov are among the names recorded in the "Golden Book" as donors to Yeshiva Tomchei Temimim in Poland, COLlive was told. Full Story

Dealing With Rebellious Teens

Next Story »

Joy at the Mayanot Shul

12
Opinions and Comments

To keep track of your comments, follow a conversation or flag a comment Login
avatar
  Subscribe  
newest oldest most voted
Notify of
plotkin?
Guest
plotkin?

as in the plotkins from montreal?

wow! This is AMAZINGLY INTERESTING!!!
Guest
wow! This is AMAZINGLY INTERESTING!!!
Who owns these?
Guest
Who owns these?

BH

Who do these seforim belong to? Why are they being auctioned? And why is the Aguch Library not buying them?

What’s going on here?

Moshiach Now!

Where is the list?
Guest
Where is the list?

Ca we see a copy of the list of donor online?

To Number 1
Guest
To Number 1

It is the Plotkin family from CH….Harav avraham Eliyahu Plotkin.

to number 3
Guest
to number 3

Aguch library, per directive from the Rebbe, does not buy seforim, period end of discussion! if a chossid feels that such a thing belongs in the library and wants to make a nachas ruach to the Rebbe and buy it and give it to the library, he will earn that zechus, but the library does not buy such things. That’s what’s going on here.

Likkutei Torah 1st Print!!!!
Guest
Likkutei Torah 1st Print!!!!

Seemingly the Tanya, and especially the Likkutei Torah 1st print should be more valuable than the “Golden Book”…

wasn’t this the print of Likkutei Torah that the Tzemach Tzedek said was the beginning of the coming of Moshiach… at least one of the Keitzim. (in HaYom Yom?) and he infact funded it?

meir bat ayin
Guest
meir bat ayin

no 6 is correct. these piece might have been part of OUR library. a legal stop should be put on the pubic sale until chabad gets clairifaction.

People! time to grow up
Guest
People! time to grow up

We live in a free world, not communist russia. These seforim don’t “belong” to lubavitch

First, the Tanya and Likkutei Torah are regular printed books. Does every book Kehos printed belong to Kehos and forbidden from being passed around?

Second, the golden book could have been given as a present to one of the donors or talmidim and their children decided to sell it for whatever reason.

Yes, Chabad seforim belong in the Chabad libary. But its not a natural process and cannot be forced upon people. As comment #6 writes, If you really care go and buy it for the libary.

plotkin????
Guest
plotkin????

didnt chezky rosenfeld just get engaged to a plotkin? must be a choshuve family…..

chocolate lover
Guest
chocolate lover

I loved Schmerling chocolates and cheeses even without knowing this information.

WOW 1799 Tanya!
Guest
WOW 1799 Tanya!

Wish I could afford that $10G Tanya…The cost of a basic Tummy-Tuck:)

X