ב"ה
Wednesday, 18 Elul, 5779
  |  September 18, 2019

Carrying Weapons on Shabbos

Question for the rabbi: When are Jewish security personnel allowed carry weapons on Shabbos? Full Story

The Rebbe, Right Before Shabbos

Next Story »

Motzei Shabbos: Change The Clock

5
Opinions and Comments

To keep track of your comments, follow a conversation or flag a comment Login
avatar
  Subscribe  
newest oldest most voted
Notify of
With an Eruv???
Guest
With an Eruv???

What about in a place with an Eruv? I guess I do not want to know unless it is not a problem since most of “carry” on shabbos.

re question 1
Guest
re question 1

It would be nice to be able to get some follow up on questions in general. This question in particular there is huge difference between muktzah and hotzaah. So please reply to question 1. Another thing, there is also a sevara to say that general people’s non-fear can be wishful thinking, or a non-comprehension of what is at hand too. (We saw lots of that in pre-WWII–especially in Hungary) If there has been a fire bombing let us say, to a shul in a city or similar in an anti Semitic attack. The police may tell you it is a… Read more »

I asked
Guest
I asked

I carry every day, and was told to no, even with an eruv.
You have to ask your own rav.

#3 to
Guest
#3 to

Where go you live? In Israel?

Netzach
Guest
Netzach

when i was in netzach aka (idf) i carried my M-4 on shabbos.

X