By anonymous
Social media, like any medium, has been a force for good since it has become a daily communication tool in the Chabad and many other Jewish communities in the U.S., Israel and elsewhere.
Facebook, What’s App, and email have helped people to share inspiration and ideas, announce programs and important communal information, encourage people to donate in Charidy campaigns, etc.
There is also the other stuff that are shared around like a trail of goo: Donald Trump clips, daily scenes at 770, funny animal photos, clips of terror scenes, insightful and silly sayings.
And then there is the “need to know stuff.”
The last category is anything we share in the hallowed mission of “transparency.” That can be documents of the latest quarrel in an institution, a degrading photo or rumors about a community member, the passionate arguments in the name of ‘everything that is holy’.
Here’s the tricky thing about transparency: It’s only really transparent when it comes from a totally unbiased source. You want to work on transparency, by all means, please do (we can use more of it).
If you start yelling “transparency” when you find yourself in a disagreement, you’re just a fraud masking your loshon hara while using bully tactics. Airing your own dirty laundry is not transparency and “fighting for justice.” It’s just airing your dirty laundry.
“But people have to know!” you will say.
No, they don’t.
Transparency never meant notifying the entire world about every disagreement and problem you are having. Disagreements are a part of life, they happen everywhere and they will happen with individuals and organizations. Even our greatest leaders are capable of disagreeing and are all human.
Your mission in this world wasn’t to C-Span Lubavitch or be the watchdog of Crown Heights, or Kfar Chabad, or London, or Russia. You are not the government and we are not your citizens. We’ll survive without your round-the-clock coverage of machlokes.
“But what about a miscarriage of justice?”
Well, justice is defined by Torah, not by your side of a fight. Those that circulate disagreements are not doing it to promote transparency or justice. They are doing it to shame the other side of their conflict into acquiescing to their demands, or simply out of boredom (it’s not clear what’s worse…).
“But who will shed the light on the corruption of our leaders and Rabbonim if not me?”
Do us a favor; if you’re involved in a disagreement, please let it be anyone but you. You aren’t shedding light on anything, you’re just being destructive to our community to make yourself feel better or fulfill your agenda.
I’m not here to tell you to go to Rabbonim or listen to a Beis Din when you find yourself at odds with someone. People have been politicking for centuries. It’s America, you ultimately will do whatever you want.
Just would you please leave our communities, our spouses and our children out of your machlokes? Every 16-year-old Yeshiva bochur is up to date on every disagreement. That is the biggest Chillul Hashem to our own children and communities.
If you came that much, quit your job, open your own organization, switch to a different shul, send the kids to a different camp, and start listening to another Rov. Just leave the rest of us out of it. Stop pretending that you are doing us the favor by sharing your loshon hara.
And to those that are sharing, stop being pawns of other people’s games. Loshon Hara isn’t only the responsibility of the speaker and listener, but also of the sharer and forwarder…
Well done! Great post!
It bothers me so much to see parents posting negative things about their own children’s administration or teachers. What message does this send your children, that its ok to Virtually tantrum? Why not take the.opportunity to show your kids how to have conflict resolution? And if all else fails change schools or home school.
1. I believe this article was more about issues that are’nt effecting YOU greatly.
2. I believe the author clearly stated that you can work on transparency, but a subjective view of a situation, isn’t important information
Thank you for the article.
Thank you as well to the Rabbonim Askanim and Shluchim, that stayed above the temptation of airing dirty laundry even while people tried to throw mud at you.
written with inspiration. Thank you!!
Sir, with all due respect, I for one am speaking for myself and I do not agree with this article. The author assumes he is speaking for all of us but that is just not so. Yes, we need to know what happens in our mosdos. The days of secret deals behind closed doors are over. Sure there is plenty of stuff that goes on and we (the public) don’t know, but what’s wrong to be in the know when major decisions are being made that will affect us greatly. You can’t expect us all to behave like ostriches. People… Read more »
I quit facebook because of that, I now really sensor who I allow myself to connect with.
I really hope all of the self appointed “community askanim”read this. Thank you for writing this.
What?
Teens can read it too; it applies to them just as much!
Teens with social media need to learn the same leson as adults with social media do!
And if a teen was already reading and article on COL (and, for your information, children as young as 7 years old read articles on COL), what would the point of your comment be?
But to the article, I completely agree.
Thank you!
This is a big issue amongst shluchim as much as with CH, lately even more. I dont need to tell you about the emails and whatsapps coming to crown heights from families of “wronged” shluchim. There were women literally whatsapping people not to give tzedakkah. Please just sign your name ” concerned lubavitcher”. This is a problem that unites us all.
I think both critical articles and feedback comments can be extremely damaging. We are learning the etiquette and propriety of a new world; an immediate, connected world. Careful thoughtfulness, cautious introspection is lost to pushing that send button quickly. There may be times to rally the community against an injustice, or raise the banner of a good cause, but usually kvetching online while you are aggravated and biased is not the most productive way to effect meaningful change. So after all that, do I now ‘share’ this article, or not?
It’s about time this was said.
100 percent
a shliach with kids in the CH moisdois
In past generation, stories and gossip was spread in the mikveh. Now it is on-line. Except, in mikveh it was spread to a dozen people or so (who each spread it to a dozen more etc), while on-line it is spread to hundreds, and each spreads it to hundreds more.
I wish ALL websites follow COL in this approach,, to publicize ONLY non-machlokess and harmless news.
Beautiful … some articles written like that got no comments hours later , I was impressed
Our cheder is in desperate need of teachers. I put a status on facebook that we needed teachers. I didn’t say the administration was incompetent. I didn’t talk about the quality of the teachers we have now. I was told it wasn’t my place to put that on facebook. Yet, the administration goes on facebook to find teachers. If used properly, social media is an excellent tool for getting a job done.
I think the issue is much broader. I think people have severe phone addiction and they cannot let go of the phone, even if to dealing with the most precious one like the kids .
I’m not excluded. My kids come home about 430 and go to bed about 8 o’clock. I realize (after a while) that half of that time I’m on my phone (usually on social media).
I made a rule with myself. When the kids come home until they go to sleep, unless it’s urgent, I don’t touch my phone.
What a breath of fresh air! How true this article is unfortunately!
If even one person less will not post one of these ‘stories’ that its referring to here, it will have been worth it, couldn’t have said it better myself! Enough!
Brilliant article!
How very well said!!!
I do not do Facebook or ANY social media.
Unfortunately, human nature being what it is, if you go into a perfume store it is highly unlikely you will come out not smelling of perfume. The yezter hara being what it is, sucks you into places on social media that you may wonder how you got there.
If you don’t want to get burned, don’t play with matches.
I couldn’t agree with you more.
BTW, if you are a teen, why are you reading this stuff anyway? There are more enjoyable things in life than reading everything on line.