ื‘"ื”
Friday, 13 Sivan, 5780
  |  June 5, 2020

Live:

Are the Frum Allowed to Smile

From the COLlive inbox: A Shliach recently asked a donor why he stopped giving. The answer surprised him, but not me. Full Story

Different Goals at Maccabi Games

Next Story »

Festival Brings Saratoga Together

32
Opinions and Comments

To keep track of your comments, follow a conversation or flag a comment Login
avatar
  Subscribe  
newest oldest most voted
Notify of
wow
Guest
wow

thank you

Beautiful
Guest
Beautiful

Thank you. Well put. ๐Ÿ™‚

Beautiful!
Guest
Beautiful!

Thanks or sharing! I will keep this in mind!

A Chabad BT
Guest
A Chabad BT

Obviously there is a time and place for everything (smiles included) BUT where does it say in Halacha to smile.

The Torah is supposed to dictate our thoughts, speech and actions according to time and place not pop culture, not celebrities and definitely not ourselves.

rabbi moishe y engel  shliach-long beach,calif.
Guest
rabbi moishe y engel shliach-long beach,calif.

i would like to say yasher koach to the lady who wrote this article. She knows the score and is 100% right.A smile ,a gut vort and a friendly disposition are one of the most powerful assets(weapons) we have. Notice the response you elicit with a pleasant countenance. You have won half the battle before you even begin.This is what we always saw by our Rebbe;He had a kind word and a pleasant smile for everyone. I once heard from a prominent Chosid, Reb Moishe Rubin a”h az dos vos men ken nit oiftuhn mit gutens vet men mit shlechtens… Read more ยป

Question
Guest
Question

When you smile at someone passing who you can see that is Jewish ( The way they dress) majority of the time you get a stoney face back Why? what does it cost to smile back!!!!

PLEASE when you meet a fellow Jew in passing, smile and hopefully they will smile back.

very true
Guest
very true

please translate into hebrew

To a Chabad BT
Guest
To a Chabad BT

It says it in pirkei Avos “Hevei mekabel es kol ho’odon besever ponim yofos”

To #4
Guest
To #4

It says in Pirkei Avos to greet everyone with a “pleasant countenance”. I can’t think of a better way to accomplish this than by smiling!

:) !
Guest
:) !

๐Ÿ˜‰ !

Well said!

To Chabad bt
Guest
To Chabad bt

In pirkei avos it says hevei mekabel es kol Adam besver panim yafos.

Also, the fifth chelek of shulchan aruch is full of instances when your obligated to smile….

It's a chiyuv gamur TO SMILE!!!
Guest
It's a chiyuv gamur TO SMILE!!!

If you would study Gemoro you would know it says son in Gemoro Kesuvois daf 112 b
ื“ืืžืจ ืจ’ ื™ื•ื—ื ืŸ ื˜ื•ื‘ ื”ืžืœื‘ื™ืŸ ืฉื™ื ื™ื ืœื—ื‘ื™ืจื• ื™ื•ืชืจ ืžืžืฉืงื”ื• ื—ืœื‘ ืฉื ืืžืจ ื•ืœื‘ืŸ ืฉื ื™ื ืžื—ืœื‘ ืืœ ืชืงืจื™ ืœื‘ืŸ ืฉื™ื ื™ื ืืœื ืœื‘ื•ืŸ ืฉื™ื ื™ื
Which means smile and show your teeth!

Excellent article
Guest
Excellent article

i sometimes wonder about people who are afraid to smile. it may ruin their perceived persona.

As an aside, the writer is obviously a member in good standing of the NY Chabad community. She writes “For Shabbos lunch, we had been sent to eat by a Chabad family.” The correct word is ‘at’ rather than ‘by’ which has crept into our English language from the Yiddish word ‘by’ which means ‘at! And yes, this caused me to smile!

KV”T to all.

Ari
Guest
Ari

How are you a slave to modern culture? I don’t think anybody owns you.

How right you are
Guest
How right you are

Greet everyone with a cheery countenance.

This was posted on a board, outside a local orthodox shaul, many years before I became observant. But it went into my heart.

Today, my children ask me why some frum stare so blankly, look so angry, or are really cold. People are people, with many problems. But if you are dressed in the uniform, you have to play the part. It’s such a turnoff. We were in Central Park, chol amoed Passover, so any families kana hora, noses up, cold stares.

Wow,
What a sight.

to #4
Guest
to #4

We just learned it in the parsha, “…serve the L-rd your G-d with joy and gladness of heart.” Smiling is a great way to accomplish it, but not the only way. I remember Rabbi Marlow Z”L, who was not a big smiler, but he was always good-natured in his quiet way, and at times had a gentle humorous quip to deliver along with his psak when he was asked a shayla. Not all of us can walk around smiling all the time — it may not be our nature. The art of serving Hashem with simcha, and letting the world… Read more ยป

#4????
Guest
#4????

What?! What messed up form of judaism were you taught?

Good point
Guest
Good point

As R’ Manis freidman relates: “Why are you so unhappy??” “Oh, I’m frum.”

#17
Guest
#17

What are attacking him for? He asked a question and got a number of answers. No need to be so negative. The Torah IS supposed to dictate our thoughts, speech and actions according to time and place. And the Torah tells us to serve Hashem with joy and greet everyone with a smile.

Chaya
Guest
Chaya

My uncle lives in Manhattan. 30 years ago he didn’t want to register his daughter in C.H. The reason: Never a smile on a face. I don’t want my daughter to learn with unhappy people.

#4 cont.
Guest
#4 cont.

I live in a community in LA where people are “phony”…a smile and a handshake means very little.

We learned from the Rebbe the value and impotance of a good word or a friendly facial expression AND we also learned the importance of acting in accordance with halacha…

Saying hi to someone while the minyan is saying/answering to kaddish is not holy…

Laughing and giggling before davening is also in the same category…

Our generation’s connection to halacha is crucial for the generations to follow.

to Rabbi Engell #5
Guest
to Rabbi Engell #5

In case anyone doesn’t know him, Rabbi Moshe Engel is the epitome of warmth and love, he has a big smile and loving manner for everyone. A true chossid.

Great message!
Guest
Great message!

Thanks

to # 20
Guest
to # 20

Being BeSimcha does not have to be a contradiction to adhering to Halacha. In my opinion, the only way to bring more people back to Yiddishkiet, including “kids at risk” is if everything is done with Simcha!!! Simcha enhances a mitzvah!! If you want Yiddishkiet to stay with your family forever, start finding good ways to be BeSimcha!! If someone is violating Halacha, it could be done in other ways, like giving a dirty look to someone during Kaddish. Why do you seem to have a general problem with Simcha?

Cows don't smile
Guest
Cows don't smile

Here is a thought: Have you ever seen a cow smile?

What does it tell you?

Be a mentch and not a behaymah.

wonderful
Guest
wonderful

๐Ÿ™‚
:~}
:-))
so many beautiful smiles.
#18, I could actually hear “R’ Manis freidman relate: “Why are you so unhappy??” “Oh, I’m frum.”
That is so him, and it made me smail real big. Thanks
IVDU ES HASHEM B’SIMCHA!

Beautiful!
Guest
Beautiful!

Thank you dear writer for putting your thoughts on paper. It was quite encouraging to hear your personal spiritual journey and the inspiring lesson you took out of it.

Be well, and never stop inspiring people!

oops
Guest
oops

I wrote comment 24. It was supposed to be for #21 not #20
sorry!

In response to 24
Guest
In response to 24

Understood.

The bottom line is that simcha, like everything else is based on time and place.

Shaking a lulav on Shabbos during Chanukah is not a mitzvah, it is the opposite.

My comments attempt to bring on one point: no matter what the mitzvah is, even smiling , we have to remember “when” and “where”

to 29
Guest
to 29

Again, being internally happy can be done always. Violating Halacha in which ever way is wrong.

Mitzvah Gedolah Le’hious Besimcha Tomid !

Beautiful!
Guest
Beautiful!

Thank you!

live in CH
Guest
live in CH

cant figure out if its CH culture; bad upbringing or another reason; some of our youth grow up and become Shluchim, and they have to be warm and friendly to their congregants in order to be successful, yet while here in CH people dont smile and they dont say Good Shabbos; in fact sometimes they see you but avoid eye contact as they pass by so they wont have to trouble themselves dont get me wrong I have a good self esteem and these people dont mean enough to make a diference to my life but it is none the… Read more ยป

X